I don't understand how the discussion in that thread happened to be derailing. Proper tiering was one of the most important reasons to accept Shinza's return or not. A large part of the blog was about tiering. Both DT and Ultima agreed to discuss tiering in the same thread. All posts in the thread were about tiering
Anyway, contrary to what it seems, I'm not looking for lowballing Shinza, I was one of the people in Yuri's threads who tried the hardest to prove that Shinza is 1-A or even high 1-A. I myself believe that Shinza is 1-A, if this were Discord or Instagram, I would agree that Shinza is 1-A. The thing is, no matter what argument or evidence we use to prove 1-A Shinza in vsbattles, it's not enough for vsbattles standards. We really tried all the possible things, but in the end, people like mods opposed them. In this community, creating and transcending all laws, concepts and dualities does not mean transcending all their expansions and it is 5D or 6D at best (In my opinion transcending concept of space is always 1-A tho). Even a statement like "transcending anything and everything" and "disconnected from all things in creation" and "creating dualities" is not enough. You can somehow prove that there are infinite phases in the universe and phase was used once for the difference between dimensions, but even that is not enough for vsbattles and you need something clearer and more consistent, something consistently and directly stating dimensions not phases or layers that can be used for multiple different things
The reason why I said in that thread that Shinza is Low 1-C is because I know that the possibility of 1-A Shinza being accepted in vsbattles is almost zero. I myself can prepare dozens arguments and proofs to prove that Shinza is 1-A, similar to what I did in Yuri's thread, but I know it won't be accepted. If you want, just tell me and I will prepare as many evidence as possible for 1-A Shinza again, but I promise it won't be accepted. Know when to give up
In the same thread, it was said that the dimensions in Paradise Lost are not spatial, and evidence was not given that the difference between each dimension is infinite. So why do you think that 1-B Shinza will be accepted or it will stay in vsbattles for a long time? What I see is that we have to choose between Low 1-C Shinza and no Shinza, and my choice is the former. I retired from fictional debating months ago, but I still want Shinza's presence in vsbattles