Ok for one, super sorry I came late to this thread.
Ok so I’ve been told you’re the resident expert on tier 1 evaluations and such so this post will hopefully serve as kind of explanation for the proposition (I’m only shooting for a Low 1-C rating, not a High 1-A or whatever lol) and a question for feats for that rating as well.
From what I gathered from reading this text, I believe you said something along the lines of “it can be conceivable for Adolla to be tier 1 if they transcend the 4-D space-time.” (Paraphrasing). And I saw some other posts from other users indicating that for low 1-C additional feats and statements are needed.
I think that can be demonstrated here.
So probably the most obscure feat in the series is when Adolla shifts
“reality” into “fiction” through a cataclysm (a merger between
the Adolla plane of pure thoughts and the real world). This feat is described to us
using drawings as an example. Would you call a stick figure human? It has two arms, legs, and a head so it can be vaguely called one.
This is what happened to the entirety of space-time in the FF verse.
(Note: This happens through the whole space-time continuum as Shinra uncovers this revelation
by traveling into the past and seeing what reality was 250 years prior to the start of the series. There’s a clear distinction between which point in time “reality” shifts.)
Now, I’m not an expert on any kind of “5D reality to fiction” shenanigans right, that’s where the “question” part of this post comes into play but frankly I don’t think it’s an ‘unreasonable’ conclusion to come to regarding this feat. Like if you were to ask me what you think a ‘reality to fiction feat would look like’ I would intuitively think that turning what would be considered a “real world” into an “anime/manga world” would classify as such, but I’m no expert on the matter. It would just be important to note that in describing the feat it’s stated that the “
rules of the world were rewritten” by the characters. (There’s literally a whole ass chapter in this series of just a real life woman giving exposition and explaining how disgusted she is about humans it’s freaking weird dude.)
Now again, on its own that might not be enough to indicate a low 1-C rating or to reach “5D” levels or whatever, but I think compounded with the information that the Adolla plane
is this world of pure human ideations which is portrayed and states as this “
transcendent realm” and that it “
World beyond human imagination.” About it being
the final point to all human imagination and embodies all the concepts
which explicitly mentions “higher dimensions” and “mathematics” as some of the concepts it embodies. (Which Adolla has further feats of impacting the concepts of mathematics
such as both creating the mathematical concept of Pi and then turning it from an infinite, unsolvable equation to a finite solvable one. Which helps to validate it as encompassing these concepts.)
Adolla has shown to embody “history” itself as well (which is the whole reason Shinra was even able to view the past despite being in the Adolla plane at the time)
as the Adolla world carries with it the very history of humanities despair. This gets further proven to be true by how it’s verbatim stated during the second cataclysm that due to the merger of the world of thoughts, Adolla, and the real world,
the concepts that Adolla carries of the people of the past are being merged with the present real world.
I think all this evidence of statements and feats compounded together helps point towards the narrative that Adolla truly does operate on this metaphysical, transcendent realm from “reality” and its statement of embodying the very concepts of “higher dimensions” helps to signify that fact.
There’s also some totally obscure feats that also help indicate this as well such as the fact that Adolla straight up
sees the world itself as a “story” and labels the characters in the verse
as either “explicitly” or “background” characters and can literally have them vanish from reality itself when their “role in the story has been completed.” I think that alongside the previous “reality to fiction” feat Adolla displayed helps shows the kind of “5D” nature I’m talking about when in reference to Adolla.
This also gets supported by how human beings who are not blessed by the Adolla flame
can’t do so much as grasp the Adolla plane as they immediately are burned up and killed. In fact
you can’t even so much as look into the Adolla world or it’s true form either as your eyes immediately combust as if you stared directly into the sun itself.
There is also the matter that Shinrabanshoman (the very pinnacle of the verse
who is cited as being ‘God itself’ and having the acquired “
the power of all creation” with the name ‘Shinrabanshoman’ literally meaning ‘all of creation’).
The end point being: There is a lot of evidence from both feats and statements (there’s even more statements like these ones above trust me they say it
a lot) indicating that Adolla and the Evangelist act in this “higher dimensional superiority” to the point where it would classify for a Low 1-C rating. Or at the very least I think the evidence compounded together makes it so the conclusion of the Fire Force god tiers being Low 1-C is not an unreasonable conclusion to come to based on that evidence.