• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

THAT SCP Revision (Yes, it's High 1-A)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Guys calm down this is a big change for a horribly inconsistent verse that we literally are picking and choosing what we accept based on the illusion there is a majority on most of the topics we index for the verse hell I wouldn't be surprised if DT is still reading scp-5800 and some other articles to build a opinion based on as much information as he can find. Why don't we take a step back who gets the new plot hax for protagonist.
 
Guys calm down this is a big change for a horribly inconsistent verse that we literally are picking and choosing what we accept based on the illusion there is a majority on most of the topics we index for the verse hell I wouldn't be surprised if DT is still reading scp-5800 and some other articles to build a opinion based on as much information as he can find. Why don't we take a step back who gets the new plot hax for protagonist.
Well
I waited for 5 years to reach to this point.
So i think i can wait for few days
Dont know about the other Boys tho
 
Anyway, it seems like I messed up early on, by not thinking through how I worded things due to rushing between different tasks, and making it seem like everybody else should automatically adapt to DontTalk's wishes, rather than just wait for and try to collaborate with him, as a safety measure. That was a serious mistake, so my apologies about that.
 
Last edited:
Even so, I generally go out of my way to help the members of this community, and keep them safe, as best as I can, so I dislike being perceived as some kind of general bad guy.
 
I will try, but I have adhd and am constantly overworked and distracted, so mistakes happen at times.
 
I think so, but he often gets busy IRL, and has to take breaks accordingly.
 
I just woke up. This was not the response I was expecting.

I understand I could have come off as rushing things, the truth is that waiting on the opinion of a single user while an entire team's worth of points were left unanswered seemed disingenuous. I don't doubt DT's capability or his knowledge on SCP since he has responded to SCP threads in the past, but this revision is a culmination of an entire team's contribution worth of knowledge after reading dozens of articles and tales. To say this is peer reviewed is putting it lightly. If DT was taking the time to read and get an understanding of the points, the least he could do was let us know that he needed time. I don't mind this thread stretching out for about a week if it meant there was active discussion. But as it stood the thread was dead silent waiting for a response.

To summarise, this is a CRT to change one thing that requires prior knowledge on at least dozens of articles to understand. Ultima, a leading expert on tiering and the use of feats to achieve tiering, was actively consulted and approves of the upgrade. We would appreciate it if a basic understanding of the topic at hand was had before engaging in rebuttals.

Rest assured, we would not have made this thread if we were not all unanimous with the decision to upgrade the verse. This is again, a team effort. A move made so that a verse as volatile as SCP does not blow up with misinformation and bad practices.
 
I was attempting to help you understand the idea of a mental distance that is metaphysically an actual distance even if we do not see it as such as material beings. When one is submerged in conceptual space, even something like an information reconstruction of a person from memory (which is "physically" the size of a person), you are able to perceive these things as distance. Its just a more psuedo-scientific take on the Warp to pull back the fancy coating. Also, even if we decided to go with your interpretation, they definitely are still "physical"/very literal piles of things, they would be sets of ideas that are the size of Alephs arranged in a complex. It just so happens that in SCP ideas can indeed have dimensions.

Okay, clearly my point here did not come across well. You had concern that because 3125 had a topology that could be graphed using finite numbers, so I was attempting to clarify and explain how you were oversimplifying the issue. Also, no, they are not "higher" than humans they are bigger. 3125 had the whole human noosphere inside of it, 'physically' if in immaterial space. You can argue that the size is a metaphor or an abstract but they do have what both material and immaterial beings view as Size. A mere subsection of 3125 does also physically exist at every point in our universe:

I know this also isn't some metaphor, because there isn't a mind to hold even the most abstract notion of SCP-3125 in the vacuum of space. If its size is purely an abstract with no true dimensions at all that could be analogous, then SCP-3125 would not be able to physically dwarf our physical universe. I am also gonna go ahead and shoot down the possibility that this is just nigh-omnipresence, because Anti ideas are not native to our material or immaterial universe, and they are not omnipresent in their own ecology either, so this is not some natural ability for them.

Okay, so what about the inverse. If an abstract, conceptual entity can enter our universe, is that also immersion? Clay from We Need to Talk about 055 and Aleister Grey from Introductory Antimemetics are both ideatic entities who are able to enter our material universe. The previous is wears physical matter after he enters, the latter has an ideatic informational body that he still walks around our 3 dimensions hunting down his prey. So we have one case where an ideatic being enters our reality and wears flesh, and one that remains wholly composed of conceptual material. As the Foundation may submerge matter into conceptual space, conceptual beings are able to, in various ways, submerge themselves in our world of hard matter. Would you say that ships and demons being able to enter and leave the warp and material space is also immersion?
To further reiterate on what I said above, SCP-3125 is also able to intersect with every point in our universe with a mere subsection of itself. Even in the most abstract interpretations of this conceptual 'space' the entities there in needs to have their sizes at least literal enough to allow for it dwarf physical space in such a way that it can exist at every point in the universe without there being a mind present to think about it.

The entrance to it is a physical rift in our universe though. You can sail directly in like the eye of terror
Sure, I guess.
Personally I still don't like the idea, but at least an argumentation is there. Since this is widely supported even amongst knowledgable staff, you guys go ahead and apply it.
updates on DontTalk? Is he still even participating in this thread?
Just as a general rule of thumb: I try to get to every important CRT (side rulings or very big upgrades) I participate in at least once a day. It's in practice sadly often not possible that I read through all the long and often plentiful replies more often than that and reply to them.
 
So have you accepted this revision then DontTalk? In that case it seems fine to apply it now.
 
Just as a general rule of thumb: I try to get to every important CRT (side rulings or very big upgrades) I participate in at least once a day. It's in practice sadly often not possible that I read through all the long and often plentiful replies more often than that and reply to them.

Oh, ok thanks
 
I'm just going to say what some of the mods have already been saying, but such a massive revision like this doesn't need to be rushed. It's best for some actual discussion to happen, and DT hasn't shown to agree just yet. And he's offered some interesting points even if I disagree, so I don't think that we can just brush that aside just cause we want to finish up this revision. So yes, I think it's best to wait for some time
He has shown up and also accepted it.
You all just needed a little patience.
 
Everything seems to have been solved, so I see no need to talk about it anymore.
 
Everything seems to have been solved, so I see no need to talk about it anymore.
I was literally just correcting him for thinking DT still hadn't responded.
He deleted his comment though, which might have made it look like I was bringing up old things.
 
Give the revision team some time to sort some matters behind the scenes and then we can move on to establishing who scales to what.
 
Ok so the established tiering will be like this:

Low Elder Gods will retain their tiering since they get stomped by War for Creation Scarlet King.

3125 will be Possibly 1-A since we have no idea where in 5800's hierarchy it stands, but we do know it is a significant enough threat to warrant this tier. It is larger than the human Noosphere and far stronger than a bottom feeder that can threaten all of it. (As an aside, Ultima explained that the Alephs only start being 1-A at Aleph-3 and up, so the human Noosphere is likely less than 1-A)

WFC SK and The Brothers Death scale above 3125 through the feat of shaking the Noosphere in their battle, and SK being unable to be sealed by 3125. All who scale to them will get Possibly 1-A.

Narrative God tiers will get High 1-A for the same reasons they're 1-A now. Where they stand in High 1-A is irrelevant but since people love tiers so much, Swann will be around baseline High 1-A. 2747 at its strongest will be infinite stacks stronger than baseline High 1-A. 3182 will be even higher than that.

Swann's True Authors key will be High 1-A, possibly 0 due to Saikou's reasoning earlier on in the thread. They are the defacto God tiers and see everything that has, has been, and ever will be written, as fiction.

Ultima has something cooking up but I will leave that to him to come out with maybe as a separate thread.

Is everyone ok with the above?
 
Ok so the established tiering will be like this:

Low Elder Gods will retain their tiering since they get stomped by War for Creation Scarlet King.

3125 will be Possibly 1-A since we have no idea where in 5800's hierarchy it stands, but we do know it is a significant enough threat to warrant this tier. It is larger than the human Noosphere and far stronger than a bottom feeder that can threaten all of it. (As an aside, Ultima explained that the Alephs only start being 1-A at Aleph-3 and up, so the human Noosphere is likely less than 1-A)

WFC SK and The Brothers Death scale above 3125 through the feat of shaking the Noosphere in their battle, and SK being unable to be sealed by 3125. All who scale to them will get Possibly 1-A.

Narrative God tiers will get High 1-A for the same reasons they're 1-A now. Where they stand in High 1-A is irrelevant but since people love tiers so much, Swann will be around baseline High 1-A. 2747 at its strongest will be infinite stacks stronger than baseline High 1-A. 3182 will be even higher than that.

Swann's True Authors key will be High 1-A, possibly 0 due to Saikou's reasoning earlier on in the thread. They are the defacto God tiers and see everything that has, has been, and ever will be written, as fiction.

Ultima has something cooking up but I will leave that to him to come out with maybe as a separate thread.

Is everyone ok with the above?

yeah seems fine. Also question, I know that 3812 was previously only ranked at 1-A+ because the wiki members think it was never made clear whether or not he completely transcended the hierarchy. But I always felt like he should've gotten a "possibly High 1-A" ranking next to it. With this translated to his new tier, would you be fine with something like "High 1-A, will eventually become higher, possibly far higher" or "High 1-A, will eventually become higher, possibly 0"? Just asking, not saying there's nothing wrong with what you said.
 
3125 will be Possibly 1-A since we have no idea where in 5800's hierarchy it stands, but we do know it is a significant enough threat to warrant this tier. It is larger than the human Noosphere and far stronger than a bottom feeder that can threaten all of it. (As an aside, Ultima explained that the Alephs only start being 1-A at Aleph-3 and up, so the human Noosphere is likely less than 1-A)
Looks pretty good, but I have some questions about the conclusion, like Swerry
1/ The hierarchy of 5800 (not Human Noosphere) is that each entity will have its own aleph number or can multiple entities share the same level/aleph?
2/ And if it's the former then each entity is the very concept of aleph number or simply no one compares them, just e.g. SCP-3125 is the very concept of aleph 4 or simply a Set has cardinality of aleph-4 without representing and/or is the concept itself? I'm quite confused because DarkmAsh says the latter (if I'm not getting it wrong) while in the quote there are many passages that imply they are the concepts/alephs themselves, the same way that aleph numbers are the cardinality of infinite and they also exist in the infinite sets (pretty meaningless if they are sets themselves, instead of their properties) and presented in them as "How many elements" (literal what cardinal is)
3/ Is 3125 baseline in its possibly raiting?
4/ Shouldn't Noospheric/Infospheric entities have a large size type 11? It's extremely clear and self-explanatory
5/ Can acidverse content also be used to support this? iirc, each aleph can contain world which also proves infinite sets and aleph are not pure mathematical abstraction because if so they wouldn't be able to contain any physical thing let alone Whole World (even in a metaphorical/abstract sense)
 
Last edited:
guys if we're going to do a scp revision can we put resistance to disease manipulation for scp-682



for those who don't want to use the link i found this

Item: SCP-217


Tissue test record: Positive. Tissue was affected by infection and follow typical symptoms.


Termination Test Log: SCP-217 has been pumped into SCP-682's cell via gas pipe. SCP-682's cell has been sealed with a decontamination airlock between him and the researchers. The following log was captured by a camera on the east wall of the containment chamber.


[Begin Log]

<1 second> SCP-682 is observed sitting.

<7 seconds> SCP-217 gas has been ejected into the containment area.

<21 seconds> SCP-682 is visibly coughing as SCP-217 enters SCP-682’s respiratory system.

SCP-682 is observed to have no visible reaction to SCP-217 for 9 days.

<224 hours 36 minutes 24 seconds> SCP-682 begins howling in visible agony, as conversion begins.

SCP-682 continues to roar in pain for 35 minutes 48 seconds

<225 hours 12 minutes 12 seconds> SCP-682's screams slowly get quieter until they are completely silent. SCP-682 appears to be in shock.

SCP-682 remains silent for for 36 minutes 48 seconds.

<225 hours 49 minutes> SCP-682 begins laughing manically and is now immune to SCP-217.

[End Log]

Notes: Alright, even though the infection did not kill SCP-682, I found this test promising. All the infectious SCP's SCP-682 has been exposed to, he is now immune to. I request to do further study on SCP-682 as we might be able to create a vaccine/cure to some incurable diseases or even create our own SCP-500. -Dr Isla Stewart
 
I was literally just correcting him for thinking DT still hadn't responded.
He deleted his comment though, which might have made it look like I was bringing up old things.
Yeah, that was my bad. But I was kinda just trying to chide people into being more patient, but things have basically been resolved, so it's not necessary now.
 
Quick question, but can someone post the scans for the narratives to justify them being High 1A? And scans to justify the true authors being possibly tier 0 would also be pretty cool.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top