Anakin and Windu

[FrancoGYFV]

Shouldn't Anakin's AP, Speed and Durability be upgraded?

AFAIK, his feats are greater than Windu's, and in the Invisible Hand scene he had an amp which would be a thread even to Yoda.

While Windu is not fodder for him, he doesn't have the feats to contend, and the only time he had such a feat ("defeating" Sidous) it was a one-time amp from his state of mind, combined with Vaapad.

 

[Sirius_The_EM_Troll]

True.

 

[Lina_Shields]

Perhaps Everlasting can explain this feat a bit more, but with regards to Mace Windu, "High 6-A, Low 5-B via Vaapad" seems to sound ok.

However, wouldn't this upgrade apply to Obi-wan and Tyranus as well, seeing they should be comparable to Anakin, and to each other?

 

[The_Everlasting]

We had an extremely extensive discussion on Windu's tier, and it was decided to remain as it is.

As for Anakin, having greater feats means extremely little since Lucas said only Mace and Yoda could contend with Sidious. Going strictly by feats characters like Whis are completely featless.

 

[Sirius_The_EM_Troll]

Yeah, but Anakin did defeat Dooku, while Mace was defeated by Dooku in The Clone War the only time they fought. Dooku is even noted as his superior.


Also, Lucas didn't say Mace could contend with Sidious in a random encounter, but meh, I won't argue.