• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
actually, that is a bit odd
but saitama himself lost his memories, meaning that he has the same brain as before the fight, and therfore the same body and power
but that saitama is the same one that did the 3-C feat so, it's really a whatever thing
I dont think it makes much of a different tbh they both the same Saitama. One day and Saitama will oneshot the other.
 
page_67.png


"That punch, abnormally powered up on a moon of jupiter". Kind of explicit that whatever power increase Saitama had is still retained in the new timeline, if people are question the feats due to the time travel.
 
page_67.png


"That punch, abnormally powered up on a moon of jupiter". Kind of explicit that whatever power increase Saitama had is still retained in the new timeline, if people are question the feats due to the time travel.
except that punch is from the Saitama that time travelled, not past Saitama, so that doesn't settle anything
 
the calculation dispute highlights a key issue with this community as a whole, in that we should allow profiles to have more flexibility and represent both low and high ends, ESPECIALLY when ambiguity to this extent causes different interpretations
it is awful practice to simply assert one of the all valid calculations as fact when none of them are demonstrably wrong from both math or story, so there's no reason why we shouldn't have something like "at least 4-A, at most 3-C" on the profile
no matter how the debate is settled, it's likely to be an unsatisfying ending
 
I mean, there were some peeps questioning if Saitama retained any power after the time travel, I'm posting that in response.
Pretty sure the discussion is if current Saitama, after seemingly assimilating with time travel Saitama, retained the power, as he doesn't seem to retain the memories
 
how do we know that they even merged by the way? maybe future saitama just disappeared after touching his time clone, something that is common in lots of media with time travel
 
page_67.png


"That punch, abnormally powered up on a moon of jupiter". Kind of explicit that whatever power increase Saitama had is still retained in the new timeline, if people are question the feats due to the time travel.
"Went back in time." You forgot this part and what happens just after.

Saitama got exponentially stronger, time traveled, then punched Garou, when the current, present Saitama was underground. Then they got pulled into each other and the alternate future Saitama got assimilated, because two cannot exist at the same time. Whether or not the current, new Saitama retains the physical strength of the original Saitama, despite not having the same memories, remains to be seen.
 
Also, people saying "Well he has the core, so clearly the physical remnants from the time travel Saitama reflect in current Saitama, meaning his body should be as strong." If current Saitama's body has all the physical changes from time travel Saitama, wouldn't he need to also have his memories? Memories are formed by neuron connections, which are a physical thing
 
saitama's case is something that is obviously just gonna be a thing where we wait for the arc to end
garou however is an easy case, we can just use the graph to see what peak garou scales to and start by scaling his non peak self to blast since they fought before he powered up
 
Original timeline sounds better
It is technically the same timeline, but altered as a result
Also, people saying "Well he has the core, so clearly the physical remnants from the time travel Saitama reflect in current Saitama, meaning his body should be as strong." If current Saitama's body has all the physical changes from time travel Saitama, wouldn't he need to also have his memories? Memories are formed by neuron connections, which are a physical thing
It is also technically a mental thing as well. As sorting out memories of the future time that affect the “past” timeline becoming the present timeline when the two merged together.
 
Also, people saying "Well he has the core, so clearly the physical remnants from the time travel Saitama reflect in current Saitama, meaning his body should be as strong." If current Saitama's body has all the physical changes from time travel Saitama, wouldn't he need to also have his memories? Memories are formed by neuron connections, which are a physical thing
Nooooot necessarily. I think MatPat did a pretty good video on if a person had regenerative powers like Deadpool and they were shot in the head, they’d lose all their memories (you know like the wolverine origins movie) due to the fact that the neural stimuli for memory isn’t really a physical thing.

Something along those lines.
 
I think you were responding to Apeiro, no?
They merged of course the power is still there

Also, people saying "Well he has the core, so clearly the physical remnants from the time travel Saitama reflect in current Saitama, meaning his body should be as strong." If current Saitama's body has all the physical changes from time travel Saitama, wouldn't he need to also have his memories? Memories are formed by neuron connections, which are a physical thing
This is a bit of an assumption similar to the one Bobsican made about the squared punch blasting out the light of the stars instead of the stars.

Like yeah, is scientifically correct, but nothing really says it, and if Murata/One wanted to show some scientific flex about the way neurons work, they would definertly have done so.
 
Nooooot necessarily. I think MatPat did a pretty good video on if a person had regenerative powers like Deadpool and they were shot in the head, they’d lose all their memories (you know like the wolverine origins movie) due to the fact that the neural stimuli for memory isn’t really a physical thing.

Something along those lines.
Good argument actually
So it’s entirely possible things could go either way. In other words we just wait for the arc to end like we ******* promise before we started MAKING CRTS A DAY AFTER THE FIGHT ENDED
 
Already seeing people say Saitama is immeasurable speed
That’d be a pretty funny way of showing that Saitama is just replicating hax through brute force, punching holes in space time to make portals, running so fast he arrives in the past, having a really good metabolism that makes it seem like he has RE
It’s all bullshit but it would be so funny if it wasn’t LMAO
 
CRT is tomorrow. I've asked Emirp to get his stuff ready.
CRT is tomorrow? Before the SP^2 has been fully decided on? And with this chapter leaving us with multiple questions?

Pain. Time for potentially 10 pages of arguing that will be rendered useless via next chapter
 
Back
Top