• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
How can anyone argue that TSO isn't EE when it was explicitly stated that edo Minato and the other edos could "die" again if they got hit by the TSO.
It was already confirmed by tobirama. That was because it negated ninjustu. And the edo kages bodies were ninjustu which was why they could not comeback.

Sakura was stabbed by tso and legit regenerated right after cause her body is not ninjustu
 
It was already confirmed by tobirama. That was because it negated ninjustu. And the edo kages bodies were ninjustu which was why they could not comeback.

Sakura was stabbed by tso and legit regenerated right after cause her body is not ninjustu
why was Minato's soul still missing his arms when ascending from the Edo Tensei then?
 
It was already confirmed by tobirama. That was because it negated ninjustu. And the edo kages bodies were ninjustu which was why they could not comeback.
Then it's up to you to actually prove Tobirama was lying. It doesn't matter what specific condition it takes for TSO to affect anyone or anything. As long as it completely prevents souls from coming back to life, then it's existence erasure gg. Edo tenseis are shown regenerating from virtually anything even durability negating attacks. They were shown regenerating from Ohnoki's atomic dismantling jutsu yet they can't even come back from a TSO attack. Look what happened to Minato's arm even after his soul left his edo tensei vessel we could still see his soul, but without his arm.
Sakura was stabbed by tso and legit regenerated right after cause her body is not ninjustu
I think it's common knowledge that the only reason she survived that attack is because Madara never added yin release to his attack.
 
Then it's up to you to actually prove Tobirama was lying. It doesn't matter what specific condition it takes for TSO to affect anyone or anything. As long as it completely prevents souls from coming back to life, then it's existence erasure gg. Edo tenseis are shown regenerating from virtually anything even durability negating attacks. They were shown regenerating from Ohnoki's atomic dismantling jutsu yet they can't even come back from a TSO attack. Look what happened to Minato's arm even after his soul left his edo tensei vessel we could still see his soul, but without his arm.
Yeah cause TSO negate jutsu, so they wouldn't come back since the edo tensei got negated.
 
You can't simple determine what is narrative statement and what isn't. Especially with characters who have 0 knowledge on a ability. The term erased is used figuratively a lot in fiction. So that's even more reason not to take this statement seriously.
Hashirama has never read Hagoromo's stone or seen the rinnegan while he was alive , but he knew about Rinne Tensei. Tobirama had knowledge of Onmyouton, he wouldn't say something about if he didn't know about it.
 
And this discussion is kind of irrelevant, your crying will not change the classification of gudoudamas. Already tried several times and failed.
 
I think it's common knowledge that the only reason she survived that attack is because Madara never added yin release to his attack.
I think here on this site the common knowledge is that he used a black receiver. There's even a discussion rule for that.
 
I think here on this site the common knowledge is that he used a black receiver. There's even a discussion rule for that.
Nope. The rules are for trying to upgrade TSO into soul erasures.
e8B8EEc.png
 
Then explain why we could see Minato's soul even outside the edo tensei vessel
Theirs no explanation at very best you can argue soul manipulation. EE is a stretch without any explanation.

Tbh i don't think it's soul manipulation either cause the way naruto souls work is kinda odd. Characters can suffer physical injuries and it will reflect on their soul body. Minato had his soul jacket originally but when he took it off when he became edo his soul jacket was gone. So naruto souls just work kinda weird in general. So unless it's explained why his soul arms are gone. I don't think you can apply any interpretation
 
Then it's up to you to actually prove Tobirama was lying. It doesn't matter what specific condition it takes for TSO to affect anyone or anything. As long as it completely prevents souls from coming back to life, then it's existence erasure gg. Edo tenseis are shown regenerating from virtually anything even durability negating attacks. They were shown regenerating from Ohnoki's atomic dismantling jutsu yet they can't even come back from a TSO attack. Look what happened to Minato's arm even after his soul left his edo tensei vessel we could still see his soul, but without his arm.

I think it's common knowledge that the only reason she survived that attack is because Madara never added yin release to his attack.
Madara never adding yin yang release is not proven at all and it makes no sense why wouldn't have it added and the db directly says madaras tbb has yin yang.

And again your ignoring context it's stated they don't come back cause the justu is negated. Minato lossing his soul arms is up for interpretation. That doesn't mean EE. You don't know if they can still come back later on or if tso can completely destroy souls. Soul reapers can cutt and damage souls does that mean they have soul EE? No
 
Madara when he stabbed Sakura used a TSB but it didn't activate any of its properties he was basically using TSB as a stick, he also throws it at Sakura in chapter 675 before Obito get her out of there, but the stick simply pierces a wall of the kamui and gets stuck in the wall, and the TSB was smeared with blood from Sakura too, further proof that Madara can turn TSB properties on and off, "just as we already knew".
 
Last edited:
It's directly stated multiple times that TSO's erase things like Ninjutsu, including the Edo Tensei body of people like Tobirama.

The onus would be on Reio to prove that "erased" in the context of these scans wouldn't imply Existence Erasure but rather something else entirely, which isn't something i believe is provable since nothing in the series inherently contradicts the assertion that "erased" in the context of these scans would imply EE. Which is the action of erasing something from existence itself, an effect that TSO's are directly stated to do.

In the lens of Occam's Razor Reio's claim requires more assumptions compared to the claim that "erased" means Existence Erasure rather then someone sort of Deconstruction or Soul Manipulation. since neither actually "erase" you from anything while Existence Erasure does "erase" you.
 
Hey by the logic of random people being the author passing on information or whatever that means this is WoG, and the meme of city level Ten tails is real.
8626643-2022-08-2018_36_17-0613-009.png%281066%C3%971600%29.png
Ahh yes. Let's act like the Juubi didn't also do this.

8361999-7157131-juubidama-coloredscan.png


Juubi destroyed a random stray city with his bomb but doesn't mean he only caps at that level. He can make over a thousand times bigger. It's not like Hiashi said the Juubi could only destroy a city.
 
Ahh yes. Let's act like the Juubi didn't also do this.

8361999-7157131-juubidama-coloredscan.png


Juubi destroyed a random stray city with his bomb but doesn't mean he only caps at that level. He can make over a thousand times bigger. It's not like Hiashi said the Juubi could only destroy a city.
Looks like city level + if I squint really hard.
 
Leave for a few hrs and I see Undre still going


God damn does Naruto live rent free in this man's head


Wait till the Bleach Anime gives some sweet low ends and this ***** finna defend to his dying breath
 
I actually think the anime will make higher end metas more viable, they'll probably go hard for stuff like Gremmy's creation of outer space and jerk that off, as well as animate the end chapter sketches of the Yhwach fight to show the possible bad futures (one sketch shows the destruction of a galaxy).
 
I actually think the anime will make higher end metas more viable, they'll probably go hard for stuff like Gremmy's creation of outer space and jerk that off, as well as animate the end chapter sketches of the Yhwach fight to show the possible bad futures (one sketch shows the destruction of a galaxy).

Then Gin comes back to life and proceeds to blitz SK Yhwach with his Mach 500 Zanpakuto with Yhwach even stating the power to see into the future means nothing against someone so fast
 
Back
Top