• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Fire Emblem Discussion Thread 5: Fire Emblem Three Houses, One Basement

Status
Not open for further replies.
I mean, the fact would be that Post-TS Byleth would be on a higher end of the scaling. Plus, Byleth was sleep for 5 years so it's not like he's been training for all those years. Hence why his students were able to catch up with him in power....somewhat. This would be consistent to SS as he can take The Immaculate One by himself showing that he's much stronger than the others.
 
I guess that works if we scale Pre-Timeskip Sothis Fused Byleth to the Immaculate One, we'd have 7-B Pre-Timeskip Base Byleth tho...
 
I mean, is that too crazy? I mean, while Byleth does only have partial powered SoC, iirc Rhea or Seteth states that it should still be superior. I'd have to go through Chapter 8 again. There is also the fact that Nemesis with the SotC was able to kill other Dragon Form Nabateans so that could be some support.

I'll type out some scaling recommendations real quick and tell me what you think. My tiers may be off cuz we got so many lol
 
The High 6-B will be revised as Low 6-B to 6-B soon anyways

Can you write out what you think the tiers should be in your opinion
 
Here's my solution.

Fodder: 7-C

Pre-TS Students: At least 7-C (Can easily defeat other soldiers and can deal significant damage to Demonic Beasts)

Pre-TS Lords: High 7-C I guess they keep scaling to Byleth pre-Sothis Fusion? I dunno, I still think it's fair to say Byleth is a decent deal stronger than them.

Pre-TS Students: High 7-C, possibly 7-A???? Has consistently been training for 5 years and Felix in particular was able to barely best Byleth in training. <-Honestly, I find Post TS Students to be the hard ones to tier.

Sothis Fused Byleth, Sothis, Nemesis, Seiros, Thales(?. tbf his Miasma didn't seem to have damaged Byleth and more pushed him back, but eh), Post TS Lords: At least 7-A, possibly 6-B (?).

Immaculate One and SS Byleth: Aside from Prime Sothis, these are the God Tiers. I do think SS Byleth deserves it's own key compared to CF and other routes.

Dunno about the Ashen Wolves or Jeritza yet.
 
High 7-C won't exist anymore if we scale Sothis Fused Byleth to 7-A, since the Hero's Relics scale to 1/2 as strong as the Sword of the Creator, so the High 7-C would become 7-B

Here's what I think

Fodder: 7-C

Pre-TS Students: At least 7-C (Can easily defeat other soldiers and can deal significant damage to Demonic Beasts)

Pre-TS Lords: At least 7-C, possibly 7-B

Pre-TS Base Byleth: At least 7-B (Half as strong as Sword of the Creator)

Pre-TS Students: At least 7-B, possibly far higher

Sothis Fused Byleth, Sothis, Nemesis, Seiros, Thales, Post TS Lords: At least 7-A, possibly whatever the tier 6 tier will be

This might be good?
 
I think some students should be on the same tier as the Pre-TS lords, as well, ive said before that Felix was able to narrowly best Byleth, and regularly spars with them. Same with Dedue, as Dedue has been shown to spar with Dimitri. Also Lysithea because she has dual crests.

I dont think Nemesis has actually fought "dark gods", pretty sure thats just a made up story to cover up the fact that Nemesis was nothing more than an OP god bandit.
 
btw for those hoping for a "Golden Route", don't get your hopes up. They've already said in an interview that they have no intentions of making one. I will find said interview shortly.
 
Rtxthegamer said:
I dont think Nemesis has actually fought "dark gods", pretty sure thats just a made up story to cover up the fact that Nemesis was nothing more than an OP god bandit.
Click to expand...
Nemesis fought and killed Nabateans. That's an entire plotpoint. Even Rhea says as much. There is a reason why there are only 5 Nabateans left.
 
@Dragonmasterxyz

"Golden route" means that there will be no let's all work together route, right? there will still be a 5th Route created though, correct?

If not, that'll be sad
 
DemonGodMitchAubin said:
@Dragonmasterxyz
"Golden route" means that there will be no let's all work together route, right? there will still be a 5th Route created though, correct?

If not, that'll be sad
Click to expand...
Yeah. Right now, any future DLC is up in the air although there is data for a female unit with a Major Crest of Flames and is 17 years old so maybe. As for a 5th route. We have no info. So as far as we know, Cindered Shadows is it until more info is given.
 
Rtxthegamer said:
I think some students should be on the same tier as the Pre-TS lords, as well, ive said before that Felix was able to narrowly best Byleth, and regularly spars with them. Same with Dedue, as Dedue has been shown to spar with Dimitri. Also Lysithea because she has dual crests.
Click to expand...
If Lysithea scales, let's match her against Death Knight.
 
PuasLuisZX said:
Rtxthegamer said:
I think some students should be on the same tier as the Pre-TS lords, as well, ive said before that Felix was able to narrowly best Byleth, and regularly spars with them. Same with Dedue, as Dedue has been shown to spar with Dimitri. Also Lysithea because she has dual crests.
Click to expand...
If Lysithea scales, let's match her against Death Knight.
Click to expand...
Jeritza: "Who hurt you?"
 
PuasLuisZX said:
Rtxthegamer said:
I think some students should be on the same tier as the Pre-TS lords, as well, ive said before that Felix was able to narrowly best Byleth, and regularly spars with them. Same with Dedue, as Dedue has been shown to spar with Dimitri. Also Lysithea because she has dual crests.
Click to expand...
If Lysithea scales, let's match her against Death Knight.
Click to expand...
Assuming she is at least 7-B, then yea we can.
 
@Dragonmasterxyz

I really hope we get one more route, I don't expect it to be a Revelations route, but maybe one that deals with more secrets or goes back to the Nabatean times, that'd be really cool

I don't want Cindered Shadows to be the end of Three Houses Story, I feel like it needs a final story of finality that could be like Future Past and Heirs of Fates
 
I would like it to be a backstory route. Like go through Rhea's life as Seiros to see what really happened in the past.
 
I'm expecting the last dlc story (if there is one) to be about Ernest, since it is the one person who we havent heard about yet.
 
Ok, so this is what we'll go with

7-C: Fodder

At least 7-C: Pre-Timeskip Students

At least 7-C, possibly 7-B: Pre-Timeskip Lords

7-B: Base Byleth

7-B, possibly far higher: Post-Timeskip Students

At least 7-A, possibly Low 6-B/6-B: Sothis Fused Byleth, Immaculate One, Nemesis, Seiros, Thales, Post-Timeskip Lords, Maybe Jeritza
 
I approve Low 6-B God Tiers. And yeah, some of the students are almost as strong as the lords. Hubert, Dedue, and Hilda? appear to be the three strongest non-lord students. Although, Hilda's mostly strong because of her Hero's Relic. Jeritza should also be almost as strong as Byleth.

And yeah, I was going to mention that even Byleth varies from route to route just like the other three lords do. Like Crimson Flower has the weakest version of Byleth due to being more "Separated" from Sothis. Where as he's much stronger in SS due to being forced to be independent and having to train harder. And Immaculate One does have the most consistent statements to be the true God Tier as far as end game bosses are concerned.
 
I don't know what you mean by that^

The reasoning for 7-B is on the Heroes' Relics page if you need more clarification
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

TheGatememer
  • Locked
Fire Emblem Verse Page Overhaul
Replies
10
Views
1K
DarkDragonMedeus
DarkDragonMedeus
XitSign
What If: Goku Landed in Garreg Mach AND WAS BETRAYED!?!? | Son Goku Vs. Claude von Riegan | 0 - 0 - 0
Replies
2
Views
541
XitSign
XitSign
KobsterHope07
The Old World will burn in the fires of the Flame Emperor
Replies
9
Views
1K
Agnaa
Agnaa
TheGatememer
Hopeful Upgrades for Fódlan (Major Revisions for Fire Emblem: Three Houses)
Replies
17
Views
2K
TheGatememer
TheGatememer
HoodedEnigma
Fire Emblem: Minor Addition Of Classic Abilities
Replies
19
Views
2K
JustSomeWeirdo
JustSomeWeirdo
Back
Top