• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

I've said this before, but I'm actually fine with it being light-speed. What I'm not fine with is some of the horrendous justifications for it not violating the laws of physics, especially since many of the papers and articles are very specific experiments/observations made years after G4 even appeared in the manga.
 
Sec said:
It look Like this or this ? It was like he was able to manipulate certain particles of a laser to bend. even in air
Click to expand...
It doesn't look like either of those, and that's just laser reflection. It's not homing lasers that outright curve towards targets at far larger angles.

Again, this is stuff that relies on very, very specific parameters to work.
 
Last edited:
boom said:
not in this one but google it there's a lot of videos in YouTube with lesser bend experiment also your wiki laws are so old people discover new things Avery day you should check it from time to time , there are no reason to not except light speed feats
Click to expand...
You shouldn't expect other people to search the evidence for your position for you, so just post it yourself if it is that easy to find. I'd also like to point out that threads to update rules do come up from time to time, so it's not like as if we insist on them staying as they are. They can always be updated with proper evidence, sources and reasoning and I have in fact seen this happen multiple times.
 
SemiRaedi said:
And as someone stated above, how can Saitama specifically know how much strength it takes to destroy the planet? Do you think Saitama one day searched up 'how much force needed to destroy a planet?' and checked to see if he could really do it?
Click to expand...
Maybe because Boros CSRC was planet level, just maybe?

When multiple translators agree that the data book translation say that the "ruins" thing is fallacious, since many definitions inside that one have the same definition as "destruction" in japanese and in the context of the statement it is "destroyed" and "erase" the earth. Also the video game introduction of One-Punch Man a Hero Nobody Know we can see Saitama destroying Earth OR the potential effect of CSRC. (Since we saw Boros eye in the background), which after a quick calc' is High 5-A.

  • (Using the Frieza and Death Star logic when the planet mass is hurled at high speed)
It's only a cutscene and a video game, but this game was made with ONE's backing it up and the intro cutscene was one of the biggest selling points for it. You feel like that's where 80% of the budget went. So they wouldn't show Saitama blowing up the Earth if he couldn't do it. Especially if ONE worked on the game and incorporate small lore elements.
 
UeTa said:
It's only a cutscene and a video game, but this game was made with ONE's backing it up and the intro cutscene was one of the biggest selling points for it. You feel like that's where 80% of the budget went. So they wouldn't show Saitama blowing up the Earth if he couldn't do it. Especially if ONE worked on the game and incorporate small lore elements.
Click to expand...
Yeah they 1000% would. It's a heavily stylised cutscene, and it's entirely within the viewpoint of Boros' pupil. It's the equivalent of saying the opening intro of a show is completely indicative of what kind of power the characters will have.

Also, the CSRC would have done this in the anime. So it very easily could just be referring to that version.
UeTa said:
When multiple translators agree that the data book translation say that the "ruins" thing is fallacious, since many definitions inside that one have the same definition as "destruction" in japanese and in the context of the statement it is "destroyed" and "erase" the earth.
Click to expand...
What translators? So far, I've seen about one from years ago. This was covered very, very extensively in multiple threads.
 
Last edited:
ByAsura said:
What translators? So far, I've seen about one from years ago. This was covered very, very extensively in multiple threads.
Click to expand...
Translators I asked for r/translator because I can't read Japanese myself, so I annoyed quite a few with the definitions of words and sentence structures.

Also VibhavM (one of the One-Punch Man main fan-translator) got the same conclusion when he translated Boros Databook page. He is the one with his team that translate every chapter to this day. And he is a reliable source, since it's his translated chapters that we use, because he and his team translate better than viz media with their extreme localization and censor.
 
UeTa said:
Maybe because Boros CSRC was planet level, just maybe?

When multiple translators agree that the data book translation say that the "ruins" thing is fallacious, since many definitions inside that one have the same definition as "destruction" in japanese and in the context of the statement it is "destroyed" and "erase" the earth. Also the video game introduction of One-Punch Man a Hero Nobody Know we can see Saitama destroying Earth OR the potential effect of CSRC. (Since we saw Boros eye in the background), which after a quick calc' is High 5-A.

  • (Using the Frieza and Death Star logic when the planet mass is hurled at high speed)
Click to expand...
CSRC is accepted as planet surface level, if you make a crt making it planet level then obviously Saitama will be 5-B but using evidence for stuff not even accepted on the site won't work. Planet surface is more consistent anyways since it appears in more legitimate mediums of OPM than others (manga and webcomic) while planet level appears in anime (less legit than manga) and data book (less legit than manga and also has debatable meanings for what the translation actually is while the others don't).
UeTa said:
It's only a cutscene and a video game, but this game was made with ONE's backing it up and the intro cutscene was one of the biggest selling points for it. You feel like that's where 80% of the budget went. So they wouldn't show Saitama blowing up the Earth if he couldn't do it. Especially if ONE worked on the game and incorporate small lore elements.
Click to expand...
Bruh, the argument of "wouldn't show if he couldn't do it" falls flat if I just say "why did Murata show Boros holding the planet if he couldn't do it" the manga volumes are more credible then the games for obvious reasons and the answer for both the volume and the game is simply that the scene looked cool and isn't something that is confirmed to be true.
 
UeTa said:
Also VibhavM (one of the One-Punch Man main fan-translator) got the same conclusion when he translated Boros Databook page. He is the one with his team that translate every chapter to this day. And he is a reliable source, since it's his translated chapters that we use, because he and his team translate better than viz media with their extreme localization and censor.
Click to expand...
Did they do the cubari translations? Because a lot of people have found a lot of problems with those.

Plus, we've also had people who can translate Japanese telling us that isn't the case.
 
SemiRaedi said:
CSRC is accepted as planet surface level, if you make a crt making it planet level then obviously Saitama will be 5-B but using evidence for stuff not even accepted on the site won't work. Planet surface is more consistent anyways since it appears in more legitimate mediums of OPM than others (manga and webcomic) while planet level appears in anime (less legit than manga) and data book (less legit than manga and also has debatable meanings for what the translation actually is while the others don't).

Bruh, the argument of "wouldn't show if he couldn't do it" falls flat if I just say "why did Murata show Boros holding the planet if he couldn't do it" the manga volumes are more credible then the games for obvious reasons and the answer for both the volume and the game is simply that the scene looked cool and isn't something that is confirmed to be true.
Click to expand...
I get the logic. But let explain to you the distinction with cover art of Boros holding the Earth and this cinematic. I'm gonna make it simple since I'm not English and it would be simpler for me.

Your example with Boros holding the earth is just a stylistic effect. Boros holds the earth in the palm of his hand. That doesn't necessarily mean he can destroy the Earth or anything else, it's just a styling trick. Maybe meaning he's disaster level God or anything in-between.

Covers art sometimes like in Dr. Slump have Arale flies through space and piercing the sun as if it were just cloud, again, that's just a comic effect. (But in Dr. Slump we do know that the character can potentially do it. That's not the point here tho)

In the case of this cutscene, it's more about introducing you to a villain, boss, characters, ground to ground and to hype you.

It's not going to overexpose them. Just like in the Smash intro cutscene, with Galeem destroying the universe. You "know" it can do it, who can do it, and if it want, it can do it again. Or with Ganondorf in Zelda and many others vilains/characters.

Characters are not presented to you as titans in the foreground, they are like actors in a scene with the aim of hyping the incoming game and game play. Not like the cover art of Boros holding the Earth that wouldn't ever happen.
 
Garou is so gonna get god intervention

page_04.png
0.png
 
Sec said:
Why is Saitama's 5-C calc 18948 km long? It's almost half the length of the Earth.I just arrived can someone tell me?
Click to expand...
Because there's some absurdly high-balled pixelscaling going on throughout that calc which stacks up to extreme results.
 
Damage3245 said:
Because there's some absurdly high-balled pixelscaling going on throughout that calc which stacks up to extreme results.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I think the value is too high, from the picture I think it's less than 10000km anyway. The normal world's circumference is only 40000 km.
 
Sec said:
Why is Saitama's 5-C calc 18948 km long? It's almost half the length of the Earth.I just arrived can someone tell me?
Click to expand...
The 18,948 km fit, since the water is coming the opposite direction to where EOW was. (EOW was next to Z-City Ghost Town sea, and the water came back from Y-City and B-City which are not bound to any oceans. So the water should have at least circled the planet after getting "push".)

Edit: changed EOC to EOW, I don't know what happened in my head, it's not a centipede.
 
Last edited:
UeTa said:
In the case of this cutscene, it's more about introducing you to a villain, boss, characters, ground to ground and to hype you.

It's not going to overexpose them. Just like in the Smash intro cutscene, with Galeem destroying the universe. You "know" it can do it, who can do it, and if it want, it can do it again. Or with Ganondorf in Zelda and many others vilains/characters.

Characters are not presented to you as titans in the foreground, they are like actors in a scene with the aim of hyping the incoming game and game play. Not like the cover art of Boros holding the Earth that wouldn't ever happen.
Click to expand...
Why would you be introduced to a boss character through a game intro when they could introduce their capabilities through the canon manga instead? It's literally a game intro and not even a cutscene to hype you up but for some reason it's "not going to overexpose them"?

Your logic is only backed by one game where the whole verse centers around the game while OPM canonically comes from the manga. It's like using jump force feats and applying them to the original manga character because "it's not going to overexpose them".
 
UeTa said:
The 18,948 km fit, since the water is coming the opposite direction to where EOW was. (EOW was next to Z-City Ghost Town sea, and the water came back from Y-City and B-City which are not bound to any oceans. So the water should have at least circled the planet after getting "push".)

Edit: changed EOC to EOW, I don't know what happened in my head, it's not a centipede.
Click to expand...
So why doesn't that look path like a curve at all?
 
Maverick_Zero_X said:
Doesn’t Naruto have a video game that massively surpasses the main canon due to exaggerated super moves, even making a character 4-A?
Click to expand...
Well, I dunno about massively surpassing the main canon but yeah kinda profiles for that game series are currently in the process of being made btw
 
Downgrade chances for a Tier 5 OPM feat ? Again ?

Guys, gotta ask something, what about Sweet Mask's fight with Fuhrer Ugly, was that debated ? There are possible feats for him to be accepted there

If not, I plan to cover his profile once again in a CRT
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

LIFE_OF_KING
Minor addition for Saitama
Replies
18
Views
3K
Epiccheev
Epiccheev
Damage3245
  • Locked
One-Punch Man Mosquito Calculation Issue
Replies
15
Views
1K
Damage3245
Damage3245
Second22
CMF Garou’s Profile Some Issues
Replies
36
Views
3K
JustANormalPerson01
JustANormalPerson01
TyranoDoom30
OPM profiles possible renaming
Replies
6
Views
4K
Epiccheev
Epiccheev
Shadow_x007x
  • Locked
Blast and Awakened Garou 4-A
Replies
34
Views
4K
Golden_Void
Golden_Void
Back
Top