This honestly lol, he can legit just make this argument and while Rohan prolly doesn't know much about law he should be smart enough to make this argument
But he was going to burn Okuyasu up and it's hard to defend him ripping a page out of Koichi's face
Breaking and entering and threatening to kill. Plus Rohan is so far up his own ass he probably doesn't even recognize the act as completely malicious (it's for the sake of his manga and he views it as a honor for Koichi, he even says it shouldn't be a big deal as he'd live on in his manga), like at worst it'd more likely be deemed an act of insanity or some shit especially as Rohan did not intend to actually push Koichi to the point of death as revealed later, he just got way to into it because he just learned about all these super powers and shit.
The law though does not care if the perpetrator themselves considers what they do to be a crime.
This is also why I created this thread, I'm curious as to how Deadly Sentencing and Heaven's Door would interact with each other.
Since Part 4 takes place in 1999, shouldn't the penal code from that year be referenced and not the current one?
He was acting against 4 people who he did his best to incapacitate, so that the threat was over lmao
Hard to imagine that those specific two articles were dramatically changed since they refer to stuff that can't be re-intepreted
This is what I managed to find so far:
Yeah ig there were some differences but it's quite hard to believe that he commited an excess against literally 4 guys who invaded his home and iirc 2 threatened violence with one of them even commiting an act of violence lol
Looking at the imgur slideshow, Josuke didn't beat Rohan up yet, but Okuyasu did threaten violence
What exactly would count as excess if ripping pages out of someone or almost burning someone alive doesn't count?
Ripping pages just take memories and/or powers out of someone in a painful process, he's basically using his magical ghost's ability to make the guy who entered his some suffer
Wouldn't Higuruma treat it like a domain expansion or curse technique though?
Even if so, defending yourself against home invaders with "a curse technique" that has killed nobody is not punishable
Even if he wrote "kill yourself" using the same technique?
if he hypotetically did it, then it would depend on how much violence was attempted or threatened against him
Ok, so there are 3 invaders, not 4
This is literally "IF YOUR FRIEND KEEP INVADING MY HOUSE THREATENING ME WITH VIOLENCE YOU'LL KILL YOURSELF"
Although how is Okuyasu supposed to "get out of Rohan's house" unfurled like that? And being shot at isn't the same as being burned alive.
From a safe distance, if Okuyasu collaborates by not letting Josuke get close to him, it is not impossible for Heaven's Door to just let him walk normally again, from what he can assume
Death as a consequence as keep threatening after a warning that there'll be consequences if the threat goes on
Well, if you got shot in the leg, you won't have any permenant disfigurement to your body as long as you go to the hospital to get the bullet removed. However getting burned can disfigure you for life, there are many tragic instances of this happening.
No he's not, i talked about it quite a bit earlier.
If you gave your best for the person to stop threatening you and the didn't by their own will, what more can you do, give up?
Bro if a dude with a superhuman punch goes that has like void manip and BFR and EE rolled into one threatened to kill me, burning him alive with a caveat of "only if the other dude who broke in tries to **** with me", is actually legally well within right.
Okuyasu literally to Rohan's face stated he was going to kill, or at the very least maim him.
Although can't he be convicted guilty for assaulting his guest?
Does ripping pages out of him or taking away his weight not count?
Despite what seems to many, i don't really think Rohan would kill Koichi. If you think hard enough, as a successful mangaka who's always in a pursuit for inspiration, he would have killed many to reach it or at least attempt it against another person later?
Battery then?
