• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

My Hero Academia General Discussion Thread #18

Considering that Star used the air around her to make the giant, the Giant Star is actually less denser than the air above ocean level and therefore should be floating (air is less and less dense the higher you are).
 
Considering that Star used the air around her to make the giant, the Giant Star is actually less denser than the air above ocean level and therefore should be floating.
Seems like a stretch dude. Let's wait for the crt I dont really wanna waste my time calcing the feat in several different ways just to prove my point
 
Ahh hell nah just checked the stars and stripes calc again and did some pixel scaling with 3 different methods.
First method got a diameter 116 times lower than the calc l.
Second one got a diameter 390 times lower and the third method which uses rustys own Pixel scaling got diameter results 65 times lower. Y'all def ain't winning this debate when the crt comes
 
Was there anyway cathleen could have defeated shigaraki without dying?
Not sure if she could do this with her power but maybe she could say “The air 100 meters in front of me will burst into flames” or “Time will stop within a 50 meter radius of me” or something like that

I feel like Star has way more potential for her power than what she displayed
 
Not sure if she could do this with her power but maybe she could say “The air 100 meters in front of me will burst into flames” or “Time will stop within a 50 meter radius of me” or something like that

I feel like Star has way more potential for her power than what she displayed
Agreed. Her Quirk literally bends Reality to her whims and she still got beat by Shigaraki despite having bullshit potential.
 
Was there anyway cathleen could have defeated shigaraki without dying?
No. When she realized she couldn't effect him with New Order as she didn't know his "true name", she also knew that she'd be unable to kill him.

If she had another method of killing him that was more effective than the missiles, she would've used that instead. That's why her Quirk is powerful, but very limited. We know she can't do everything, and she can't kill Shigaraki unless she knew his true name.
 
Not sure if she could do this with her power but maybe she could say “The air 100 meters in front of me will burst into flames” or “Time will stop within a 50 meter radius of me” or something like that

I feel like Star has way more potential for her power than what she displayed
She was just used to demonstrate how dangerous AFO shig is.

I mean there had to be someway she could have beatin him without dying.

Also when she destroyed all the quirks inside of his body, was shig just left with only AFO and decay?
 
Question when she ordered all the quirks inside his body destroyed, why did it harm Him so much if it’s just quirks destroyed?

also was the only reason he survived was because of regeneration? (If that’s the case why didn’t it destroy the regen quirk)

why didn’t it destroy AFO and decay either considering their both quirks too.
 
Also when she destroyed all the quirks inside of his body, was shig just left with only AFO and decay?
The only Quirk we got confirmation that was destroyed was Reflect. She visibly destroys more, but we don't know what they were.

I think she might have destroyed his regeneration as well? Since one of the Near High-Ends at Octo Island lost their regeneration. Since we know Regeneration is standard for the Upper/High-End Nomu, it's very unusual for a High-End to not have regen. Either Shiggy took it or Horikoshi is planning something else with that line.

Quirks are physical abilities, it makes sense that destroying them would physically harm him. They aren't spiritual powers or something.
 
The only Quirk we got confirmation that was destroyed was Reflect. She visibly destroys more, but we don't know what they were.

I think she might have destroyed his regeneration as well? Since one of the Near High-Ends at Octo Island lost their regeneration. Since we know Regeneration is standard for the Upper/High-End Nomu, it's very unusual for a High-End to not have regen. Either Shiggy took it or Horikoshi is planning something else with that line.

Quirks are physical abilities, it makes sense that destroying them would physically harm him. They aren't spiritual powers or something.
Why didn’t it destroy every single quirk though?
 
Why didn’t it destroy every single quirk though?
Because it couldn't. That's kind of similar to asking why Star couldn't make herself stronger than All Might. She just can't, her Quirk isn't strong enough to do it.

Her Vestige was killed by fighting the other Quirks inside of AFO. She'd have to get through all of his Quirks before she could land a fatal strike on Shiggy or AFO.
 
Because it couldn't. That's kind of similar to asking why Star couldn't make herself stronger than All Might. She just can't, her Quirk isn't strong enough to do it.

Her Vestige was killed by fighting the other Quirks inside of AFO. She'd have to get through all of his Quirks before she could land a fatal strike on Shiggy or AFO.
Speaking of his quirks. If you had to make a guess though, how many quirks does shig have left?
 
Speaking of his quirks. If you had to make a guess though, how many quirks does shig have left?
Hundreds probably. I doubt AFO didn't have Shiggy take some extra Quirks if he could. If I'm right that he lost regeneration and took it from that Near High-End.

Who knows what other Quirks he could've stolen. From villains or maybe some Quirks Garaki had in stock somewhere. They have hideouts the heroes never found. Like where AFO found the Modified Rewind bullets. Maybe there was a stockpile of Quirks for Shiggy to "refuel" at.

Though this is assuming AFO can take Quirks the Doctor extracts/copies from people. This is all speculation. I'm sure he has a large number of powers. I don't think New Order took out that many, the main thing was causing his completion time to go back. Giving the heroes more time to prepare.
 
Hundreds probably. I doubt AFO didn't have Shiggy take some extra Quirks if he could. If I'm right that he lost regeneration and took it from that Near High-End.

Who knows what other Quirks he could've stolen. From villains or maybe some Quirks Garaki had in stock somewhere. They have hideouts the heroes never found. Like where AFO found the Modified Rewind bullets. Maybe there was a stockpile of Quirks for Shiggy to "refuel" at.

Though this is assuming AFO can take Quirks the Doctor extracts/copies from people. This is all speculation. I'm sure he has a large number of powers. I don't think New Order took out that many, the main thing was causing his completion time to go back. Giving the heroes more time to prepare.
I realized something If there was a quirk that you basically an instant expert in anything and All For one got it, he could give it to shig and basically make him more OP.

remember how AFO said he didn’t want jeanist’s quirk as it requires lots of training and skill. Well if there was a quirk that made you an instant expert in anything it could help deal with that problem.

just give it shig and he can master every quirk he has (and AFO could just give him any quirk he wants since there’s no need to worry about training and skill anymore) that is assuming such a. Quirk exists
 
Because it couldn't. That's kind of similar to asking why Star couldn't make herself stronger than All Might. She just can't, her Quirk isn't strong enough to do it.

Her Vestige was killed by fighting the other Quirks inside of AFO. She'd have to get through all of his Quirks before she could land a fatal strike on Shiggy or AFO.
Not exactly. AFO ditched her quirk in some random and planned to wait until he figured out how to pacify it, but then New Order destroyed itself. At least that's what I remember.
 
I definitely feel Shiggy needs more support type and unconventional type quirks rather than just pure power quirks.
 
I definitely feel Shiggy needs more support type and unconventional type quirks rather than just pure power quirks.
Unfortunately, Shigaraki is handicapped by the “AFO gets quirks that are simple because he’s too dumb to use complicated ones challenge (Difficulty: Impossible)”
 
Unfortunately, Shigaraki is handicapped by the “AFO gets quirks that are simple because he’s too dumb to use complicated ones challenge (Difficulty: Impossible)”
If Nen abilities, Stands and Cursed techniques were biological and AFO tried to use them, it would be the equivalent of asking a mentally challenged toddler to write a college thesis
 
This was a peak episode, Deku vs Muscular was animated really well. I don't need 24/7 sakuga, but if we can keep the quality of this episode for the rest of the season, then I will be very satisfied with Season 6. In general, I'm very happy with how things are progressing, hope the season keeps this up
 
Back
Top