- 2,014
- 2,424
The anime had Malevolent Shrine turn Mahoraga into dust immediately and he healed from that which is a Mid-High regen feat
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Isn't it a rule that we can't make separate profiles for the anime version unless they have unique powers they don't have in the manga?The anime had Malevolent Shrine turn Mahoraga into dust immediately and he healed from that which is a Mid-High regen feat
Actually, from my understanding of the canon (feel free to correct me if I am wrong), if the anime can be considered secondary then extended fight scenes are fair game so long as there are no major plot contradictions. The most relevant text from the canon page beingStuff like that is allowed normally when the visuals of the manga aren't clear enough to get scale and such. I think we have old MHA calc which uses the anime for a feat Bakugo pulls off because figuring out scale was a mess. I won't act like I know the specifics behind this calc, but due to One's own style being on the more amateurish side I imagine the anime was allowed because it was just clearer.
And while I can understand frustration with the standard, it exist primarily because of what's being asked for here. The idea that the anime version will inflate the value of calculations and push stats far beyond what was intended with the manga. That's also why its asked for that direct statements from the author emerge in cases like this that essentially say the anime is the intended form for consumption.
andWhen different source materials give different versions of the same feat, and by that they contradict each other in the depiction of the feat, the primary canon takes precedence over the secondary canon.
Which directly infers that "entirely new feats" of secondary canon and details added to fight scenes, are okay for secondary canon so long as it isn't the same feat calced in the primary source and the results don't heavily contradict the narrative (such as place, time, etc).Entirely new feats of tertiary canon, like for example new abilities, should be disregarded. Details added to existing fight scenes, such as damage caused to the surroundings, can be accepted for text based media like books.
Actually
Please get back to calcing sir.
i mean, he cant adapt to what one shotted him right?So before fighting Yorozu Sukuna smoked Makora again & tamed 3 other Shikigamis.
When I watched latest episode realised Ten Shadow users themselves should tame the Shikigami. Any outside help to tame then would be make the ritual null.i mean, he cant adapt to what one shotted him right?
Wasn't that obviousWhen I watched latest episode realised Ten Shadow users themselves should tame the Shikigami
I forgot if it was stated in manga it's been a while I read it.Wasn't that obvious
When I watched latest episode realised Ten Shadow users themselves should tame the Shikigami. Any outside help to tame then would be make the ritual null.
I cant believe some people were comparing Ryomen Sukuna to ******* Lucifero man
I cant believe some people were comparing Ryomen Sukuna to ******* Lucifero man
How did that special grade got killed instantly but kenjaku is still alive? is that some sort of resistant or-
dude I've seen someone claim muzan from demon slayer is a better villain than sukunaYou mean the disappointment of Black clover?
That's utter disrespect for JJK Villains.
Nah Denim Shorts Lucifero > King of Frauds Sukuna FR /jdude I've seen someone claim muzan from demon slayer is a better villain than sukuna
Like man YOU WHAT!?
I understand that this is a "vague" distinction, but it's not precisely like that. Unless the anime version establishes a separate narrative canonicity, creating anime profiles is not permitted, as they are essentially adaptations from the original manga.Isn't it a rule that we can't make separate profiles for the anime version unless they have unique powers they don't have in the manga?
He is Michael Jacksondude I've seen someone claim muzan from demon slayer is a better villain than sukuna
Like man YOU WHAT!?
nah he talked about it way more and the Mappa CEO aka the devil himself also confirmed his participationAs far as I know Greg isn’t approving anything. The production asks him for feedback, and he says he gave them a half assed feedback. And it’s really half assed, dude said “as long as something something it should be fine”.
Clearly there’s no in depth collaboration between the anime production and Greg.
Again this is the only time I saw Greg stating something about the anime.
don't compare the king of pop to the king of fools pleaseHe is Michael Jackson
You can maybe use scans from the anime as support for the mangaIsn't it a rule that we can't make separate profiles for the anime version unless they have unique powers they don't have in the manga?
Nah Denim Shorts Lucifero > King of Frauds Sukuna FR /j
King Of Frauds and King of Dancedon't compare the king of pop to the king of fools please
yeah and if its secondary canon anime only content can be used as long as it doesn't contradict current scaling by too much and doesn't contradict the storyYou can maybe use scans from the anime as support for the manga
Then Gojo is Clown of frauds?King Of Frauds and King of Dance
Muzan & Lucifero are few disappointing Villains of new gen.dude I've seen someone claim muzan from demon slayer is a better villain than sukuna
Like man YOU WHAT!?
Given anime Mahoraga has powers his manga version doesn't, I'm pretty sure making him a profile is fair game
Fights - Culling GameWhat's yalls ranking of the series story arcs?
For me,What's yalls ranking of the series story arcs?
I mean sukuna has psudo flight the guy has shown the ability to air hop so I mean its canonJust for us to say "Maho's adaption allows him to grow gills when adapting to water" like this is something that is probably possible in manga version, they just presented it differently. Like we're not gonna give Sukuna a whole new page cuz he and Maho were basically flying as well lol
I mean his personality for a final villain simply doesn't work he is just a 1000 year old man child that gets pissy when things don't go his wayMuzan is interesting in concept and backstory, it's just that he doesn't get as much time to actually do things.