Pikaman
He/Him- 6,525
- 5,211
So yeah WWE LS do be in a bad state right now
Essentially to shorten it we scale wayyyyy to many people to the “Strongmen” of the franchise when really the only people even remotely comparable to them are each other. I always want to point out how the normal Wrestlers have some pretty major anti-feats, such as The Demon Finn Bálor struggling to powerbomb a 124KG Bobby Lashley, which is barely Athletic Human. It’s also outright stated that Base Finn wouldn’t have managed the feat at all.
With this in tow, some new scaling propositions
I had informed @RandomGuy2345 in advance of the creation of this CRT I was planning on these revisions, and we ended up hitting a bit of a crossroads where we have been unable to agree (I know I know ironic considering we’re tag champs and meant to have all this synergy and blah blah blah)
So we mostly agree on the creation of 3 tiers (Low, Mid, Too) and the general types who belong in those tiers:
Low: Cruiserweights (Finn Bálor, Rey Mysterio, etc.)
Mid: Heavyweights, “Powerhouses” (Austin Theory, John Cena, Sheamus, etc.)
Top: “Strongmen” (Mark Henry, Braun Strowman, Brock Lesnar, Big Show, etc.)
We also agreed on the following:
- Low Tiers should be “Athletic Human, Possibly Peak Human”
- Top Tiers should be “Class 5 to Class 25”
Where we disagree is on Mid-Tiers
I propose “At least Athletic Human, Likely Peak Human, possibly Higher.” For the following reasons
- Low Tiers and Mid-Tiers are not particularly far apart, and Low Tiers are very low down in Athletic Human, so it’s more than possible they share a tier, hence the acknowledgment of Athletic Human
- They are still world class Heavyweight Athletes, so Peak Human is the most likely destination
- There are some potential feats that would put them above Peak Human, and while I generally disagree with them, I felt it right to acknowledge the possibility of a higher LS being there.
@RandomGuy2345 proposes “At least Athletic Human, Likely Peak Human, possibly Class 5”
- They are less happy with an acknowledgment of Athletic Human when compared to me, but still support it FRA
- Agree with likely Peak Human FRA
- They argue that “Higher” should instead be “Class 5”, as Mid-Tiers have at times competed with Top-Tiers in shows of strength (Arm Wrestling Contests, Tug of War matches, etc.)
I do not wish to make and debunk Random’s argument for him, but I will note I disagree with Class 5 going anywhere near Mid-Tiers. I’ll let Random respond with his reasoning for Class 5, I’ll post my refutes, and ultimately staff will make final call.
Essentially to shorten it we scale wayyyyy to many people to the “Strongmen” of the franchise when really the only people even remotely comparable to them are each other. I always want to point out how the normal Wrestlers have some pretty major anti-feats, such as The Demon Finn Bálor struggling to powerbomb a 124KG Bobby Lashley, which is barely Athletic Human. It’s also outright stated that Base Finn wouldn’t have managed the feat at all.
With this in tow, some new scaling propositions
I had informed @RandomGuy2345 in advance of the creation of this CRT I was planning on these revisions, and we ended up hitting a bit of a crossroads where we have been unable to agree (I know I know ironic considering we’re tag champs and meant to have all this synergy and blah blah blah)
So we mostly agree on the creation of 3 tiers (Low, Mid, Too) and the general types who belong in those tiers:
Low: Cruiserweights (Finn Bálor, Rey Mysterio, etc.)
Mid: Heavyweights, “Powerhouses” (Austin Theory, John Cena, Sheamus, etc.)
Top: “Strongmen” (Mark Henry, Braun Strowman, Brock Lesnar, Big Show, etc.)
We also agreed on the following:
- Low Tiers should be “Athletic Human, Possibly Peak Human”
- Top Tiers should be “Class 5 to Class 25”
Where we disagree is on Mid-Tiers
I propose “At least Athletic Human, Likely Peak Human, possibly Higher.” For the following reasons
- Low Tiers and Mid-Tiers are not particularly far apart, and Low Tiers are very low down in Athletic Human, so it’s more than possible they share a tier, hence the acknowledgment of Athletic Human
- They are still world class Heavyweight Athletes, so Peak Human is the most likely destination
- There are some potential feats that would put them above Peak Human, and while I generally disagree with them, I felt it right to acknowledge the possibility of a higher LS being there.
@RandomGuy2345 proposes “At least Athletic Human, Likely Peak Human, possibly Class 5”
- They are less happy with an acknowledgment of Athletic Human when compared to me, but still support it FRA
- Agree with likely Peak Human FRA
- They argue that “Higher” should instead be “Class 5”, as Mid-Tiers have at times competed with Top-Tiers in shows of strength (Arm Wrestling Contests, Tug of War matches, etc.)
I do not wish to make and debunk Random’s argument for him, but I will note I disagree with Class 5 going anywhere near Mid-Tiers. I’ll let Random respond with his reasoning for Class 5, I’ll post my refutes, and ultimately staff will make final call.