• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
I know that most witches born from Oblivion which means they didn't evolve from the human domain so Beato and those who evolved from the human domain are an exception from the same process as we have seen in the confession?
 
Last edited:
Small side quest

 
Small side quest

What is the point to have a separate version since we know that anime is just poor adaptation unlike Higurashi Meguri/Sotsu or Umineko Ep8 VN/Manga which is literally a separate version?
 
I have read it but still don't get it at all. Since we can apply outside information for scaling so all media can share the same scaling by default.

Your eyes are not deceiving you. Recently, new information came to light that shows the Umineko anime’s cosmology exists within the broader macro-cosmology of the 07th Expansion, so for the sake of completeness, in this thread I am going to propose a scale specifically for the anime.

Recently, new information came to light that shows the Umineko anime’s cosmology exists within the broader macro-cosmology of the 07th Expansion
 
Your eyes are not deceiving you. Recently, new information came to light that shows the Umineko anime’s cosmology exists within the broader macro-cosmology of the 07th Expansion, so for the sake of completeness, in this thread I am going to propose a scale specifically for the anime.

Recently, new information came to light that shows the Umineko anime’s cosmology exists within the broader macro-cosmology of the 07th Expansion
Source
 
I am a bit confused. If anime is already a part of the cosmology, why specifically anime-side scaling? Isn't it just redundant?
 
Small side quest

Opening the link only shows "Umineko no Naku Koro Ni [REDACTED] version cosmology scale", why did you make an empty CRT?
 
on Battler's P&A the tea party 4th wall breaking is listed for his witch domain manifestation, is there a specific consensus on the tea party's all happening in the witch domain? If so, what's the basis? I just finished Ep1 and its tea part segment and the whole thing is Battler doubting the existence of witches, and anything supernatural, which seems like it'll contradict that placement.
 
also, another thing is I am writing some notes on the powerscaling stuff so I can talk about it afterwards and I wanna make sure my notes are mostly accurate. Like Beatrice's Tea Party feats are in her Piece P&A section, but Battler's aren't, so I'm a little confused how I'm supposed to interpret the tea party's in general tbh
 
I've already been spoiled on most stuff by powerscalers lol
I guess it's ok then
also, another thing is I am writing some notes on the powerscaling stuff so I can talk about it afterwards and I wanna make sure my notes are mostly accurate. Like Beatrice's Tea Party feats are in her Piece P&A section, but Battler's aren't, so I'm a little confused how I'm supposed to interpret the tea party's in general tbh
Profiles are severely outdated.

Tea parties should take place in the Meta-World, yeah, because they happen after the narrative of the games ends (i.e., after the last day has already passed and everyone has died), characters there can acknowledge the events of the kakera as games, etc.

Even if there is some upgrade that I am not knowledgeable about for the cosmology that'd put Tea Parties below the Meta-World, they certainly do not happen inside the Human World of the fragment that defines the game that took place in the episode.

Besides that, 07th profiles are severely outdated, so it could be just wrong placement of abilities. But, given that most of Beatrice's magical abilities come from Endless Magic (which she can use as a piece) and that Meta-Beings mantain the abilities they had as a piece (seen several times within the game), I guess you could argue she has it as a piece as long as it doesn't involve Game Master Authority, or anything that is directly tied to being at the Meta-World.

That doesn't apply to 4th Wall Breaking for Battler because, to my knowledge Piece Battler doesn't seem to share consciousness with his meta-world realm in the first episodes.

Unlike other detectives like Erika who, even as a piece, seems to share the knowledge of her Meta-World manifestation, as seen several times across Episode 5 and 6.
 
Back
Top