- 10,758
- 6,491
I am not knowledgeable on Splatoon I'll say that right off the bat. But I'm commenting because some of stuff said in this thread are really weird to me.
>Scaling a weapon to its battery
I went to the Inklings upgrade thread Weekly linked and it was disagreed with there
Idk about scaling the entire output of his battery to his stats. We got nuclear powered battleships and submarines and stuff, but that doesn't make the weapons besides the actual nukes stop being tiers 9 and 8.~Wokistan
Electro isn't a vehicle. This means that it would actually reasonably scale to durability, and thus since Spiderman hurts him physically and he can hurt Spiderman he scales either way. You'll also notice the calcer adjusted the numbers to compensate for how him using all the energy at once makes no sense.
With vehicles with powerful batteries, they don't necessarily inheret thst same durability because batteries are specifically meant to not ruin what you out them in. The energy is utilized in a way that isn't supposed to be damaging the vehicle or being exposed to the wrong places. When stuff like that does happen, you get catastrophic mechanical failures. Nuclear subs aren't tier 7 in dura just because nuclear reactors.~Wok again when Electro was brought up.
After that The Egg Robot was brought up and he had this to say
Yeah that kinda doesn't make any sense. Batteries shouldn't have their entire outputs count towards AP/dura.
At least eggrobo can still just scale to Sonic via being the final boss.
After that there was a brief discussion on Sonic ratings but no real counterargument was brought against the Egg Robot rating being illegitimate
>Using total energy not energy per second
This was also disagreed with
Scaling somethings AP to it's battery makes no sense unless they can release it all at once in an attack, and real world is more reliable then how sonic is scaled, only one of the twp is unarguably true after all.
So unless there is a reason to scale it to what amounts to stamina, it shouldn't scale. I'll make a question and answers board, and if needed a crt, about sonic later.~Ricsi-viragosi
Unless it can release it all at once, it in no way scales to AP, and I also doubt you can scale dura directly since tecnology can be made to be more conductive without being durable.~Ricsi again
And it's how electri's powers work. But I will downfrade him and pete. He never released it all at once despite seemingly trying. And peter never once harmed him. So he doesn't scale at all.~Ricsi yet again
And if you're wondering, yes Electro did get downgraded, with Ricsi's support.
And even ignoring Ricsi's arguments, we do in fact take time needed to perform a feat into consideration. It's why heat releasing feats are explicitly stated to only be the amount of energy released in a unit time in the Calculations page.
And as for how this discussion around this feat ended
"Dont worry, we moved past that and found another feat they scale to"~Weekly
>Scaling a battery being a wiki standard
It's at least not an officially recognized standard and even if it's how things are usually done that means nothing other than the common practice likely being wrong. If there's a logical argument disproving the " A weapon scales to the battery" idea then it shouldn't be used, common practice or not.
>Scaling a weapon to its battery
I went to the Inklings upgrade thread Weekly linked and it was disagreed with there
Idk about scaling the entire output of his battery to his stats. We got nuclear powered battleships and submarines and stuff, but that doesn't make the weapons besides the actual nukes stop being tiers 9 and 8.~Wokistan
Electro isn't a vehicle. This means that it would actually reasonably scale to durability, and thus since Spiderman hurts him physically and he can hurt Spiderman he scales either way. You'll also notice the calcer adjusted the numbers to compensate for how him using all the energy at once makes no sense.
With vehicles with powerful batteries, they don't necessarily inheret thst same durability because batteries are specifically meant to not ruin what you out them in. The energy is utilized in a way that isn't supposed to be damaging the vehicle or being exposed to the wrong places. When stuff like that does happen, you get catastrophic mechanical failures. Nuclear subs aren't tier 7 in dura just because nuclear reactors.~Wok again when Electro was brought up.
After that The Egg Robot was brought up and he had this to say
Yeah that kinda doesn't make any sense. Batteries shouldn't have their entire outputs count towards AP/dura.
At least eggrobo can still just scale to Sonic via being the final boss.
After that there was a brief discussion on Sonic ratings but no real counterargument was brought against the Egg Robot rating being illegitimate
>Using total energy not energy per second
This was also disagreed with
Scaling somethings AP to it's battery makes no sense unless they can release it all at once in an attack, and real world is more reliable then how sonic is scaled, only one of the twp is unarguably true after all.
So unless there is a reason to scale it to what amounts to stamina, it shouldn't scale. I'll make a question and answers board, and if needed a crt, about sonic later.~Ricsi-viragosi
Unless it can release it all at once, it in no way scales to AP, and I also doubt you can scale dura directly since tecnology can be made to be more conductive without being durable.~Ricsi again
And it's how electri's powers work. But I will downfrade him and pete. He never released it all at once despite seemingly trying. And peter never once harmed him. So he doesn't scale at all.~Ricsi yet again
And if you're wondering, yes Electro did get downgraded, with Ricsi's support.
And even ignoring Ricsi's arguments, we do in fact take time needed to perform a feat into consideration. It's why heat releasing feats are explicitly stated to only be the amount of energy released in a unit time in the Calculations page.
And as for how this discussion around this feat ended
"Dont worry, we moved past that and found another feat they scale to"~Weekly
>Scaling a battery being a wiki standard
It's at least not an officially recognized standard and even if it's how things are usually done that means nothing other than the common practice likely being wrong. If there's a logical argument disproving the " A weapon scales to the battery" idea then it shouldn't be used, common practice or not.