- 16,993
- 22,819
Premise
Edo Itachi, KCM1 Naruto, and BM Killer B bust Nagato's Chibaku Tensei. Since the attacks are all portrayed as relative to each other, they should all scale to 1/3 of Nagato's CT value.
Potential Energy
So, from what I've seen and what I've been told is that this has been rejected because the CT wasn't fully formed and therefore destroying the core wouldn't scale to the full value. However, I find that reasoning a bit faulty and let me explain why.
CT gets its value based on the amount of mass it was shown to be capable of lifting a certain height above Earth's surface. This is all done by the core itself, and is independent of the rocks. For example, if I use my hand to lift a book to increase its potential energy, its my hand thats capable of lifting that book and regardless of if that book is there my hand can always do that work to increase that potential energy. All this means is that regardless of if there is mass to be lifted in the vicinity or if the CT is up in the sky not near anything, the CT contains the energy required to lift the mass of rock we see earlier in the story. To tie it back to the hand analogy, just because the book isn't in my hand doesn't mean my hand can't provide the work necessary to increase said potential energy.
To claim that they didn't destroy the max mass of rock the CT can lift means they can't scale is incorrect, because the energy required to lift said mass of rock comes from the black core itself. So, if they can overcome and destroy that core, they would scale to the energy value of that core. If the calc was them pulverizing the amount of rock, then yes the amount of rock would be important; however, that's not what's happening. Itachi, B, and Naruto are destroying the CT core which contains enough energy (~15 GT) to lift a large mass of rock above the surface of the Earth, it possesses that energy regardless of if it's surrounding the core at that point in time.
Conclusion
I don't think B's tier would change (this would just function as another supporting feat for him I guess), but KCM1 Naruto's rasenshuriken and Itachi's susanoo should get upgraded
.
Edo Itachi, KCM1 Naruto, and BM Killer B bust Nagato's Chibaku Tensei. Since the attacks are all portrayed as relative to each other, they should all scale to 1/3 of Nagato's CT value.
Potential Energy
So, from what I've seen and what I've been told is that this has been rejected because the CT wasn't fully formed and therefore destroying the core wouldn't scale to the full value. However, I find that reasoning a bit faulty and let me explain why.
CT gets its value based on the amount of mass it was shown to be capable of lifting a certain height above Earth's surface. This is all done by the core itself, and is independent of the rocks. For example, if I use my hand to lift a book to increase its potential energy, its my hand thats capable of lifting that book and regardless of if that book is there my hand can always do that work to increase that potential energy. All this means is that regardless of if there is mass to be lifted in the vicinity or if the CT is up in the sky not near anything, the CT contains the energy required to lift the mass of rock we see earlier in the story. To tie it back to the hand analogy, just because the book isn't in my hand doesn't mean my hand can't provide the work necessary to increase said potential energy.
To claim that they didn't destroy the max mass of rock the CT can lift means they can't scale is incorrect, because the energy required to lift said mass of rock comes from the black core itself. So, if they can overcome and destroy that core, they would scale to the energy value of that core. If the calc was them pulverizing the amount of rock, then yes the amount of rock would be important; however, that's not what's happening. Itachi, B, and Naruto are destroying the CT core which contains enough energy (~15 GT) to lift a large mass of rock above the surface of the Earth, it possesses that energy regardless of if it's surrounding the core at that point in time.
Conclusion
I don't think B's tier would change (this would just function as another supporting feat for him I guess), but KCM1 Naruto's rasenshuriken and Itachi's susanoo should get upgraded
.
