- 165,203
- 72,181
Hello.
The second phase of our DC Comics revision project will determine where and how the cosmology of the verse in question is divided. Our current blog provides four cosmologies, Vertigo, DeMatteis, Morrison, and Snyder/Tynion, with a 'Williamson Cosmology' being tentatively outlined. These five were selected based on each having a distinct approach to the core concepts of DC, and having a certain level of internal consistency with those approaches.
This thread is for assessing the division into these five cosmologies, and reaching a community consensus on the matter. However, this thread is not for tiering these cosmologies, as the tiers cannot be decided until the cosmologies themselves are agreed upon. Once a consensus is reached on where we draw the dividing lines, another discussion will be had for tiering.
Moreover, due to practical limitations for this discussion, it is advised that a level of restraint be applied in debating the specific qualities or details of a specific cosmology. In other words, a specific objection about how "the Dreaming" is described in the blog under the "Vertigo" cosmology is better left to a later discussion. It is best that we avoid encumbering this discussion with the fine details of each cosmology, and focus foremost on which cosmologies DC will be divided into.
With that said, here is the link to our current cosmology blog, and the matter is now open for discussion.
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Antvasima/DC_Comics_Cosmology_Revision_Project
As before, participation in this thread will be limited to staff, project members, and regular members who are knowledgeable about the verse, if they contact a member of our staff for permission. The discussion will be strictly moderated, so any comments that are off-topic or toxic will be removed, and those who repeatedly post them will be barred from further participation, in order to focus on productive discussion.
The second phase of our DC Comics revision project will determine where and how the cosmology of the verse in question is divided. Our current blog provides four cosmologies, Vertigo, DeMatteis, Morrison, and Snyder/Tynion, with a 'Williamson Cosmology' being tentatively outlined. These five were selected based on each having a distinct approach to the core concepts of DC, and having a certain level of internal consistency with those approaches.
This thread is for assessing the division into these five cosmologies, and reaching a community consensus on the matter. However, this thread is not for tiering these cosmologies, as the tiers cannot be decided until the cosmologies themselves are agreed upon. Once a consensus is reached on where we draw the dividing lines, another discussion will be had for tiering.
Moreover, due to practical limitations for this discussion, it is advised that a level of restraint be applied in debating the specific qualities or details of a specific cosmology. In other words, a specific objection about how "the Dreaming" is described in the blog under the "Vertigo" cosmology is better left to a later discussion. It is best that we avoid encumbering this discussion with the fine details of each cosmology, and focus foremost on which cosmologies DC will be divided into.
With that said, here is the link to our current cosmology blog, and the matter is now open for discussion.
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Antvasima/DC_Comics_Cosmology_Revision_Project
As before, participation in this thread will be limited to staff, project members, and regular members who are knowledgeable about the verse, if they contact a member of our staff for permission. The discussion will be strictly moderated, so any comments that are off-topic or toxic will be removed, and those who repeatedly post them will be barred from further participation, in order to focus on productive discussion.