• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

(STAFF NEEDED) Major AP and Speed Revisions DxD

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wth, light in this verse is just Holy element, magic not real light being made of photon. Can we stop nitpicking everything that have the word "light" to be real light??
Evidence presented in the thread debunks this.
Tsubaki Mirror Alice feat is just magical reflection feat which reflect incoming attack and doubling its power, so something a holy light attack got reflected back due to it magical nature, it isn't natural reflection of light or photon
That's just a single example.
Also before anyone mention, energy, magical attacks that shining with light is common in fiction, doesn't make them light speed or being made of actual photon.
That's not my point.
Also, iirc Boost do not increases speed
Multiple examples proving otherwise have been shown throughout the thread.
Conclusion: Pls read the thread before commenting.
 
I was asked to give my opinion on facets of this. I don't have much interest in the verse but I'll give my opinions where applicable. Much of this is incomprehensible to me, particularly the OP, so you'll have to forgive me if something is missed.

Regarding light feats: some of those listed in the blog wouldn't matter whether they are made of light or not. Something can be made of light and not actually move at light speed, its components move at that speed. To give an example of what I'm getting at, when you have a drone light show forming some image in the sky in the real world, that image is made entirely of light, even though it isn't moving at light speed- only the light that comprises it is. In the example of, say, an arrow made of light, it doesn't necessarily just get light speed for being made of that. Light constructs still need to have indicators of adhering to the properties of light to be counted. Given the strangeness of some of the evidence (a magic summoned mirror being used to argue reflections, the light in one of the image visibly curving on trajectory rather than moving in a straight line, etc), I don't think this is as concrete as is being argued.

Regarding AP multipliers: Even if this were accepted, it really should have a more readable blog than this. It's even worse than the light one. I'm not trying to be mean but this is nigh-on incomprehensible, it is the presentation of raw data with very little formatting at all. I will go on to say that at least some of the evidence here is severely lacking for the points suggested- the quote from Volume 2 doesn't in any way support a manual lowering of "DC". I also don't think other quotes suggest an actual weakening of one's power, but rather just showing restraint in using hyper-powerful abilities. Still, I don't have strong opinions on this, other than that some of the evidence isn't really obviously related to it and that the blog itself needs some TLC.
 
Regarding light feats: some of those listed in the blog wouldn't matter whether they are made of light or not. Something can be made of light and not actually move at light speed, its components move at that speed. To give an example of what I'm getting at, when you have a drone light show forming some image in the sky in the real world, that image is made entirely of light, even though it isn't moving at light speed- only the light that comprises it is. In the example of, say, an arrow made of light, it doesn't necessarily just get light speed for being made of that. Light constructs still need to have indicators of adhering to the properties of light to be counted.
I believe that I've shown enough properties. Although if the lack of presentation is the cause for you not seeing that, I completely understand. I can highlight some excerpts for you that may help. Like this link and this quote from the OP.
DxD Light fits the standard (And one user's use of the technique is currently accepted but for some unexplained reason, the rest aren't), as they reflect off of non magic mirrors and metal, are called natural light/rays of light/beams of light (recreation of natural phenomena) dozens of times, are said to be made of photons, has a similar effect as natural sunlight (damages devils), are always moving in a straight line, diffuses in a realistic way ("returns to nothing"), are never interacted with by normal humans, require the user to have an extensive knowledge on the scientific and mathematic properties of natural light before recreating it in that image, and are only shown at different speeds via abilities that alter the phenomena of light itself (magic, which makes the natural into supernatural causing impossible phenomena like photons moving beyond the SoL, essentially altering the physical laws of matter).
Given the strangeness of some of the evidence (a magic summoned mirror being used to argue reflections, the light in one of the image visibly curving on trajectory rather than moving in a straight line, etc), I don't think this is as concrete as is being argued.
The normal mirror being summoned by magic doesn't seem to go against my points in any way. And all images I shared that aren't from the LN are Secondary or Tertiary canon as their events and lore are very different from the source material (although they still follow the same general storyline), I just included examples that aligned with my points however if you believe that it'd be wiser to remove them, I'm perfectly willing. And I'd appreciate if you could tell me the specific image you're referring to because if that example was of Irina's light, then I'd have a pretty simple explanation.
Regarding AP multipliers: Even if this were accepted, it really should have a more readable blog than this. It's even worse than the light one. I'm not trying to be mean but this is nigh-on incomprehensible, it is the presentation of raw data with very little formatting at all.
Sure, if it gets accepted, I'll reformat it. Although, I'm not sure exactly what the problem is. Sure it's long but is that it or is there something else? (Not asking in a rude way, just for future reference.)
I will go on to say that at least some of the evidence here is severely lacking for the points suggested- the quote from Volume 2 doesn't in any way support a manual lowering of "DC". I also don't think other quotes suggest an actual weakening of one's power, but rather just showing restraint in using hyper-powerful abilities.
The example from Volume 2 of Issei focusing his power into one spot is similar to what Gen did in Volume 5, and what Issei did in Volume 9. Both of the latter instance involve restraining the AoE of their attacks to not damage their surroundings, thus intentionally lowering their DC. And in the instances I showed, those "hyper-powerful abilities" were still used, the user just adjusted them to not damage their surroundings.
Still, I don't have strong opinions on this, other than that some of the evidence isn't really obviously related to it and that the blog itself needs some TLC.
That's fine and I respect your opinions, it's just that this thread is something that I worked really hard in researching for and I just think that compiling the research in a "readable" manner should be enough. Especially given the possibility that my work could be for naught if the thread doesn't get accepted (and I'm still not exactly sure how to format it any better, given the amount of information and the method with which I want to deliver it), anyway, thanks for responding and I greatly appreciate the feedback. If you have any tips, please share and I'll try to fix things up when I have time. (And if you could share this thread around a bit just so it can get some positive attention, I'd be very grateful. Though your response is already enough.) Have a nice day. 🙏
 
You dropped the proof. It is directly said that Boost multiplies the power and increases the speed. The point is therefore: using multipliers on the speed is downright "aberrant". This scan was needed to get the thing out.
Not sure what you're trying to say here.
 
The fact is that the scan says:

The boost therefore does not apply in the same way to the power and the speed.
The boost can be done as follows:
Power x2
Speed +10%
... what? Doubling means x2 where is it ever stated that it only ups your speed by a bit this makes 0 sense.
 
The fact is that the scan says:
It actually says
"I can go past him directly if I multiply my power and increase my dash!"
A multiplication of something is still considered an increase. The statement in no way contradicts that boosts multiply speed and actually support it given my argument in the op.
The boost therefore does not apply in the same way to the power and the speed.
The boost can be done as follows:
Power x2
Speed +10%
But you're literally pulling the 10% from thin air, there's nothing within the series that support that claim and quite a lot that contradicts it.
 
In case I need to clarify, Demonic Power (sometimes abbreviated as "power") increases the user's speed. (More DP=More Speed) Therefore, Boosts being shown to increase speed and double power mean that the increase to the speed would be x2 per boost. The evidence for DP increasing speed is here.
(The multipliers (shown in the multiplier blog) refer to doubling of "power", in DxD, "power" refers to the various energy systems like holy power, demonic power, dragon power, magic power, etc (explained in the light feats blog). These forms of energy are used by characters to amp their speed (another example, another example) and strength, and the boosts are shown increasing speed and strength (shown in the blogs and throughout the thread) so logically, the boost multipliers apply to both stats.) Also, the Evil Pieces used by most devils use demonic power to increase their stats (Bishop increases magic, Knight increases speed, Rook increases physical strength and defense, Pawn can increase each stat individually, Queen increases all 4, and King increases the stats of the user by a large multiplier.), more evidence of demonic power increasing stats.
 
In case I need to clarify, Demonic Power (sometimes abbreviated as "power") increases the user's speed. (More DP=More Speed) Therefore, Boosts being shown to increase speed and double power mean that the increase to the speed would be x2 per boost. The evidence for DP increasing speed is here.
Nothing says having twice the Demonic Power equals having twice the speed.
Let's say DP = Speed +10%
So DP x2 = Speed +20% Simple enough.
 
Nothing says having twice the Demonic Power equals having twice the speed.
Let's say DP = Speed +10%
So DP x2 = Speed +20% Simple enough.
You're assigning arbitrary values created by your headcanon tho. If Demons' speed comes from their Demonic Power which is the case as I've shown earlier, then the doubling of that would equal the doubling of their speed. It's a perfectly logical conclusion. There are many examples of increases in DP directly correlating to an increase in speed.
 
Last edited:
Once again increase=/=multiply. I agree that the speed increases but it is not multiplied. These are two very different terms.
Increase does equal multiply tho, they are quite literally the same thing. If you increase something by 200%, you are multiplying it by 2. Fairly simple math.
 
Once again increase=/=multiply. I agree that the speed increases but it is not multiplied. These are two very different terms.
The power of boost is to double the user's power by times 2, it is explicitly stated that it DOUBLES their power, and we know power applies to both their strength and speed.

This is just nitpicking.

Besides if you multiply anything by a number other than 1 or a negative it'll increase, lol I don't get where this is coming from.
 
You're assigning arbitrary values created by your headcanon tho. If Demons' speed comes from their Demonic Power which is the case as I've shown earlier, then the doubling of that would equal the doubling of their speed. It's a perfectly logical conclusion.
Exactly. Increase=/=multiply so you are proposing arbitrary values. What I gave you were examples to show you how it works. In most manga the speed is increased by mana but never and I mean never it has been said that doubling the mana doubles the speed without this being stated.
 
You're assigning arbitrary values created by your headcanon tho. If Demons' speed comes from their Demonic Power which is the case as I've shown earlier, then the doubling of that would equal the doubling of their speed. It's a perfectly logical conclusion. There are many examples of increases in DP directly correlating to an increase in speed.
@DarkDragonMedeus do you see what everything is based on here?
 
Exactly. Increase=/=multiply
But this is like, factually incorrect tho, like, this isn't even my opinion, you're just wrong.
so you are proposing arbitrary values
Arbitrary and Correct aren't necessarily synonyms.
. What I gave you were examples to show you how it works. In most manga the speed is increased by mana but never and I mean never it has been said that doubling the mana doubles the speed without this being stated.
DxD isn't most manga, DxD is DxD. (y)
 
The power of boost is to double the user's power by times 2, it is explicitly stated that it DOUBLES their power, and we know power applies to both their strength and speed.

This is just nitpicking.

Besides if you multiply anything by a number other than 1 or a negative it'll increase, lol I don't get where this is coming from.
Except that's not how it happens. Demonic Power functions as an element of Statistics Amplification. By doubling the Demonic Power nothing says that the speed will be doubled.
 
Except that's not how it happens. Demonic Power functions as an element of Statistics Amplification. By doubling the Demonic Power nothing says that the speed will be doubled.
It's kinda just common sense tho, there's more than enough evidence to show that demonic power makes devils fast, doubling it doubles their strength, and is stated to increase speed. Atp, you're kinda just proposing your argument on inconsequential wording details.
 
It's kinda just common sense tho, there's more than enough evidence to show that demonic power makes devils fast, doubling it doubles their strength, and is stated to increase speed. Atp, you're kinda just proposing your argument on inconsequential wording details.
What common sense? It makes me laugh. Just because Demonic Power makes them fast doesn't mean doubling it doubles their speed. The quantity has just increased. Not inconsequential wording but the facts.
 
I mean, all it takes is a quick google search. And please don't insinuate that I'm stubborn of hardheaded, Phoenks did that earlier and I obviously don't appreciate it.
Research based on what? What will your source be based on? The rules for using multipliers from the wiki?
 
The fact is this:
Demonic Power has been said to increase speed. So let's say Issei's base without Demonic Power is Hypersonic and Demonic Power takes him to Sub-Relativistic+. You see in this case that doubling Demonic Power does not double the speed.
 
The fact is this:
Demonic Power has been said to increase speed. So let's say Issei's base without Demonic Power is Hypersonic and Demonic Power takes him to Sub-Relativistic+. You see in this case that doubling Demonic Power does not double the speed.
But you're making these claims without evidence. It'd be like me saying, "Let's say Issei is universe level with 1% of his power, and Multiverse Level with 10%. You can see in this case, Issei solos and is too op." Like, come on. Be serious.
 
Nothing to do with the case of fiction. The fact is that the speed that the characters display is a speed already increased by Demonic Power. Doubling Demonic Power does not double the speed because you don't know how fast the character's speed is without Demonic Power.
English isn't the same in real life as it is in fiction? lmao
 
But you're making these claims without evidence. It'd be like me saying, "Let's say Issei is universe level with 1% of his power, and Multiverse Level with 10%. You can see in this case, Issei solos and is too op." Like, come on. Be serious.
Exactly. You're making assumptions from the start and it's not a matter of no evidence but that's how it works.
 
English isn't the same in real life as it is in fiction? lmao
And magic actually exists? We try to get closer to reality but the same rules don't always apply. If that were the case why do you think there are verses on the wiki that have been rejected for using multipliers? They could all come out with the same argument.
 
And magic actually exists? We try to get closer to reality but the same rules don't always apply. If that were the case why do you think there are verses on the wiki that have been rejected for using multipliers? They could all come out with the same argument.
You were arguing that the definition of the world "multiply" doesn't have the same meaning in DxD as it does in real life. Sorry, but you're kinda just making non points. If you make a claim that has supporting evidence or a logical basis, I'll respond, but I won't argue just to argue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top