Blue vs. Silver: Pokemon Edition

[SuperKamiNappa]

Gen 1 Champion Blue, His starter is Charmander
Post-Game Silver, His starter was Totadile

who wins and why?

 

[Enryu_The_Red_Tower]

Silver has AP and Dura advantage, since: Silver (Post-Game) = Ethan (Post-Game) = Kanto Gym Leaders >> Lance (HG / SS) = Blue (Champion)

In the matter of versatility both are the same, but since this is Blue (FR / LG) neither has experience advantage over the other, but in the intelligence category I have that Blue wins, since he was able to quickly face the Gym Leaders of Kanto in the battles and always one passes the front of Red, it seems that both are balanced, like Silver with advantage of AP and Dura and Blue with intelligence to his side.

so now I'm going to start telling you the scenario of how it would be the battle between the two:

Silver and Blue start playing their Pokémon's:

Pidgeot vs. Sneasel: Although Sneasel has a type advantage against Pidgeot, the bird is better able to overcome this disadvantage by using the Sand-Attack to block gusts of cold wind with his Sand and even create tornadoes using Sand and thus block the sight of Sneasel and thus being able to use Aerieal Ace spam while Sneasel is blind because of the sand and thus Pidgeot winning with difficulties and wounds because of Icy Wind that Sneasel used before Pidgot blinds him.

Pidgeot vs. Alakazam: With Pidgeot weakened and slowed due to Icy Wind, Alakazam is simply able to use various Psychic against Pidgeot and if he is injured by some Bird attacks, Alakazam can heal with Recover and then use Reflect, which weakens attacks which can be considered a victory for Alakazam.

Rhydon vs Alakazam:

Due to Reflect activated, Rhydon's physical attacks become much weaker, but he is still able to make Alakazam slow with Scary Face, but Alakazam still has Recover that is able to recover all the damage from Rhydon's attacks as if nothing had Alakazam can also use Disable against Scary Face, in case he thinks that this move is a threat, which is likely, since speed is one of the keys to Alakazam's victory and thus Alakazam wins.

Alakazam vs Alakazam:

Although both have Reflect, it will not be useful due to the fact that neither two are close combat fighters, the Alakazam's of SIlver and Blue have no noticeable advantage over each other, both have Disable that they can use in the Recover's of a of the other so both being unable to recover from the wounds that they accomodate in the fight and they faint.

Charizard vs. Magneton:

The two have advantage of type on the other, Charizard begins using Fire Spin that weakens Magneton gradually, but Magneton is able to be released from the Fire Spin using Discharge that can great AoE and thus hitting Charizard, although the fire Pokémon is weakened, he still has a surprise, his ability Blaze, which is able to make Fire-Type blows more powerful while he is very weak, and he uses a Fire Blast against Magneton and before he falls, and Pokémon Steel uses Thunder Wave to paralyze the weakened Charizard before dropping out after one-shotted by powered Charizard.

Charizard vs Golbat:

With Charizard weakened because of Discharge and paralyzed, Golbat uses Confuse Ray to be able to ensure that he will be unharmed from any Charizard attacks so he can face the next opponent with full power without injuries, and thus confused Charizard attacks himself and with Golbat using Bite and thus incapacitating Charizard.

Exeggutor vs Golbat:

LightScreen will not be useful because Golbat is a physical fighter, Exeggutor uses Sleep Powder to make Golbat sleep and so uses several Egg Bombs to faint and defeat Golbat, but before being defeated, Golbat uses Confuse Ray before falling.

Exeggutor vs Feraligatr:

With Exeggutor confused, Feraligatr uses Ice Fang to finalize the Exeggutor, but did not count that he used Giga Drain to drain most of Feraligatr's energy to recover and so Feraligatr falls.

Exeggutor vs Gengar

Gengar takes advantage that Exeggutor is confused and thus uses Shadow Ball spam to quickly defeat Exeggutor, but before falling Exeggutor uses Giga Drain to drain the energy of Gengar + Sleep Powder

Gyarados vs Gengar

Gyarados must win due to the Bite that can faint Gengar in a few seconds and with this asleep.

Blue wins overall due to intelligence

 

[SuperKamiNappa]

1-0 Blue

 

[ABoogieYesSir]

Blue FRA

but that reply though

 

[The_Calaca]

Blue FRA

but that reply though

Yeah...

Blue FRA.