• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Maou Gakuin Discussion Thread

Well, it would be helpful if you could link the thread where Immortality type 5 was proposed and rejected.
I tried searching for Ramadhanday CRT via the search function (maybe because I'm dumb), but I couldn't find the CRT pertaining to immortality type 5 addition to the verse.

All I could find was a Speed upgrade about Silver Sea Key for the character.
There was such a CRT for type 5 for gods and it sis get rejected but for some reason I also can't seem to find older CRTs such as that one in which 99 layers were accepted.
 
I'm going to give you some help on what can be changed to improve the profile, and again, I'm basing myself on what's in the profile.

First let's change the powers that are wrong.

BFR: Through Forced Reincarnation (this seems to me just resuscitation for the sake of explanation, apart from being without reference or scan to have a base of what it is, so if this is a spell I don't even know what it does)

Statistics Reduction: The cold air from artieltonoa drains opponents of their physical strength and magic power (this is clearly Absorption, must be changed)

Holy Manipulation: God's are holy existences (you need to show that they can manipulate holy energy, not just say they are holy beings)

Resistance to Poison Manipulation (this is more of a personal opinion, but getting drunk literally affects your brain which messes with your hand-eye coordination and stuff, in my opinion it has nothing to do with types of poison, but apparently they accept it, so then you choose )

Speed: Must be changed to Massively FTL with Infinite Combat Speed and Reactions

Now let's go to things that are unexplained in power, that we don't even know what it does, everything I list here should get an explanation of power and not just a "With", they use this when you already have a separate tab only for the explanation of the techniques, which in this case does not have.

Damage Boost
Dream and Memory Manipulation
Light Manipulation
Fusionism

Well, what's left to do is attach scans or references to the powers that are without.
 
I never knew there were threads about Arcana honestly
it was not an exclusive Arcana CRT, it was one of those that add powers to several characters in the back, and they tried to give immo type 5 to the Gods but it was rejected, but anyway I don't remember who made the CRT, it's been more than one year
 
Speed: Must be changed to Massively FTL with Infinite Combat Speed and Reactions
I've fixed this, tho going by the description, if she's capable of traveling through layers via own speed, she should have Infinite overall.
 
From what I gather.
The OP proposed type 7 (which is kinda dumb to give God immo type 7 based on that scan) and does not even understand immortality that much and didn't try to argue for type 5 which everyone (except Null) agrees to be some form of type 5.
It is not immortality type 7. I would disagree with it.
 
I'm going to give you some help on what can be changed to improve the profile, and again, I'm basing myself on what's in the profile.

First let's change the powers that are wrong.

BFR: Through Forced Reincarnation (this seems to me just resuscitation for the sake of explanation, apart from being without reference or scan to have a base of what it is, so if this is a spell I don't even know what it does)

Statistics Reduction: The cold air from artieltonoa drains opponents of their physical strength and magic power (this is clearly Absorption, must be changed)

Holy Manipulation: God's are holy existences (you need to show that they can manipulate holy energy, not just say they are holy beings)

Resistance to Poison Manipulation (this is more of a personal opinion, but getting drunk literally affects your brain which messes with your hand-eye coordination and stuff, in my opinion it has nothing to do with types of poison, but apparently they accept it, so then you choose )

Speed: Must be changed to Massively FTL with Infinite Combat Speed and Reactions

Now let's go to things that are unexplained in power, that we don't even know what it does, everything I list here should get an explanation of power and not just a "With", they use this when you already have a separate tab only for the explanation of the techniques, which in this case does not have.

Damage Boost
Dream and Memory Manipulation
Light Manipulation
Fusionism

Well, what's left to do is attach scans or references to the powers that are without.
anyway this should be fixed, i'm focusing on other verses at the moment so i can't do it
 
Alone lacking death grants u.
UOWuqfU.jpg
 
I do have some problem with why Sasha and Misha doesn't have high godly regeneration based on their gods transformation. I am not saying they should get HGR to normal state but they uses their gods transformation to utilise all of their gods order of creation and destruction so my point is they should get HGR. Well we can point that out in the note that only in their gods form. What do you guys think.
 
and about self-sustainability it's the same thing, the explanation doesn't imply any of that
It literally does, especially when they are showings of it. Arcana can sleep and eat doesn't mean she needs to.
She also has a feat of fighting inside a vacuum (no air)

I asked here if that statement was enough to get type 5 immortality and they agreed, coupled with the fact no god has been killed without CM/ existence erasure.
 
Last edited:
you giving "BFR" with an explanation of "can force reincarnation" that doesn't even make sense or has something to do with power, that would be resuscitation. Another thing is you putting CRTS powers that have already been rejected, such as type 5 immortality or type 1 Acausality, in addition to others, I'm just talking about that because the anime is about to be released and Arcana is a recurring character in the series and it will definitely be very visited
Graham forcing Anos to reincarnate inside aganzon was given BFR. If you forcefully reincarnate your opponent and they don't come back in time then that's BFR.

I've not seen a single thread that rejected immortality type 5, it also has 0 anti feats, acausality type 1 was already accepted when we updated lays profile, it just hasn't been applied for all characters.

Where have you been honestly? Most things you're finding issues with were already discussed here.
 
BFR: Through Forced Reincarnation (this seems to me just resuscitation for the sake of explanation, apart from being without reference or scan to have a base of what it is, so if this is a spell I don't even know what it does)
Already addressed this
Statistics Reduction: The cold air from artieltonoa drains opponents of their physical strength and magic power (this is clearly Absorption, must be changed)
No, its not absorption. I literally read through the entire arcs where these events happened. Anos just says it was draining shin of his magic power and physical strength (textbook stat redux)

Holy Manipulation: God's are holy existences (you need to show that they can manipulate holy energy, not just say they are holy beings)
This might be impossible. You'd have to search through entire arc's. Also isn't this wrong? If you're mad of holy energy you don't need to be shown manipulating it. Not to mention gods are the ones who gave holy magic and water to the humans, they are repeatedly "called divine beings"
Damage Boost
Dream and Memory Manipulation
Light Manipulation
Fusionism
First 3 are literally self explanatory.
Piercing= increased psi (the smaller the area a force is applied to, the higher the pressure).
Dream and memory manipulation= the memory part might need scans, i agree+ he's literally called the god of dreams.
Light manipulation (literally called the god of light, any kid should understand it)
Fusionism= Yeah, probably needs an explanation (she fussed shin's god slayer sword and evansmana together using artieltonoa to create livaingirma)
 
Yeah, I went through the thread. What was rejected was immortality type 7.

Others suggested type 5 for it (though no one tried to apply it). Null was against type 5 immortality (not heavily). His reason was it not being literal which I disagree with.

The scan literally says "gods are immortal and don't even live".
This isn't metaphorical in anyway especially when its from militia (literally the 1st god to exist alongside avernyu) and nousgalia (the HFG who governs order) literally no god will be more knowledgeable than them, what's more they say it the exact same way without using different words or expressions to describe it. It also attributes their immortality to the fact they don't live.

All this is further supported by the gods having only been killed with EE and CM
 
Yeah, I went through the thread. What was rejected was immortality type 7.

Others suggested type 5 for it (though no one tried to apply it). Null was against type 5 immortality (not heavily). His reason was it not being literal which I disagree with.

The scan literally says "gods are immortal and don't even live".
This isn't metaphorical in anyway especially when its from militia (literally the 1st god to exist alongside avernyu) and nousgalia (the HFG who governs order) literally no god will be more knowledgeable than them, what's more they say it the exact same way without using different words or expressions to describe it. It also attributes their immortality to the fact they don't live.

All this is further supported by the gods having only been killed with EE and CM
If Null is still alive.
I'm interested in hearing his reasoning against type 5 in elaboration.

The thread didn't really argue for type 5 and just drop it without much debating.
 
Back
Top