Wario Question

[Flashlight237]

I know we had Wario as Class 10 or Classs G, but... The Bottomless Money Bag was explicitly stated to contain infinite money.: https://www.mariowiki.com/Bottomless_Coin_Sack
Why don't we give Wario infinite lifting strength from not only carrying, but also shaking something infinite?

 

[Imaginym]

Being able to infinitely produce doesn't mean containing infinite mass/quantity.

 

[Flashlight237]

Being able to infinitely produce doesn't mean containing infinite mass/quantity.

Okay, but the normal moneybags in-game worked the same way as the Bottomless Money Bag, only they had a certain amount of coins in them before the bags decide that offing themselves is a good idea.

 

[BigSmoke4269]

but it does mean he can lift any finite number of cash

 

[Imaginym]

Okay, but the normal moneybags in-game worked the same way as the Bottomless Money Bag, only they had a certain amount of coins in them before the bags decide that offing themselves is a good idea.

Source that they have infinite money then self-destruct?

Also, being able to generate an infinite quantity over time doesn't mean having infinite at 1 time.

If it could give infinite money if it never self-destructs, but only ever physically holds, say, 1,000 coins or such at any given moment before it generates/releases more, holding it is not infinite mass.

but it does mean he can lift any finite number of cash

No Limits Fallacy?

How do we know these money bags have no upper limits on the finite quantities of cash they can hold?

 

[DarkDragonMedeus]

Think it just means an infinite sized pocket dimension might be in it or it can magically create infinite coins. Not that there's physically infinite coins/mass inside the bag.

 

[Flashlight237]

Source that they have infinite money then self-destruct?

What sentence are you reading, bro?

 

[Imaginym]

What sentence are you reading, bro?

This one.

Okay, but the normal moneybags in-game worked the same way as the Bottomless Money Bag, only they had a certain amount of coins in them before the bags decide that offing themselves is a good idea.

You compared them to a "Bottomless Money Bag" & also said that the bags "off" themselves.

 

[BigSmoke4269]

i think he was referring to the normal, non-infinite bags

 

[Flashlight237]

i think he was referring to the normal, non-infinite bags

Yeah, that. Bro really dropped the ball on the reading comprehension there.

 

[Imaginym]

Clearly, I must have misunderstood something, yes. So lemme try & reassess this:

1. There are 2 kinds of money bags: Normal money bags that Wario finds regularly throughout his adventure, & the Bottomless Coin Sack that Wario is seeking out & obtains at the end of the game.
2. Normal coin sacks disappear in a puff of smoke when they have no more coins.
3. The Bottomless Coin Sack can be shaken to get more coins as many times as is wished.

Is that assessment correct?

 

[ShionAH]

This is literally just dimensional storage