• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Why does Neo Metal have invulnerability negation in the speed sim doc? He never hurts Super Sonic, he only pushes him back
 
She did cause a thunderstorm in a recent issue, yeah. And you're right about Surge having those. They're just haven't been any focus on the IDW OCs in this site.
Gee... I wonder why? Heh.

I may not be a fan of the IDW Sonic comics but at least I want the characters to be properly represented hete, I may do a small CRT in the future (assuming no-one else is planning to do one).
 
Hey, is there a reason Time Eater is treated as having affected Crisis City, instead of it just going to White Space due to that being where erased space time goes?
 
I’m talking with someone who’s arguing that TE didn’t erase CC and it was just there already cuz of ‘06’s ending, just wanted to make sure I wasn’t misremembering smthn.
 
A little off topic but I might as well bring up another topic I'm curious on others opinions towards.
What do we think here about the existence of Two Worlds' legitimacy? Pre Tailstube retcons anyway since it killed Two Worlds.
 
No, at best we have is that all that the Time Eater erases goes there
The game does say that the dimension of time is a thing, so if time is lost from a dimension (say if it was erased from existence by time paradox), it could be the equivalent of Time Eater sucking the dimensional energy from the world, which was the catalyst for them being voided and left in White Space (is what the guy I’m talking to is saying)
 
The game does say that the dimension of time is a thing, so if time is lost from a dimension (say if it was erased from existence by time paradox), it could be the equivalent of Time Eater sucking the dimensional energy from the world, which was the catalyst for them being voided and left in White Space (is what the guy I’m talking to is saying)
Why was present day Blaze stuck in Crisis City needing to be restored the same as it was, then?
 
The game does say that the dimension of time is a thing, so if time is lost from a dimension (say if it was erased from existence by time paradox), it could be the equivalent of Time Eater sucking the dimensional energy from the world, which was the catalyst for them being voided and left in White Space (is what the guy I’m talking to is saying)
this.......sounds a LOT like fanfiction and headcanon, ngl
 
Why was present day Blaze stuck in Crisis City needing to be restored the same as it was, then?
She was kinda just outside Crisis City, even if she wasn’t TE could have just stuck her in there if CC was already in white space due to being erased prior.

this.......sounds a LOT like fanfiction and headcanon, ngl
If it’s possible to definitively show that areas in white space aren’t there solely because they had their time/space removed, and it’s all because of Time Eater, that would be great.
 
A little off topic but I might as well bring up another topic I'm curious on others opinions towards.
What do we think here about the existence of Two Worlds' legitimacy? Pre Tailstube retcons anyway since it killed Two Worlds.
I just didn't like it. thus, ofc, it's wrong
 
I don't think there's anything saying Crisis City was already in White Space. That person needs to prove that, first. We see Time Eater opening a portal to Crisis City and sending Blaze there, just like the other places.
 
A little off topic but I might as well bring up another topic I'm curious on others opinions towards.
What do we think here about the existence of Two Worlds' legitimacy? Pre Tailstube retcons anyway since it killed Two Worlds.
Worked perfectly in the original context of the Sonic series, but whatever Takashi Iizuka got from it wasn't exactly that (Or at least, not how the games depicted it at least).

I would be fine if they went back with the original concept, especially if they use it as a justification to unify the different Sonic as one (As it should have always been).
 
She was kinda just outside Crisis City, even if she wasn’t TE could have just stuck her in there if CC was already in white space due to being erased prior.


If it’s possible to definitively show that areas in white space aren’t there solely because they had their time/space removed, and it’s all because of Time Eater, that would be great.
Again..........you kinda of the one who needs to show the proof here.......all you said sounds purely like headcanon
 
Yeah ig it’s just unclear if what ends up sticking these elements in White Space is, the act of having their dimensional energy/time removed in and of itself, or Time Eater specifically doing it. Because realistically, if Eggman was trying to reverse his previous defeats that he remembers, Crisis City shouldn’t be a part of that due to being erased from the memories of most of the cast.
 
Yeah ig it’s just unclear if what ends up sticking these elements in White Space is, the act of having their dimensional energy/time removed in and of itself, or Time Eater specifically doing it. Because realistically, if Eggman was trying to reverse his previous defeats that he remembers, Crisis City shouldn’t be a part of that due to being erased from the memories of most of the cast.
But he literally sent Blaze there, so it was a premeditated action.
 
Idk, I think it was kinda arbitrary, like Charmy doesn’t have anything to do with planet wisp. Think he just picked places in white space and spun a wheel.

But also, where would Crisis City have been as an erased timeline before White Space? Is there like a second zone for erased space time in the cosmology, cuz I don’t think so.
 
Last edited:
Idk, I think it was kinda arbitrary, like Charmy doesn’t have anything to do with planet wisp. Think he just picked places in white space and spun a wheel.

But also, where would Crisis City have been as an erased timeline before White Space? Is there like a second zone for erased space time in the cosmology, cuz I don’t think so.
Going to be honest, all your answers have literally just been headcanon, sorry. They just lack any proof.
 
I’m just saying a decent amount of the places where Sonic’s friends were sent share a very tenuous or even nonexistent connection to them, or their placements were more gameplay and meta focused than in universe. And there isn’t any other place in sonic we know that erased timelines go for Crisis City to be in before Time Eater’s influence.
 
I’m just saying a decent amount of the places where Sonic’s friends were sent share a very tenuous or even nonexistent connection to them, or their placements were more gameplay and meta focused than in universe. And there isn’t any other place in sonic we know that erased timelines go for Crisis City to be in before Time Eater’s influence.
Erased time and space don't NEED to go anywhere, it's erased. And they do share a connection, they're places where Eggman lost before. We know Eggman sent them on purpose to those places, he says so himself.
 
Erased time and space don't NEED to go anywhere, it's erased. And they do share a connection, they're places where Eggman lost before. We know Eggman sent them on purpose to those places, he says so himself.
Then how does Eggman remember crisis city all of a sudden, if it was erased from everyone’s memory?

Tails dialogue also sort of implied that having dimensional energy ripped out of a space causes it to become white space, so wouldn’t being an erased timeline also trigger that?
 
Back
Top