Wiki Vandalism Reports

[TheRustyOne]

User Apotheosis69 made massive changes to Monkey D Luffy's profile without any permission to my knowledge.

I've undone the changes and I believe that both Luffy's and Sanji's profiles should both be locked once again.

@Apotheosis69

Did you receive permission to make such drastic altercations to the profile?

If you did, you should be linking where you received this permission when you make such edits to avoid any confusion.

Note: I don't believe this should be considered vandalism, I just don't know where else to post this.

 

[Antvasima]

Almost all of those changes seem to have been self-evident structural improvement cleanup work, with the possible exception of changing the Japanese names for power techniques into English localisations.

 

[TheRustyOne]

Almost all of those changes seem to have been self-evident structural improvement cleanup work, with the possible exception of changing the Japanese names for power techniques into English localisations.

Than the changes can be brought back, assuming they don't change the Japanese naming scheme on the profile.

I dislike the idea of making such a radical change to the profile without getting the opinions of a verse's knowledgeable members.

I don't believe any of this was vandalism, as I said I just don't know where else to put this.

 

[Vietthai96]

Hmm, most of the change is adding Kanji for Character and Abilities name, and change Romaji of some power, techniques in abilities' justification into English, and some minor changes in the placement of abilities in P&A section. Well none of this is bad but yeah i think he should at least discuss this with the verse supporters, though i appreciate his efforts to make thing look better and more informative, well it is up to staffs to decide then

 

[Antvasima]

I think that it mostly seems harmless, but the localised names in English should preferably be asked about in the main One Piece discussion thread before they are applied.

https://vsbattles.com/threads/one-piece-general-discussion-elbaph.115795/

 

[Apotheosis69]

Almost all of those changes seem to have been self-evident structural improvement cleanup work, with the possible exception of changing the Japanese names for power techniques into English localisations.

Everything here. I put English localizations because the Majority of people in media aren't aware of Japanese romanized names of the techniques, let alone Utilize them in conversations, ofc here being the exception but its for the outside audience that wants. Plus it gives consistency to the general consensus of Anime character's technique's names.

I also don't usually think asking the verse supporters for Those kinds of changes are needed, cus well no statistical changes are made in any sense. That and to me it doesn't give it an authentic cause, though I'm certain most of you all will completely disagree on that part. To which I can understand.

Than the changes can be brought back, assuming they don't change the Japanese naming scheme on the profile.

May I ask what are you referring to for "Japanese naming scheme"? For specification.

 

[Antvasima]

Well, I personally agree with you, but it still seems best if you receive approval from our One Piece community for the changes from Japanese to English terms before they are applied.

The rest of the changes seemed beneficial and uncontroversial.

 

[Apotheosis69]

So can Those specific changes be applied then?