- 33,408
- 8,430
btw I am done with replying to this for today. I'll see how this thread develops by tomorrow.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'm just posting this again since nobody answered this.Nehz XZX said:If "conceptually in piece" is flowery language, in what state was Sora in the Final World and what were the Sora's he was collecting?
Even if hearts don't don't get accepted as concepts, Vanitas returning from getting his heart destroyed should be Mid-Godly Regenerationn since the body and the soul/mind got destroyed as well and regenerating from that is the definition for Mid-Godly on the page for Regenerationn. In fact it would be superior to regular Mid-Godly Regenerationn since the heart got destroyed too and is explicitly separate from the body and the soul/mind.Dragonmasterxyz said:Coming back from your heart being destroyed is simply returning from nothingness in some way shape or form.
We disagree with every single person being abstracts as we have noted above.
Many people (including people more knowledgeable on this stuff than I) also seem to agree that the OP is not convincing for the changes they wish to make. I do not have the time to constantly go in circles with Bob over this and so I will let others air their opinions on this.
Nobody argued for the soul to be a concept.DarkDragonMedeus said:The Soul is just a spiritual body, not an abstract concept. Example of an abstract concept or conceptual manipulation would be to erase the concept of pain. And now no one in the Universe/Multiverse can feel pain at all until someone recreates the concept of pain.
TBH I wouldn't mind this, as the issue appears that KH is too unique to properly fit into the current variants of Concept Manip, so perhaps some editing here and there is needed to deal with this sort of cases, assuming concepts indeed have to be "universal" in scale to qualify for concept manip, as apparently there's plenty of cases on the wiki where that's not the case and yet they have it.Nehz XZX said:Does that mean we need general revisions about Conceptual Manipulation?
Quoting because this seems to be important, as the "Non-Universal" concepts are the main thing of this CRT, so this can't really be properly discussed further without the CRT above being done first.Bobsican said:I guess I can go ahead and do a CRT over "Non-Universal" concepts regarding Concept Manip?
Just posting this again since nobody answered.Nehz XZX said:Regardless of whether or not individual hearts qualify as concepts, affecting Kingdom Hearts should qualify as type 2 Conceptual Manipulation. This would apply to the X-Blade for allowing it's user to control Kingdom Hearts and the regular Keyblade since the Guardians of Light managed to hold back Kingdom Hearts using their Keyblades. Can I go ahead and add it?