Excellence616
He/Him- 6,042
- 4,356
Thanks for the info.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Naruto to Boruto Discussion Thread
- 11,749
- 16,164
No problem
- 2,282
- 1,337
Eh but madara black rods can nullify ninjustu as shown with sasuke amaterasu. But it cannot and was not able to do that to edo. Doesn't it suggest that nullifying ninjustu isn't what's causing it?
- 11,749
- 16,164
It literally did, though.
- 2,282
- 1,337
That's tso. I'm talking of the black rods madara consistently used as an edo before he got revived. They nullify ninjustu but never did they release the edo tensei
- 11,749
- 16,164
Oh you meant the Rinnegan rods? I misunderstood you. Anyway, those don't nullify ninjutsu.
- 1,012
- 540
If It neutralized Edo Tensei, why didn't Minato's soul have arms when Edo Tensei was corrupted
Last edited:
- 2,282
- 1,337
Well do you remember when madara wa trying to make obito use rinne rebirth? The scene where obito was instead resisting and doing the signs to be the 10 tails jinjuriki ? If I remember correctly sasuke fired a susanoo amaterasu arrow and madara used 3 rods to nullify it. Unless if I missed something
- 11,749
- 16,164
The argument goes that since Edo Tensei is a Jutsu that summons and binds souls from the Pure Land, then those bound souls were released from their binding and returned to the Pure Land when the TSO nullified the Jutsu.
As for why only the arms were released, that would be because the TSO only affects things that they make direct physical contact with, aka only the point of impact, which is the arm in this case.
- 11,749
- 16,164
He didn't nullify it, just kinda matched them in AP. It was a physical clash, no indication of anything else going on here.
- 2,282
- 1,337
I mean in the anime the flames was kinda completely put out. And ion think an ap clash is going to out out amaterasu. Sasuke also seemed very shocked. If it was a clash then the amaterasu should have still vaporised the rods. Kinda like itach and sasuke fire clash.
- 11,749
- 16,164
The arrows are still tangible physical objects, so even if the flames aren't put out, Madara still managed to stop them in their tracks, which is what he was going for.
You also gotta realize that the black receivers have never been shown or stated to have the ability to nullify ninjutsu, so it'd be a massive assumption to assert that they do solely based on this interaction and nothing else. This is especially true when this interaction in and of itself isn't a clear cut showcase of power null imo.
- 2,282
- 1,337
I will also like to point out that the rods also negated edo regen. Tobirama could not regen anymore same as hashirama.
I think madara Rinnegan rods are different from nagato. Maybe Coz edo madara kinda has low budget hagoromo chakra his rods somewhat mimick some qualities of tso?
So like it's not just one instant. Nullifying edo regen is still part of Nullifying ninjustu. But it still didn't affect the soul
- 2,282
- 1,337
No like I'm saying in the anime the flames were completely put out like turned off. For a hax like amaterasu doesn't that strike you as power null? And yes it is just one scene which is why I just cited another. They also nulled edo regen.
I think we need to stop treating madara rods like pain.
And for the fact that the rod did not null sakura regen but edo regen also points more to the fact that it is nullifying edo tensei itself
- 11,749
- 16,164
It didn't nullify their regeneration, it just paralyzed them (which is an established ability of the rods) . Once they were removed, they regenerated just fine. You can't really heal with something still embedded in your wound after all.
- 2,282
- 1,337
I know they did regen eventually but it nullified it for a while. Even the entire time that tobirama had his removed he didn't regen. He still had the holes there. I think they all regened when the rods completely stopped existing when madara kaguya and that kinda makes sense
- 11,749
- 16,164
Karo, come on, of course they wouldn't regenerate when the rods were literally still inside them
And Edos don't always regenerate instantly, sometimes they take a little bit.
- 4,327
- 2,978
The Black Receivers also cause Chakra Disruption if it impales you which Tobirama notes when he's unable to move, heal, or do anything to help a dying Sasuke.
- 2,282
- 1,337
Eh well true sha. So my agenda just has one shaky feat. DamnKaro, come on, of course they wouldn't regenerate when the rods were literally still inside them
And Edos don't always regenerate instantly, sometimes they take a little bit.
- 11,749
- 16,164
Look Imma be honest with you, I can kinda see both sides, cause it's not really something super conclusive. I just feel like the power null interpretation is slightly more supported and can be arrived at with less assumptions. That's the only reason I favor it, for now.
- 4,327
- 2,978
I made the Discussion Rule for TSO given that the evidence provided to us through the Databooks and Manga don't actually support Soul Erasure when TSO's basic nullification property already explains the effect.
You have to make a large assumption that contradicts the initial nullification statement in conjunction with the original scene of Edo's not regenerating.
I was tired of multiple threads of the same argument and thought the upcoming Boruto manga (at the time) would bring back TSO but hey Kishimoto forgot all about them.
You have to make a large assumption that contradicts the initial nullification statement in conjunction with the original scene of Edo's not regenerating.
I was tired of multiple threads of the same argument and thought the upcoming Boruto manga (at the time) would bring back TSO but hey Kishimoto forgot all about them.
- 11,749
- 16,164
Yeah, it's a shame. I really wanted a lot of the concepts introduced in late part 2 to get expanded upon, but oh well.
- 4,327
- 2,978
I've completely abandoned any thought of Kishi bringing back old concepts or even utilizing the Rinnegan efficiently.
Kishi made Adult Sasuke the worst Rinnegan user ever and forgot about every single Path.
- 11,749
- 16,164
The anime and novels mitigate this slightly, but the manga is atrocious in this regard 100%.
- 4,327
- 2,978
True, but I disregard them since Kishi didn't have creative control over them.
Plus the anime is just straight-up not canon with all its contradictions to the manga.
Amenotejikara this and that, Sasuke running out of Chakra... imagine if he had an ability that let's him absorb Chakra? Oh.
- 11,749
- 16,164
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 21,381
- 9,048
That's actually kind of an insane AP Feat that Madara can neg a Susano'o Arrow just like that without even using his own Susano'o. Remember when those were shown blitzing people who were comparable in speed to MS Sasuke?
MinatoSparkle
He/Him- 7,271
- 4,036
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 21,381
- 9,048
MinatoSparkle
He/Him- 7,271
- 4,036
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 21,381
- 9,048
MinatoSparkle
He/Him- 7,271
- 4,036
XSOULOFCINDERX
They/Them- 21,381
- 9,048
HelloThere1089
He/Him- 3,287
- 4,018
Choji Villain arc when?Buddy pointed this out to me
Kishi def did this on purpose lmfao
HelloThere1089
He/Him- 3,287
- 4,018
10 Tails oiled up twerkingKawaki saying he'd winCode being a fraud as usualKishimoto's never ending agenda of capping the verse at moon level
- 16,103
- 12,094
Code gonna have to become a 10 tails Jinchuuriki or he's going to be a Boruto victim forever.
Also, Boruto is wrecking everyone rn, has Kawaki not been practicing?
HelloThere1089
He/Him- 3,287
- 4,018
I just found out about the verse downgrading to 5-C lmao.
Suddenly Code's internal organs being 5-C is not so lame now is it. Imagine Code's pancreas being able to solo Shippuden.
HelloThere1089
He/Him- 3,287
- 4,018
Code's gonna be a jobber until maybe he gets his Shigaraki-esque moment. And then will either turn good(which I doubt. He's a sheep through and through) or die.
Why would he? He's got daddy Amado. Also that's in line with his dichotomy with Boruto.
- 3,255
- 1,974
Is that comment about internals from part 1 still true?
