- 1,371
- 558
Ayanokouji and Horikita fall 10 meters: This calculation would work if Ayanokouji and Horikita directly fell to the ground from 10 meters distance but that's clearly not the case as Ayanokouji states that they "went tumbling down the slope". Ayanokouji does not tank the full energy of the fall, making this calculation completely invalid.
Housen serves a tennis ball: The "as fast and powerful as a bullet" statement is made by the narrator of this arc, Suzune Horikita. This statement falls under "The Hasty Generalization Fallacy" as there is no way for Horikita to calculate the speed of the ball right there and make a statement like this. These kinds of statements are considered as unvalid statements in vs wiki standards. Moreover, Suzune (who has Athletic Human speed) was able to follow the ball with her eyes as she even said that the ball "rushed straight at Onodera" when the ball should be about 30 times faster than her reaction. This statement is just a Hyperbole which makes this calculation invalid.
Edit: The narrator in this feat is actually not Horikita but the "Bullet speed" statement still looks like flowery language which is a thing a lot of people agreed on.
Ayanokouji saves Horikita: I don't have a problem with this calculation as a whole but looking more deeply into an another source related to the punching speed used for this calculation, I found out that the 32 mph speed was clocked with a hook. Manabu clearly doesn't use a hook to attack Horikita here (0.17). I think the calculation should just stick to the average speed generated by professional-level boxers.
Edit 2: We decided to discard this whole calculation as the anime version of this feat (which is the source this calculation used) doesn't adapt the scene correctly so using the manga version of the feat is better to use. The revised calculation of the feat is here.
I think I made myself pretty clear but If anyone has any more questions, make sure to ask it peacefully so we can discuss it. Thanks for reading.
Agree: @HollowVanity , @TheShape03 , @Zefra3011 , @MorrisHatesYou , @DekuGlazer , @Nierre , @GoldenScorpions , @RoggerReggor , @ShionAH
Disagree: @Syncornize
Staff Approvals: @Mr._Bambu , @Deagonx
Housen serves a tennis ball: The "as fast and powerful as a bullet" statement is made by the narrator of this arc, Suzune Horikita. This statement falls under "The Hasty Generalization Fallacy" as there is no way for Horikita to calculate the speed of the ball right there and make a statement like this. These kinds of statements are considered as unvalid statements in vs wiki standards. Moreover, Suzune (who has Athletic Human speed) was able to follow the ball with her eyes as she even said that the ball "rushed straight at Onodera" when the ball should be about 30 times faster than her reaction. This statement is just a Hyperbole which makes this calculation invalid.
Edit: The narrator in this feat is actually not Horikita but the "Bullet speed" statement still looks like flowery language which is a thing a lot of people agreed on.
Ayanokouji saves Horikita: I don't have a problem with this calculation as a whole but looking more deeply into an another source related to the punching speed used for this calculation, I found out that the 32 mph speed was clocked with a hook. Manabu clearly doesn't use a hook to attack Horikita here (0.17). I think the calculation should just stick to the average speed generated by professional-level boxers.
Edit 2: We decided to discard this whole calculation as the anime version of this feat (which is the source this calculation used) doesn't adapt the scene correctly so using the manga version of the feat is better to use. The revised calculation of the feat is here.
I think I made myself pretty clear but If anyone has any more questions, make sure to ask it peacefully so we can discuss it. Thanks for reading.
Agree: @HollowVanity , @TheShape03 , @Zefra3011 , @MorrisHatesYou , @DekuGlazer , @Nierre , @GoldenScorpions , @RoggerReggor , @ShionAH
Disagree: @Syncornize
Staff Approvals: @Mr._Bambu , @Deagonx
Last edited: