I have a guy who is asking me some questions about these One Piece calculations

[DTG499]

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:The_Calaca/Whitebeard%27s_quake_revision

https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Damage3245/Aokiji's_Ice

I have limited knowledge about the show and so my explanations are not understandable to him, woud like some help pls.

 

[DTG499]

here I'll copy paste some of the things he is asking.

"all they did is try to use physics to a fiction character. That is just the enegry output calculation which cant even be scaled with other characters they dont even have same type power. Freezing things over not the same as destroy entire mountain. Plain and simple. Actually how does whitebeard cracking an island in half comes out as country bursting. All yall doing is using physics to fiction characters to make damn stronger than the actual feat shown. Explosion that country size would be threating to in rl but in the actual fiction series hell no."

"the problem is those are physics cal not stated by teh actual author. their is no actual feat of destroying him country. Pretty much just saying producing earthquakes and a tsunami is equalent to destorying a country.. But can he destorying a country in one hit tho hell no, has regular ppl still survival his attacks near him yes. Has its been offical stated in the manga his punches hit like a destorying country? You cant even prove u need country lvl durability to survive his attacks"

 

[The_Calaca]

That concern is usable to the wiki as a whole. We apply physics to every single calc.

His comments are nothing but a bunch of fallacies that can be said for everything here but doesn't hold on by itself because if we throw physics away we would have no way of knowing anything of any character here.

 

[DTG499]

I was hoping he would come to the wiki and learn for himself about that. I just let him go after that comment because that would take all day to explain.