Erza Scarlet vs Knuckles the Echinda (speed equalized)

[Cropfist]

Two strict red-haired rivals to the cocky teenage main protagonist.

Base Knuckles and no Nakagami, Wingblade, Flight, Adamantine or flight-granting armors for Erza.

 

[Golem_Guy_(Neo)]

Well I'm not sure who would win, but Erza can still change to her Admantine Armor, which gives her a major boost to defense.

 

[Cropfist]

edited, that would probably make it a stomp

 

[Golem_Guy_(Neo)]

Erza due to versatility and access to water attacks from the Sea Empress Armor that could make Base Knuckles drown.

 

[Dragonmasterxyz]

Yeah even with Erza as restricted as she is her versatility and intellect should gice he a win. Also why restrict so many armors? I mean most of those wouldn't make this a stomp....

 

[NotEvenHuman]

Yeah, i can understand flight and Nakagami, but Adamantine has low offensive power, if any at all, and Wingblade wouldn't be of much use here, since Knuckles doesn't use any weapons or armor.

Regardless, i say Erza due to versality and Knuckles's readable attacks.

 

[Cropfist]

Adamantine would make it a stomp as Knuckles would have no way of damaging her.

 

[NotEvenHuman]

As i said, Adamantine has barely no offensive uses. If she brings it out, she's not dealing any signficant damage to Knuckles either. And she barely uses it anyway.

 

[Cropfist]

An inconclusive match by default isn't any better.

 

[NotEvenHuman]

Except that the match won't be inconclusive at all, since as i said, Erza barely uses the armor, and when she does, it's only against attacks that she considers way too dangerous to defend against normally. Knuckles doesn't have anything that strong.

Also, Erza is always constantly switching armors. She wouldn't stay in something like Adamantine for more than 10 seconds once she realizes she also has no way of hurting Knuckles in it.

 

[Golem_Guy_(Neo)]

And don't forget the Sea Empress Armor, which could allow Erza to use the water to drown Knuckles.

 

[Cropfist]

If she barely uses it she might as well not have it to begin with.

 

[Cropfist]

I think it should be noted that Knuckles' massive range advantage of several kilometers and sneek attacks via digging could help him.