- 972
- 146
Continuing from here.
Low Tiers
The low tiers, meaning Rom and the rest of the Felt camp not named Reinhard, should be significantly above 10-A. In Arc 1, Rom was able to easily destroy a table (he does this mutiple times in the anime) which is 9-B. There is also a case to be made about a WN statement about Rom being able to smash a car, which would be 9-A, because we know that the LN is not always canon in every aspect and a bunch of cut were made "because of the page count" while sometimes the anime even retcons the LN.
Mid Tiers
As already established, the calc used to scale the mid tiers is bunk and their 8-A rating needs to go. They should instead scale to Al Goa (the low end was accepted) as it is an Al level magic which even Mimi, who's down there with Aldebaran, can cast. This is further supported by the fact that Otto's Al Dona, which is powerful enough to pulverize trees, did nothing to Garfiel. Now, pulverizing just a single tree is 0.56 Tons of TNT which is 8-C, and if the amount of trees that Al Dona can pulverize is greater than 4 (note that the word used in Japanese is 木々, which usually means 'many trees'), this spell would also be High 8-C like Al Goa. Now, while Garfiel is resistant to earth magic, it's doubtful it's anywhere near Reinhard's 80% resistances, and even if nerf to damage to 8-C, he was still unscratched by it. Another piece of evidence I'll supply to help the scaling is the fact that 8 y/o Rem was already capable of smashing large trees with her attacks, which is 9-A+.
High Tiers
The high tiers scaling to Puck's true form was entirely based on a fake translation stating that Roswaal was tied with him in power, so it's bunk. It's even contradicted by the fact Roswaal is comparable to Echidna who's much weaker than Typhon and Daphne who are weaker than Puck's true form by virtue of the fact that he made the top 5 while they didn't. The high tiers would need to be rescaled to Puck's small form based on Roswaal and Melakuera being able to match him in combat, meaning they go down to Low 7-B.
God Tiers
Needless to say, Sekhmet loses her 7-A rating because the characters she can one-shot are no longer 7-B. The ratings of the other god tiers are also under question and they will likely be downgraded to 'At least 7-B'.
Abilities Revisions
Beatrice gets (goes without say that this will be added to Subaru's profile as well):
Low Tiers
The low tiers, meaning Rom and the rest of the Felt camp not named Reinhard, should be significantly above 10-A. In Arc 1, Rom was able to easily destroy a table (he does this mutiple times in the anime) which is 9-B. There is also a case to be made about a WN statement about Rom being able to smash a car, which would be 9-A, because we know that the LN is not always canon in every aspect and a bunch of cut were made "because of the page count" while sometimes the anime even retcons the LN.
Mid Tiers
As already established, the calc used to scale the mid tiers is bunk and their 8-A rating needs to go. They should instead scale to Al Goa (the low end was accepted) as it is an Al level magic which even Mimi, who's down there with Aldebaran, can cast. This is further supported by the fact that Otto's Al Dona, which is powerful enough to pulverize trees, did nothing to Garfiel. Now, pulverizing just a single tree is 0.56 Tons of TNT which is 8-C, and if the amount of trees that Al Dona can pulverize is greater than 4 (note that the word used in Japanese is 木々, which usually means 'many trees'), this spell would also be High 8-C like Al Goa. Now, while Garfiel is resistant to earth magic, it's doubtful it's anywhere near Reinhard's 80% resistances, and even if nerf to damage to 8-C, he was still unscratched by it. Another piece of evidence I'll supply to help the scaling is the fact that 8 y/o Rem was already capable of smashing large trees with her attacks, which is 9-A+.
High Tiers
The high tiers scaling to Puck's true form was entirely based on a fake translation stating that Roswaal was tied with him in power, so it's bunk. It's even contradicted by the fact Roswaal is comparable to Echidna who's much weaker than Typhon and Daphne who are weaker than Puck's true form by virtue of the fact that he made the top 5 while they didn't. The high tiers would need to be rescaled to Puck's small form based on Roswaal and Melakuera being able to match him in combat, meaning they go down to Low 7-B.
God Tiers
Needless to say, Sekhmet loses her 7-A rating because the characters she can one-shot are no longer 7-B. The ratings of the other god tiers are also under question and they will likely be downgraded to 'At least 7-B'.
Abilities Revisions
Beatrice gets (goes without say that this will be added to Subaru's profile as well):
- Black Hole Creation with Ul Shamak.
- Durability Negation via Minya's transmutation properties.
- Illusion Creation
- Sense Manipulation
- Statistics Amplification with Yang magic.
- Statistics Reduction with Yin magic.
- Enhanced Senses thanks to his Yang magic buffs. He can also sense shifts in the amtosphere and detect heat sources via his spirits.
- Extrasensory Perception for being able to to detect the guards outside of his room and sensing Cecilus' presence when even Ferris couldn't.
- Empathic Manipulation with the Divine Protection of Empathy.
- Automatic Translation via Otto's Divine Protection of Soul Language.
- Clairvoyance via Ram's Divine Protection of Clairvoyance.
- Earth Manipulation with Garfiel's Divine Protection of Earth Spirits and possibly Elemental Manipulation because he possesses the other elemental counterparts to this blessing.
- Spatial Manipulation for this where he not only bent but also cut space. And just to make sure, here is a better translation of that last part as I found out that sentence is just copypasta from the WN of Arc 1. So Reinhard can cut space like Reid can, makes sense as they use the same ability.
- Reactive Power Level via the Divine Protection of Second Sight.
- Animal Manipulation with Meili's Divine Protection of Magic Manipulation which allows her to control witch beasts.
- Their authority isn't Power Absorption as their victims retain their powers, it is instead the exact definition of Soul Absorption.
- With Emilia's name, they get Weapon Creation and, though we haven't seen them use it, they might have Danmaku if they can replicate Icicle Line.
- His resistance to Memory Manipulation needs to be scrapped because not only does he not remember Emilia after Ley ate her name, but he also was also eaten by Roy. Him taking control of his body later should be considered resistance to Soul Absorption.
- Regeneration (Low-Mid) in her scorpion form.
- Danmaku with Infinitied Hell Snipe.
- Resistance to Perception Manipulation for seeing through Emilia's cloak.
- Aura which he has had since youth and still has, so it goes for all of his keys.
- Aura, the same one as Wilhelm's.
- Aura.
- Resistance to Empathic Manipulation for being resistant to Sirius' authority.
- Status Effect Inducement, because she has never been stated to be able to use Yin magic.
- That part about her Unseen Hands being invisible needs to go, too, because they aren't invisible. Actually, this is possibly just an application of shadow control as they were never called 'Unseen Hands' or 'Authority of Sloth' beyond some mistranslations.
- No idea where Empathic Manipulation came from.
- No idea where Petrification came from.
- No idea where Regeneration came from.
- Memory Manipulation, Causality Manipulation and Power Absorption are all abilities possessed by Ley, Roy and Louis but not Daphne. I'd assume the same thing goes for Duplication because Daphne cannot divide herself in two.
- Her rating, because she has no combat ability whatsoever. We have her as '7-B with Magic' but what magic? She has none and her authority is a non-combat one.
- Superhuman Physical Characteristics. She's 10-B physically, that's already on her profile.
- Why dose she have Regeneration instead of Healing?
- Superhuman Physical Characteristics. Why does she even have this in the first place?
Last edited:
