• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
All logical possibilities.
Embodiment of all logical possibilities and impossibilities something like that.
I know the definition, I just dont understand how a character can achieve that.

Like @ExcelsisBerny said the voyagers can be High 1-A+, but I dont know how they can reach that level from what I rember of the works, though there is prob big things in Rewrite for the cosmology anyway
 
I know the definition, I just dont understand how a character can achieve that.

Like @ExcelsisBerny said the voyagers can be High 1-A+, but I dont know how they can reach that level from what I rember of the works, though there is prob big things in Rewrite for the cosmology anyway
I don't want to guess anymore so just wait Berny answer by himself, otherwise, we will know when the CRT comes out with tier 0 Creator
 
I might be mistaken, but I think it’s because fundamentally both Lambda and Bern are themselves the manifestations of the concepts of perseverance and miracles, with said concepts applying to both the Human and Witch’ domains, effectively transcending it. Don’t quote me though.
 
I don't want to guess anymore so just wait Berny answer by himself, otherwise, we will know when the CRT comes out with tier 0 Creator
Actually there no High 1-A+ or Tier 0 in Umineko, the verse does not meet the requirements for these levels.
Also, there no "Creator", but "Creators" like Featherine.
 
I might be mistaken, but I think it’s because fundamentally both Lambda and Bern are themselves the manifestations of the concepts of perseverance and miracles, with said concepts applying to both the Human and Witch’ domains, effectively transcending it. Don’t quote me though.
Simply transcending such structures is not High 1-A+, Umineko unfortunately does not have any High 1-A+, since there would be contradictions about that, unless the High Outerversal+ in question was tf Featherine.
 
Actually there no High 1-A+ or Tier 0 in Umineko, the verse does not meet the requirements for these levels.
Also, there no "Creator", but "Creators" like Featherine.
Featherine isn't a Creator (there is long explanation here in previous page and Creator profile)
Japanese has no plural so plural and singular in english translation is based on the context.
and actually, there is none of character who is a Creator (Maria isn't yet, it's just her potential)

Also, there is an exception for that
Q: Can there be multiple Tier 0 characters in the same verse?

A:
This might seem like a strange question to note down, seeing as I've already established that there can only be one Tier 0 being per verse under these proposals. However, it is worth to note down a distinction between "being" and "character." The latter term refers to narrative presentation and characterization, and the former refers to in-universe ontology.

What I mean is: There may be occasions where two characters or more are presented and characterized separately in terms of the plot and narrative, but are in fact of a single essence/existence as per the verse's cosmology. If their individual characterizations are sufficiently notable, then it might be that they deserve individual profiles, even if ultimately they are the same being.
 
Last edited:
Featherine isn't a Creator
Japanese has no plural and singular so plural and singular in english translation is based on the context.
and acutally, there is none character who become a Creator (Maria isn't yet, it's just her potential)

Also, there is a exception for that
She is a creator, his true form resids in the Last Domain as the strongest 07th Expansion Character, is sayed in certain guides than Featherine is a Creator, and is sayed in the VN and than she reached the Last Domain and have becomed a Creator.
The plural exists in Japanese, but it works completely differently from Western languages, since context, a numerator, etc. are needed to know when something is plural.
I recommend reading this text that explains the plural in Japanese and all the confusion surrounding "The Creator." The idea of "The Creator" as a standalone character is simply the result of translation errors in the manga and visual novel.
 
She is a creator, his true form resids in the Last Domain as the strongest 07th Expansion Character, is sayed in certain guides than Featherine is a Creator, and is sayed in the VN than she reached the Last Domain and have becomed a Creator.
I recommend you to find the explanation of it here because we discuss about this before
The plural exists in Japanese, but it works completely differently from Western languages, since context, a numerator, etc. are needed to know when something is plural.
I recommend reading this text that explains the plural in Japanese and all the confusion surrounding "The Creator." The idea of "The Creator" as a standalone character is simply the result of translation errors in the manga and visual novel.
Yeah, I said that it is based on the context
Creator is the position/the state of being so if Creator is oneness, multiple Creator as a character isn't an anti-feat against that according to QA above.
 
I recommend you to find the explanation of it here because we discuss about this before

Yeah, I said that it is based on the context
Creator is the position/the state of being so if Creator is oneness, multiple Creator as a character isn't an anti-feat against that according to QA above.
Actually no, "Creators" are the Witch than reached the Last Domain, is not a entiry, nature force or something like that, is literally a title.
Also there the fact than one Creator can be strongest than others, which is a contradiction if the Creators are Tier 0.
Unfortunately there no Tier High 1-A+ or Tier 0 in Umineko, all possible arguments for this are translation errors or misinterpretations.
 
Actually no, "Creators" are the Witch than reached the Last Domain, is not a entiry, nature force or something like that, is literally a title.
Also there the fact than one Creator can be strongest than others, which is a contradiction if the Creators are Tier 0.
Unfortunately there no Tier High 1-A+ or Tier 0 in Umineko, all possible arguments for this are translation errors or misinterpretations.
I am fairly sure we debunked these notions in this very thread back when Ovy was more often online.

TLDR: Creator is singular and 0 via Last Note of the Golden Witch clarifying it.

I myself was arguing for High 1-A+ Aurora via her being the great flame that supports the entire hierarchy below the Creator, but that’s up in the air, obviously.
 
Actually no, "Creators" are the Witch than reached the Last Domain, is not a entiry, nature force or something like that, is literally a title.
Creator is the existence that created everything in the verse. It makes no sense if Creator isn't a primordial existence, otherwise, Lambda lied about this.
Also there the fact than one Creator can be strongest than others, which is a contradiction if the Creators are Tier 0.
That context doesn't describe how powerful they are.
 
Creator is the existence that created everything in the verse. It makes no sense if Creator isn't a primordial existence, otherwise, Lambda lied about this.

That context doesn't describe how powerful they are.
She not lied, Lambdadelta literraly sayed than the Creators are the Witches than reached the Last Domain.
I don't understand the other thing than you sayed.
 
She not lied, Lambdadelta literraly sayed than the Creators are the Witches than reached the Last Domain.
(1) Everything was created and fated by Creator
(2) There is no Creator in the first place because a witch reached and became it later.

I don't understand the other thing than you sayed.
It's about her potential and destined to be a Creator compared to other witches.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I just remembered. We actually accepted that CRT regarding Creator this very year. Damn, that was a long year, huh.
 
Eh it is also said various time that she only reached the Creator domain and then come back, and Lambda memoir state that anyone reach Creator will lost all restriction and vanish, which Featherine obviously still exist

And in Last Note, Peace said Featherine upon touching Creator Realm, realize this is not a place for people with purpose then she returned.

So maybe Ryukishi does plan for Creator Witch being a type of Witch, but later reveal kind of go against that notion and point to Creator being a state of being or a force rather than a character or a title
 
Last edited:
O Criador é a existência que criou tudo no verso. Não faz sentido se o Criador não for uma existência primordial; caso contrário, Lambda mentiu sobre isso.

Esse contexto não descreve o quão poderosos eles são.
Ela não mentiu, Lambdadelta lite
O Criador é a existência que criou tudo no verso. Não faz sentido se o Criador não for uma existência primordial; caso contrário, Lambda mentiu sobre isso.

Esse contexto não descreve o quão poderosos eles são.
Disseram que os Criadores são as Bruxas que alcançaram o Último Domínio.
(1) Everything was created and fated by Creator
(2) There is no Creator in the first place because a witch reached and became it later.


It's about her potential and destined to be a Creator compared to other witches.
1: The Creators are nothing more than representations of the screenwriters; they "shape destiny" precisely because they can write the plot of their own stories (after all, Umineko is nothing more than a story by FAA, one of the creators).
2: Maria being the one with the most potential supports my point; she has enough potential not only to reach but also to surpass Creators like Featherine.
How could a Tier 0 be stronger than the other?
 
It's 2025 and people still think that the Creator is a title and not a being. This shit got debunked like years ago man.
The only evidence for this is literally a mistranslation of Umineko.
Featherine was literally described as the author (Ryukishi07) inserting himself into his work as the strongest character, and is also referred to as a Creator in the Character Slot of The Golden Witch.
 
Eh it is also said various time that she only reached the Creator domain and then come back, and Lambda memoir state that anyone reach Creator will lost all restriction and vanish, which Featherine obviously still exist

And in Last Note, Peace said Featherine upon touching Creator Realm, realize this is not a place for people with purpose then she returned.

So maybe Ryukishi does plan for Creator Witch being a type of Witch, but later reveal kind of go against that notion and point to Creator being a state of being or a force rather than a character or a title
The Featherine we see in the visual novel is literally an avatar, and her self-imposed limitation is a reference to Tohya Hachijo's amnesia.
Featherine has been referred to as a Creator and as the strongest character in Umineko.
 

That’s not related to power whatsoever. I don’t even know why you’re using that statement at all.

When it’s said that Maria could become the "greatest creator", it’s only referring to the fact that, since she’s a little girl with autism, she keeps her heart pure and will never lose her creativity, which basically means she’ll never get bored.

"Screenwriters" in-verse are Lords of territory, as I explained in my blog about canonicity in the section about Beako.


Creators are a nothingness devoid of any property / limitations. The concept of "strength" or "power" is completely irrelevant.
 
I literraly barelly know how to use this website.
Just reply to the message you want to reply to

then after you type everything you want to them, reply to the next person BEFORE you hit send and it will keep it all in one message like this:


The Featherine we see in the visual novel is literally an avatar, and her self-imposed limitation is a reference to Tohya Hachijo's amnesia.
Featherine has been referred to as a Creator and as the strongest character in Umineko.
hi

hi

The only evidence for this is literally a mistranslation of Umineko.
Featherine was literally described as the author (Ryukishi07) inserting himself into his work as the strongest character, and is also referred to as a Creator in the Character Slot of The Golden Witch.
hi

See, all in one message.
 
That’s not related to power whatsoever. I don’t even know why you’re using that statement at all.

When it’s said that Maria could become the "greatest creator", it’s only referring to the fact that, since she’s a little girl with autism, she keeps her heart pure and will never lose her creativity, which basically means she’ll never get bored.

"Screenwriters" in-verse are Lords of territory, as I explained in my blog about canonicity in the section about Beako.


Creators are a nothingness devoid of any property / limitations. The concept of "strength" or "power" is completely irrelevant.
1: My argument would still work, what exactly would be the logic of Tier 0 (Omnipotent) beings feeling boredom and the like? An Omnipotent being is not capable of feeling such things.

2: Territory lords are representations of story protagonists, Battler himself and the Cats Overlords are examples of this.

Yes, Creators are "transcendental voids," which I didn't deny, but this doesn't negate anything I said; they are still representations of writers. And literally, Ryukishi explains that Creators are writers:
Question 3: そもそもフェザリーズとは、どういう存 在なのでしょう? A 『Ep6』のTipsで、フェザリーヌ が「生き死にを繰り返している」とあったのは、 フェザリーヌ自身が駒だった頃、自分たちも 誰かにライティングされている登場人物であ るという事実を知り、自由意志と信じて疑 わなかったことが、誰かにライティングされ ている物だと気づいたために死んじゃったん ですよね。でも彼女は、自らもライターとな って帰ってきた。 そして恥も外聞もなく、自 分の作品の中に自分を描くことで真の自由 意志を得た。彼女は今、リレーマンガのよ うな世界にいるのかもしれないですね。自 分のキャラは自分で書くけど、それ以外は 複数のライターが書いているような世界に 存在しているのかもしれません。 Question 4: 航海者が造物主になるのを恐れるとい うのは、そのあたりに由来するのでしょうか? A: そうですね。 マンガって読んで いるときは面白いけど、いずれ読み飽きち ゃう。でも白いノートを与えられて自分で書いていれば無限に遊べるので、マンガを読 むより遙かに面白いかもしれない。ただし、 自分のアイデアが枯渇したり、描く行為に 飽きたら終わりますよね。しかも自分(作者) の望まないような展開やキャラクターは生ま れてこない。造物主というのは何でも生み 出せるが故につまらない生き物ですよ。 Question 5: ------ 他人が作った面白い話を読めなくなる んですね。 A: 造物主でないほうが、TVの前 に座っていればどんどん物語を見ることが できるのと同じで楽なんですよ。人間は、 自分が誰かの作品の登場人物であることす ら自覚しておらず、自由意志によって行動 していると信じているので、一番気楽な存 在です。 一方でベルンやラムダたちは、チャンネ ルを自由に変えたり、ときどきシナリオライ ターに注文をつけて、話に介入できる階層。 ただし介入すると物語が変わってしまうの で、その事実はギリギリまで知らないふりを している。 フェザリーヌは、そこに踏み込ん で死んでしまったんでしょう。 白紙のノート に妄想するのは楽しいけど、そこにずっと話 を書き続けるのはかなりしんどいので、魔 女は死んでしまうわけですね。魔女というの は、「自分たちは、誰かの創作物じゃないか」 ということに気づき始めていて、なおかつ 異なる創作物を閲覧できる立場にいる者で、 上に行けば行くほど執筆者の立場に近づい ていき、本当に執筆者の域まで到達すると 終わってしまう。真里亞が「原初の魔女」と 呼ばれた理由は、飽きることなく、ゼロから ドンドンとアイデアや世界を膨らませていけ るからなんです。
Translation:
Question 3: What kind of existence is Featherine anyway?
A: In the tips of Ep6, it was said that Featherine "constantly repeats a cycle of life and death." When Featherine herself was a piece, she realized that she was a character being written by someone, and what she had believed to be free will was being written by someone else. That's why she died. But she came back as a writer herself and found true free will by drawing herself in her own work, without shame or embarrassment. She may now be in a world of relay manga. She may exist in a world where she writes her own characters, but other characters are written by several writers.
Fear of the Voyagers becoming a creator, and why Maria is the promised witch to being the strongest creator

Question 4: Is that where the Voyager's fear of becoming a Creator comes from?
A: That's right. Manga is interesting when you read it, but eventually, you get tired of reading it. But if you are given a blank notebook and write in it yourself, you can play with it endlessly, which is much more interesting than reading manga. However, if you run out of ideas or get bored with the act of drawing, it's over. Moreover, you (the artist) will not be able to create characters or developments that you do not want. A Creator is a boring creature because they can create anything they want.
Question 5: ---You won't be able to read interesting stories made by others
A: It's easier to not be a creator, just like it's easier to sit in front of the TV and watch more and more stories. Humans are the most comfortable because they don't even know they are characters in someone else's work, and they believe they are acting of their own free will. On the other hand, Bern, Lambda, and the rest of the hierarchy can intervene in the story by changing the channel at will and occasionally giving orders to the scenario writer. However, they pretend not to know this fact until the very last minute, because it would change the story. I think that's what killed Featherine. It's fun to fantasize in a blank notebook, but it's very hard to keep writing stories in it, so the witch dies. Witches are those who have begun to realize that they are someone else's creation, and they are in a position to view different creations. The reason why Maria was called "the Witch of Origins" is because she can expand her ideas and world from scratch without ever getting bored.

Ryukishi's main idea with the Creators is that they are representations of the screenwriters; the screenwriters are supreme beings over what they write, just like the Creators.

And finally, FAA is nothing more than a self-insert of Ryukishii07, acting as the strongest character in his own work (Umineko). Further supporting the idea of Creators=Screenwriters.

Also, the source of the interviews are the Shinsou Kaimei Dokuhon of Episode 8.
 
My argument would still work, what exactly would be the logic of Tier 0 (Omnipotent) beings feeling boredom and the like? An Omnipotent being is not capable of feeling such things.

Maria is not tier 0.

2: Territory lords are representations of story protagonists, Battler himself and the Cats Overlords are examples of this.

Story protagonists and writers. Gamemaster Battler and Gamemaster Beato are the screenwriters of the worlds of the episodes inside the Chessboards. Read the link I sent.


Yes, Creators are "transcendental voids," which I didn't deny, but this doesn't negate anything I said; they are still representations of writers. And literally, Ryukishi explains that Creators are writers:
Question 3: そもそもフェザリーズとは、どういう存 在なのでしょう? A 『Ep6』のTipsで、フェザリーヌ が「生き死にを繰り返している」とあったのは、 フェザリーヌ自身が駒だった頃、自分たちも 誰かにライティングされている登場人物であ るという事実を知り、自由意志と信じて疑 わなかったことが、誰かにライティングされ ている物だと気づいたために死んじゃったん ですよね。でも彼女は、自らもライターとな って帰ってきた。 そして恥も外聞もなく、自 分の作品の中に自分を描くことで真の自由 意志を得た。彼女は今、リレーマンガのよ うな世界にいるのかもしれないですね。自 分のキャラは自分で書くけど、それ以外は 複数のライターが書いているような世界に 存在しているのかもしれません。 Question 4: 航海者が造物主になるのを恐れるとい うのは、そのあたりに由来するのでしょうか? A: そうですね。 マンガって読んで いるときは面白いけど、いずれ読み飽きち ゃう。でも白いノートを与えられて自分で書いていれば無限に遊べるので、マンガを読 むより遙かに面白いかもしれない。ただし、 自分のアイデアが枯渇したり、描く行為に 飽きたら終わりますよね。しかも自分(作者) の望まないような展開やキャラクターは生ま れてこない。造物主というのは何でも生み 出せるが故につまらない生き物ですよ。 Question 5: ------ 他人が作った面白い話を読めなくなる んですね。 A: 造物主でないほうが、TVの前 に座っていればどんどん物語を見ることが できるのと同じで楽なんですよ。人間は、 自分が誰かの作品の登場人物であることす ら自覚しておらず、自由意志によって行動 していると信じているので、一番気楽な存 在です。 一方でベルンやラムダたちは、チャンネ ルを自由に変えたり、ときどきシナリオライ ターに注文をつけて、話に介入できる階層。 ただし介入すると物語が変わってしまうの で、その事実はギリギリまで知らないふりを している。 フェザリーヌは、そこに踏み込ん で死んでしまったんでしょう。 白紙のノート に妄想するのは楽しいけど、そこにずっと話 を書き続けるのはかなりしんどいので、魔 女は死んでしまうわけですね。魔女というの は、「自分たちは、誰かの創作物じゃないか」 ということに気づき始めていて、なおかつ 異なる創作物を閲覧できる立場にいる者で、 上に行けば行くほど執筆者の立場に近づい ていき、本当に執筆者の域まで到達すると 終わってしまう。真里亞が「原初の魔女」と 呼ばれた理由は、飽きることなく、ゼロから ドンドンとアイデアや世界を膨らませていけ るからなんです。
Translation:
Question 3: What kind of existence is Featherine anyway?
A: In the tips of Ep6, it was said that Featherine "constantly repeats a cycle of life and death." When Featherine herself was a piece, she realized that she was a character being written by someone, and what she had believed to be free will was being written by someone else. That's why she died. But she came back as a writer herself and found true free will by drawing herself in her own work, without shame or embarrassment. She may now be in a world of relay manga. She may exist in a world where she writes her own characters, but other characters are written by several writers.
Fear of the Voyagers becoming a creator, and why Maria is the promised witch to being the strongest creator

Question 4: Is that where the Voyager's fear of becoming a Creator comes from?
A: That's right. Manga is interesting when you read it, but eventually, you get tired of reading it. But if you are given a blank notebook and write in it yourself, you can play with it endlessly, which is much more interesting than reading manga. However, if you run out of ideas or get bored with the act of drawing, it's over. Moreover, you (the artist) will not be able to create characters or developments that you do not want. A Creator is a boring creature because they can create anything they want.
Question 5: ---You won't be able to read interesting stories made by others
A: It's easier to not be a creator, just like it's easier to sit in front of the TV and watch more and more stories. Humans are the most comfortable because they don't even know they are characters in someone else's work, and they believe they are acting of their own free will. On the other hand, Bern, Lambda, and the rest of the hierarchy can intervene in the story by changing the channel at will and occasionally giving orders to the scenario writer. However, they pretend not to know this fact until the very last minute, because it would change the story. I think that's what killed Featherine. It's fun to fantasize in a blank notebook, but it's very hard to keep writing stories in it, so the witch dies. Witches are those who have begun to realize that they are someone else's creation, and they are in a position to view different creations. The reason why Maria was called "the Witch of Origins" is because she can expand her ideas and world from scratch without ever getting bored.

WTC fans trying to understand what an analogy is: mission impossible.

If you actually read Last Note of the Golden Witch, you should know that becoming a creator means losing thought and will, which is why Featherine decided to come back after reaching the top, since she’s a writer.

How can a writer without thought or will write something? Having any property attached to what you are is a limitation and Creatorhood is a stated devoid of limitations in an absolute sense.

Ryukishi's main idea with the Creators is that they are representations of the screenwriters; the screenwriters are supreme beings over what they write, just like the Creators.

He never said that. Ryukishi07 and other 07th Expansion members are normal meta beings in-verse.

And finally, FAA is nothing more than a self-insert of Ryukishii07, acting as the strongest character in his own work (Umineko). Further supporting the idea of Creators=Screenwriters.

Ryukishi07 is an actual character inside the verse what. He appears in some meta sections in Higurashi.

Using your own translation:

There's no doubt that Line is close to being the strongest character. At the same time, she's a pretty embarrassing character. She features herself in her own work and writes, "I'm super strong!" (laughs). It's like a fantasy novel in which the author himself is the strongest protagonist.

It’s never stated anywhere that Featherine is Ryukishi07’s self-insert, it’s only talking about how Featherine self-inserted into Beatrice’s story as the strongest character in that world, something any Gamemaster can do.
 
Maria is not tier 0.



Story protagonists and writers. Gamemaster Battler and Gamemaster Beato are the screenwriters of the worlds of the episodes inside the Chessboards. Read the link I sent.




WTC fans trying to understand what an analogy is: mission impossible.

If you actually read Last Note of the Golden Witch, you should know that becoming a creator means losing thought and will, which is why Featherine decided to come back after reaching the top, since she’s a writer.

How can a writer without thought or will write something? Having any property attached to what you are is a limitation and Creatorhood is a stated devoid of limitations in an absolute sense.



He never said that. Ryukishi07 and other 07th Expansion members are normal meta beings in-verse.



Ryukishi07 is an actual character inside the verse what. He appears in some meta sections in Higurashi.

Using your own translation:



It’s never stated anywhere that Featherine is Ryukishi07’s self-insert, it’s only talking about how Featherine self-inserted into Beatrice’s story as the strongest character in that world, something any Gamemaster can do.
1: Yes, and one of the ideas defended here is "The Creator" being a Tier 0 state of existence (unless I've read or interpreted this wrong, since my English isn't very good), a state of existence that Maria can achieve.
2: i don't read Last Note, i just readed the VN and some extra stories.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1: Yes, and one of the ideas defended here is "The Creator" being a Tier 0 state of existence (unless I've read or interpreted this wrong, since my English isn't very good), a state of existence that Maria can achieve.

I don’t see anything wrong with that. You’re creating a non-existent problem. “Boredom” in-verse is just the absence of thought. The text is just saying that Maria as the Witch of Origins is able to create stuff ex nihilo without dissolving because of boredom. That's what means "following the path of a Creator".

2: i don't read Last Note, i just readed the VN and some extra stories.

Figured.

3: no?
"Question 1: Since Featherine has the ability to make what she writes come true, is it feasible to interpret that the entire story of "Ep 08" was written by Featherine?
A: That's one way of thinking about it. She's the closest thing to a god in that world, the author of the world. So there is no doubt that she is the strongest of all the characters. At the same time, it's pretty embarrassing. I'm embarrassed WHEN I PUT MYSELF IN MY WORK and say, "I'm so strong~!" (laughs). It's like a fantasy novel with the author as the strongest protagonist."
Ryukishi literally speaks as if he's talking about himself; he's saying that Featherine is a self-insert of himself.

Lol? Why are you changing your own translation?

This is what you sent earlier

There's no doubt that Line is close to being the strongest character. At the same time, she's a pretty embarrassing character. She features herself in her own work and writes, "I'm super strong!" (laughs). It's like a fantasy novel in which the author himself is the strongest protagonist.

Ryukishi07 is not talking about himself.
 
I don’t see anything wrong with that. You’re creating a non-existent problem. “Boredom” in-verse is just the absence of thought. The text is just saying that Maria as the Witch of Origins is able to create stuff ex nihilo without dissolving because of boredom. That's what means "following the path of a Creator".



Figured.



Lol? Why are you changing your own translation?

This is what you sent earlier



Ryukishi07 is not talking about himself.
Do we have the original text for that interview ??
 
Lol? Why are you changing your own translation?

This is what you sent earlier



Ryukishi07 is not talking about himself.
Actually, i just realized that I used a seemingly incorrect translation, since the translation I used made it seem like Ryukishi07 was talking about himself.
But when I used Google Translate and DeepL to translate the scan, I saw that Ryukishi was talking about Featherine.

About the boredom part: i simply interpret "Boredom" as the boredom of an writer without any creativity to write his stories.

Anyway, my point about "Creators=Screenwriters" still stands, since Ryukishii07 still describes a Witch's journey as the journey to become a writer (Creator):
Raw:
一方でベルンやラムダたちは、チャンネ ルを自由に変えたり、ときどきシナリオライ ターに注文をつけて、話に介入できる階層。 ただし介入すると物語が変わってしまうの で、その事実はギリギリまで知らないふりを している。 フェザリーヌは、そこに踏み込ん で死んでしまったんでしょう。 白紙のノート に妄想するのは楽しいけど、そこにずっと話 を書き続けるのはかなりしんどいので、魔 女は死んでしまうわけですね。魔女というの は、「自分たちは、誰かの創作物じゃないか」 ということに気づき始めていて、なおかつ 異なる創作物を閲覧できる立場にいる者で、 上に行けば行くほど執筆者の立場に近づい ていき、本当に執筆者の域まで到達すると 終わってしまう。真里亞が「原初の魔女」と 呼ばれた理由は、飽きることなく、ゼロから ドンドンとアイデアや世界を膨らませていけ るからなんです。
Google Translate:
This is the level where you can give orders to the texter and intervene in the story. However, intervening changes the story, so you pretend not to know this fact until the very last moment. Featherine stepped into this and died. It's fun to fantasize on a blank notebook, but it's extremely tiring to keep writing stories there, so that's why witches die. Witches are those who have begun to realize that they are someone else's creation, and who are in a position to view other creations, but once they reach the level of true authorship, that's the end. Maria is called the "original witch" because she never gets bored and can steadily expand her ideas and worlds from scratch.
DeepL:
"On the other hand, Bern and Lambda belong to a tier where they can freely switch channels and occasionally intervene in the story by placing orders with the scenario writer. However, since intervening changes the story, they pretend not to know this fact until the very last moment. Featherine stepped into that realm and died, didn't she? Daydreaming in a blank notebook is fun, but writing stories there continuously becomes quite exhausting, which is why the witch dies. Witches are those who begin to realize, “Aren't we someone's creations?” and are in a position to view different creations. The higher they ascend, the closer they get to the writer's position, and when they truly reach the writer's realm, it ends. The reason Maria was called the “Primordial Witch” is because she could endlessly expand ideas and worlds from scratch without ever growing tired."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Anyway, my point still stands, since Ryukishii07 still describes a Witch's journey as the journey to become a writer (Creator):
Raw:
一方でベルンやラムダたちは、チャンネ ルを自由に変えたり、ときどきシナリオライ ターに注文をつけて、話に介入できる階層。 ただし介入すると物語が変わってしまうの で、その事実はギリギリまで知らないふりを している。 フェザリーヌは、そこに踏み込ん で死んでしまったんでしょう。 白紙のノート に妄想するのは楽しいけど、そこにずっと話 を書き続けるのはかなりしんどいので、魔 女は死んでしまうわけですね。魔女というの は、「自分たちは、誰かの創作物じゃないか」 ということに気づき始めていて、なおかつ 異なる創作物を閲覧できる立場にいる者で、 上に行けば行くほど執筆者の立場に近づい ていき、本当に執筆者の域まで到達すると 終わってしまう。真里亞が「原初の魔女」と 呼ばれた理由は、飽きることなく、ゼロから ドンドンとアイデアや世界を膨らませていけ るからなんです。
Google Translate:
This is the level where you can give orders to the texter and intervene in the story. However, intervening changes the story, so you pretend not to know this fact until the very last moment. Featherine stepped into this and died. It's fun to fantasize on a blank notebook, but it's extremely tiring to keep writing stories there, so that's why witches die. Witches are those who have begun to realize that they are someone else's creation, and who are in a position to view other creations, but once they reach the level of true authorship, that's the end. Maria is called the "original witch" because she never gets bored and can steadily expand her ideas and worlds from scratch.
DeepL:
"On the other hand, Bern and Lambda belong to a tier where they can freely switch channels and occasionally intervene in the story by placing orders with the scenario writer. However, since intervening changes the story, they pretend not to know this fact until the very last moment. Featherine stepped into that realm and died, didn't she? Daydreaming in a blank notebook is fun, but writing stories there continuously becomes quite exhausting, which is why the witch dies. Witches are those who begin to realize, “Aren't we someone's creations?” and are in a position to view different creations. The higher they ascend, the closer they get to the writer's position, and when they truly reach the writer's realm, it ends. The reason Maria was called the “Primordial Witch” is because she could endlessly expand ideas and worlds from scratch without ever growing tired."

Again, this is just an analogy.

Gamemasters are already writers, whereas the Voyagers are the readers who read what the Gamemasters write.

Creators have no form, no thought; they are pure nothingness, perfect, lacking any limitation. They create through a process completely different from that of an author writing a work on a page.
 
There's no doubt that Line is close to being the strongest character. At the same time, she's a pretty embarrassing character. She features herself in her own work and writes, "I'm super strong!" (laughs). It's like a fantasy novel in which the author himself is the strongest protagonist.
Ryukishi07 is not talking about himself.
I misunderstood about that too because the translation in the wiki looks like it refers to himself so it's mistranslation (?)
Does this mean that Featherine has the ability to make what she writes come true, or is it possible to interpret the entire story of Ep8 as being written by Featherine?

R07: That's one way to look at it. Featherine is the closest thing to a god in that world, the world's guardian. So there's no doubt that she's the strongest character in the story. At the same time, it's pretty embarrassing. I made myself appear in my work and wrote "I'm super strong~!" (laughs) Isn't it like a fantasy novel with the author himself as the strongest hero?
 
Back
Top