-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Murata declares his own statements not "Word of God"
- Thread starter Scumerage
- Start date
-
- Tags
- boros garou one-punch man saitama
- Status
- 20,541
- 17,454
> Do we treat narrative in Murata's version of the manga as non-canon? Dialogue? Feats?
If its in the manga, then its been approved by ONE. So anything there is fine.
> So, presuming at least some, what parts of Murata's manga will be considered non-canon, given this new info?
Nah, only his WoG quotes that aren't prefaced with "ONE told me/I asked ONE and he said x" are ignored.
If its in the manga, then its been approved by ONE. So anything there is fine.
> So, presuming at least some, what parts of Murata's manga will be considered non-canon, given this new info?
Nah, only his WoG quotes that aren't prefaced with "ONE told me/I asked ONE and he said x" are ignored.
- 61,177
- 14,747
All of the stuff Murata said in streams and blogs and whatnot will be considered non-canon
- 20,541
- 17,454
ONE has complete control over what is allowed in the manga due to owning the copyright. Think of it less like a Manga and more like a Comic in this regards. The artist is not in charge of the story, the author/editor is and they can veto what he draws. Anything that's in the manga has been written and/or approved by ONE, so they would be canon. Like how the Boruto manga is approved by the original Naruto author.
- 548
- 306
@Qawsedf234
Ok, I had to check back on some stuff. So, in regard to PPP > DSK and Geryuganshoop having sub-light attack speed. I have no answer.
But when it comes to Saitama being a planetary statement. I have answers.
When looking back at the Korean stream and the translation founded in the reddit post you provided above. The statements in the Webcomic from ONE are still canon. So, either Saitama Webcomic page needs to be created or a note left on Saitama current page.
2. The rest involving Murata statement of Saitama being planetary are still justified by the Hero Encyclopedia aka Databook. However, the problem is vsbattle wiki doesn't accept OPM databook even though it was created by ONE and drawn by Murata.
"Like, except "They are in Hero Encyclopedia" or "ONE sensei said that" all things I said are only my guess." <--Murata. His guess isn't off because it was confirmed in the Databook in regard to Saitama feat.
Ok, I had to check back on some stuff. So, in regard to PPP > DSK and Geryuganshoop having sub-light attack speed. I have no answer.
But when it comes to Saitama being a planetary statement. I have answers.
When looking back at the Korean stream and the translation founded in the reddit post you provided above. The statements in the Webcomic from ONE are still canon. So, either Saitama Webcomic page needs to be created or a note left on Saitama current page.
2. The rest involving Murata statement of Saitama being planetary are still justified by the Hero Encyclopedia aka Databook. However, the problem is vsbattle wiki doesn't accept OPM databook even though it was created by ONE and drawn by Murata.
"Like, except "They are in Hero Encyclopedia" or "ONE sensei said that" all things I said are only my guess." <--Murata. His guess isn't off because it was confirmed in the Databook in regard to Saitama feat.
- 20,541
- 17,454
> The statements in the Webcomic from ONE are still canon. So, either Saitama Webcomic page needs to be created or a note left on Saitama current page.
ONE writes both stories. So it was likely just retconned out of existence
> still justified by the Hero Encyclopedia aka Databook.
The databook is accepted, its just that it was decided that the comment does not support Boros being 5-B because in Japanese the kanji for destroy means destroy in a figurative sense and not a literal sense
ONE writes both stories. So it was likely just retconned out of existence
> still justified by the Hero Encyclopedia aka Databook.
The databook is accepted, its just that it was decided that the comment does not support Boros being 5-B because in Japanese the kanji for destroy means destroy in a figurative sense and not a literal sense
- 548
- 306
I didn't know about that thread. Thank you for the update.
- 7,330
- 1,302
Noticeably despite the nerfs this might buff up some feats.
Like Murata saying that Eye Monster Tatsumaki fought being only capable of tossing buildings.
Like Murata saying that Eye Monster Tatsumaki fought being only capable of tossing buildings.
- 20,541
- 17,454
The thought of a random fodder monster being High 6-C is hilarious in a sense.
- 12,562
- 2,517
I still think Saitama, Garou and Boros should keep Relavistic, via Garou being immensely faster than Flashy Flash when holding back. If we were willing to not scale Flash to Garou back then cause the speed gap was logically massive, we should use the same logic here.
- 20,541
- 17,454
My original idea was a Rel rating, but it was suggested that's not the way we do it. So I dunno. Garou should be 1.7x Flashy's speed when going all out. If not him than at least Saitama.
- 29
- 6
Aren't you that guy on the One Punch Man subreddit? Scumerage?
- 20,541
- 17,454
Me? Nah I'm Qawsedf234. I'm usually always that user name.
- 29
- 6
I was talking about OP... not youQawsedf234 said:
And ****, I'm an enormous One Punch Man fanboy, so this kills me. The recent downgrades from City/Mountain level to Town level, nearly killed me, but this is gonna finish me off. I want to cry. Why the **** can't I just get light speed star level Saitama.... That's all I'm ******* asking for ONE...
Just downgrades after downgrades. Soon enough Saitama is gonna be reduced to 10-B or something.
- 20,541
- 17,454
> I was talking about OP... not you
Ah, my bad then
> That's all I'm ******* asking for ONE
There's still that inevitible fight with God that could bump him up a few tiers. Might take a decade to get there though.
Ah, my bad then
> That's all I'm ******* asking for ONE
There's still that inevitible fight with God that could bump him up a few tiers. Might take a decade to get there though.
- 29
- 6
I'm tired of tier 7 OPM. I'm so ******* tired of it. Dammit ONE.Qawsedf234 said:
- 14
- 0
Is all OPM affected by this?
- 31,400
- 27,690
No.SakuraDorms said:
Just anything impacted from an unofficial Murata quote.
- 11,099
- 4,323
Who is going to be downgraded?
- 63,529
- 8,506
Saitama to High 6A I think
- 31,400
- 27,690
Also Pri-pri Prisoner.
Does anyone know where the quote about the Giant Crow comes from?
Does anyone know where the quote about the Giant Crow comes from?
- 22,383
- 18,589
- 31,400
- 27,690
Okay, then that statement is legit but the one about the random monster that was as strong as the Deep Sea King probably isn't legit.
- 31,400
- 27,690
That's been effectively retconned out of the manga for now since the scene where he said it no longer exists in the manga unless it has been moved to a later point that the manga hasn't reached yet.Konaguna said:
- 9,253
- 2,731
"The World" (Not his one) can very well mean just the surface of the planet.
- 1,178
- 407
Multi-continent Saitama. I told you
- 11,135
- 14,120
I see there was confusion in this thread. This doesn't affect how we treat his manga. It only affects how we treat his statements in interviews and such. He only mentions that when he says something in an interview etc, unless he quotes ONE, it's all his personal opinion.
Udlmaster
They/Them- 6,925
- 2,128
"B-but, S-Saitama can one punch anyone, guh, this is downplay, GRRR, your not getting the joke, Saitama is a Gag character, he solos all of fiction GRRRRR."
I've debated people who thought Saitama beats people like Yukari Yakumo, or the God Emp and only stalemated with Bugs Bunny and Omnipotent beings because "muh gag character"
I'm actually glad to see OPM downgraded because people wank him so hard.
I've debated people who thought Saitama beats people like Yukari Yakumo, or the God Emp and only stalemated with Bugs Bunny and Omnipotent beings because "muh gag character"
I'm actually glad to see OPM downgraded because people wank him so hard.
- 63,529
- 8,506
That's not a reason to see him downgraded, that's shallow
Anyway, AP wise Saitama should scale to being massively superior to Boros's Roaring Cannon, which is 500 Pettatons
Anyway, AP wise Saitama should scale to being massively superior to Boros's Roaring Cannon, which is 500 Pettatons
- 8,229
- 1,487
It may be a downgrade but at least Saitama has a chance at having an AP advantage now
Udlmaster
They/Them- 6,925
- 2,128
What? I'm not saying OPM should be downgraded because I don't like it, I'm saying, I'm glad to see it get downgraded (Some of the Speed feats are based on statements from the Word of God).Gargoyle One said:
I think you need to read my wording a bit better because you're misundering what I wrote.
- 12,562
- 2,517
"I'm saying, I'm glad to see it get downgraded (Some of the Speed feats are based on statements from the Word of God)."
I also don't see how one person calling Saitama omnipotent is anything but a poor reason to want to see a verse downgraded, but whatever, let's stop derailing.
I also don't see how one person calling Saitama omnipotent is anything but a poor reason to want to see a verse downgraded, but whatever, let's stop derailing.
- 63,529
- 8,506
Uhh what?
"I'm actually glad to see OPM downgraded downgraded because people want him so hard"
You're words, not mine, that's the textbook definition of wanting to see him downgraded
If that's not what you were trying to say, you worded it badly.
"I'm actually glad to see OPM downgraded downgraded because people want him so hard"
You're words, not mine, that's the textbook definition of wanting to see him downgraded
If that's not what you were trying to say, you worded it badly.
- Status
