So I know everyone loved the DLC, myself included, but could you imagine how awesome it would have been for an extended boss fight with Young Kratos, I'm talking GoW 3 Kratos so he's switching weapons like we do and how Tyr was, using all of his various magics and abilities like the bow, boots, and Head. Imagine if we got a reflect battle like with the Fates, since Young Kratos would have the Fleece, even having actual quick time events as a throw back to the Greek games and how we are fighting ourself who always had to do the Qte's. Maybe even have both of them use Spartan Rage at the same time, so Young Kratos pulls out the Blade and they have a callback to Zeus's fight, where they fight over the Blade of Olympus, except know they are even more evenly matched and they both get cuts from the Blade slowly weakening both of them, until finally Old Kratos is able to stab Young Kratos enough to beat him, but of course Young Kratos went out swinging trying to choke Old Kratos to death. I think this should also be the bloodiest we've seen either of them, from how brutal the fight was.
But, have it similar to Thor's defeat where Old Kratos has to talk his Young self down, because he see's Thor in himself, and finally they are able to reconcile, with both committing to being better as Faye always said, with that down, Young Kratos fades away and Old Kratos finally takes his place on his throne. I was even thinking of having Valhalla be damaged from how severe the fight was, with Freya, Tyr, Sigrun, and Mimir commenting on how strong the clash was with whoever Kratos fought, only for him to reveal it was his younger, angrier self, just so they could finally understand how strong he was when he was truly bloodthirsty since they were surprised about some of Kratos's exploits. I don't know how sensical it is to make their fight damage Valhalla, since it isn't really Young Kratos there, but I think it would show how powerful Kratos is, past and present, to have his hardest fight be himself, plus when he destroyed the sacrificial cage he broke Valhalla as Mimir point out, so it wouldn't be too far fetched.
What do you think? Too cheesy, over the top maybe? Or just the right amount.