Hol Horse downgrades

[Arigarmy]

I now believe Thoth's prediction on "killing" the crusaders is invalid for giving Hol Horse the Large Building stat. Here's why:

1. Thoth's prediction only mentioned Jotaro. No other Crusaders were ever mentioned in the original manga.

2. Jotaro wasn't killed, obviously. "Went through Jotaro's forehead" can also mean that they just simply flew by or was referring to the picture on Thoth itself, take your pick. The bullet holes in the pictures were actually picturing these ones.

I'm pretty late to making this after months of rediscovering the feat. I don't know where JSW exactly got these claims but they were essentially misguided or false.

 

[Antvasima]

I suppose that this seems to make sense, but you should probably ask JSW to comment here.

 

[JustSomeWeirdo]

Well, we should probably just change the justifications, as Emperor still damaged Avdol, iirc

 

[TheJ-ManRequiem]

Wasnt it because hevwas off by 1 minute,so destiny reallighnrd to make it happen, just nkt the way it should have.

>shoot at noon, hit Jotaro.

>shot 1 minute early, recompansated by shooting Jotaro in the book.

 

[Arigarmy]

@JSW

It grazed him, yes. Wouldn't it seem to be an outlier though if it's that one feat compared to the other smaller feats it has?

@J-Man

No, I don't think so? Thoth's predictions are set in stone, there's no way to really get past it outside of Fate Manipulation or some other trickery like that. Not unless Boingo is a filthy liar.

 

[Lord_blizzard58]

@JSW
It grazed him, yes. Wouldn't it seem to be an outlier though if it's that one feat compared to the other smaller feats it has?

@J-Man

No, I don't think so? Thoth's predictions are set in stone, there's no way to really get past it outside of Fate Manipulation or some other trickery like that. Not unless Boingo is a filthy liar.

I think Boingo himself metions that Thoth adjusts fate to suit whatever was written, I think he said that if Oingo just changed out of his Jotaro disguise that fate would turn the orange that Oingo had into a normal one and change Jotaro's into the bomb, but i don't have the scene on hand to make sure I didn't just dream this

 

[Antvasima]

This is an old thread. I will close it.