• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Yet another Hoyoverse cosmology downgrade

just say asdana galaxy, thats millions of light years big, but idk why even assume tree is galaxy when himeko says leaves are universes like how does that even make sense 😭
Leaves are universes in the sense they’re independent space-times. Their size varies otherwise. The Asdana System being a spiral galaxy and the HI3 system being the size of our IRL solar systems are our only hard confirmed notion of how big leaves are.
 
Man i forgor to unwatch it and ended up reading entire thread. I will reply by today or tomorrow.
Is it possible to downgrade everyone to Low 2-C from not scaling to the whole Tree in this thread or would I have to make another CRT for that?
 
I'd like to ask everyone in the thread to consider my argument as well (although if you find that it is best, I can potentially save my own argument for a future thread). I straight-up don't think Ryusuke's statement is reliable whatsoever.
I agree with OP.

The issue with using Ryusuke's statements is that Ryusuke is unreliable and his statement about pseudo-R>F contradicts more credible information we have in Honkai. Ryusuke obviously betrayed Welt and was being deceitful with pretty much everyone he interacted with. Even after "explaining" his plans, he even tried to trick Welt into thinking he instantly cut off all of Welt's limbs when in reality, he was just moving stuff around in the higher dimensional space to make it look like that (Note that Welt was still able to curl his fist after it was "severed", which shows that it wasn't really cut off). It's far more likely that Ryusuke was just bluffing.

Additionally, contrary to your claim that Welt's singularity rebuild explains why Welt was able to defeat Ryusuke despite supposedly being uncountably infinitely weaker than him, that doesn't solve all the inconsistencies. Namely, Welt was able to block one of Ryusuke's attacks not with his gravity powers, but with an imaginary barrier. So what's going on here? The imaginary barrier previously got bypassed entirely by Ryusuke's attacks, which seemed to support the idea that Ryusuke had pseudo R>F over him. But then, Welt reframed his perspective and looked at the bigger picture past the illusions caused by the higher dimensions. He not only discovers that he was in one piece the whole time, but is also able to block one of Ryusuke's attacks with his imaginary barrier. The fact that all Welt had to do to be able to do this was reframe his perspective/recalibrate his senses rather than power himself up physically shows that Ryusuke didn't actually have uncountably infinitely stronger AP than Welt, he was just using spacetime hax to go around Welt's defenses (which Welt was eventually able to properly defend against).

On top of all of that, Ryusuke's statement simply contradicts the credible information we do have about higher dimensions in Honkai Impact. Here, it straight up says that only real space (which is explicitly said to only be 4-dimensional even when counting the dimension of time!) is capable of producing any sort of real physical meaning, and all higher dimensional spaces are incapable of producing meaning, physically interacting with realspace objects, or having the attributes that characterize any sort of physicality (raw text can also be seen here). It's literally impossible for Honkai Impact to have any significant higher dimensions because all of the higher dimensional spaces explicitly lack the characteristics necessary for Low 1-C to Low 1-A to begin with.

So overall, we should in fact downgrade Honkai to tier 2 at best. Not only is the only statement supporting Tier 1 a non-credible bluff, but it also contradicts the actually credible information we do have that confirms that significant higher dimensions simply do not exist in the verse.
It even contradicts the fact that it's straight up explained that only 4-dimensional real space is capable of producing any meaning or sustaining relationships that characterize physicality like speed or size and that objects of imaginary space (which is everything outside of 4-dimensional real space) are incapable of physically interfering with objects existing in the space of real numbers (which is everything that exists in 4D space).
so you didnt actually debunk anything about ryusuke here saying hes unreliable then saying hes manipulating space in a higher dimension yet he himself says that he is apart of this higher dimension
I don't think you understand what my argument actually is. Yes, he was telling the truth about using a higher dimension, but he was also bluffing about various things such as pretending to sever Welt's limbs when he actually didn't as well as literally betraying everyone he worked with. Some things he says are true, but overall he's not reliable.
ok so here with the imaginary barrier stuff is AFTER keyword here AFTER welt figure out how the dimension works. no one was ever arguing ryusuke had higher ap than welt????
Really? You're telling me Ryusuke didn't have higher AP than Welt? That literally proves my point. Ryusuke was bluffing and claimed that Welt was lower dimensional and that as a result, Ryusuke had pseudo-R>F over Welt (which would've given him uncountably higher AP), which was of course contradicted by the fact that Welt was able to use an imaginary barrier (not even needing his gravity powers) to block one of Ryusuke's attacks. And no, Welt didn't uncountably power up his imaginary barrier or anything, he literally just used his Herrscher abilities to perceive Ryusuke's higher dimension properly. That's hax, not AP.
 
I'd like to ask everyone in the thread to consider my argument as well (although if you find that it is best, I can potentially save my own argument for a future thread). I straight-up don't think Ryusuke's statement is reliable whatsoever.

It even contradicts the fact that it's straight up explained that only 4-dimensional real space is capable of producing any meaning or sustaining relationships that characterize physicality like speed or size and that objects of imaginary space (which is everything outside of 4-dimensional real space) are incapable of physically interfering with objects existing in the space of real numbers (which is everything that exists in 4D space).
What does this have to do with Ryusuke?
I don't think you understand what my argument actually is. Yes, he was telling the truth about using a higher dimension, but he was also bluffing about various things such as pretending to sever Welt's limbs when he actually didn't as well as literally betraying everyone he worked with. Some things he says are true, but overall he's not reliable
Really? You're telling me Ryusuke didn't have higher AP than Welt? That literally proves my point. Ryusuke was bluffing and claimed that Welt was lower dimensional and that as a result, Ryusuke had pseudo-R>F over Welt (which would've given him uncountably higher AP), which was of course contradicted by the fact that Welt was able to use an imaginary barrier (not even needing his gravity powers) to block one of Ryusuke's attacks. And no, Welt didn't uncountably power up his imaginary barrier or anything, he literally just used his Herrscher abilities to perceive Ryusuke's higher dimension properly. That's hax, not AP.
He wasnt bluffing that he was higher dimensonal towards welt at all, because the very move welt used is explicitly stated to be capable of affecting all dimensions and hence literally has one shot Ryusuke because he was higher dimensional being.
this entire argument is reliant on the fact that we should assume that Ryusuke was bluffing which this literally isnt the case and that he wasnt actually higher dimensional.
 
The entire fight before welt used singularity rebuild is that welt literally had no way of interacting with Ryusuke while ryusuke could do anything to welt, in fact the entire realm was higher dimensional including ryusuke, he quite literally says that everything in that dimension is a higher dimension while welt was the lower one
 
What does this have to do with Ryusuke?
The scan clearly explains that only the four dimensions of realspace are capable of producing any meaning, and blah blah blah I've already explained this multiple times. This obviously contradicts the idea that higher dimensional realities/structures/objects in Honkai are uncountably infinitely more powerful compared to lower dimensional ones.
He wasnt bluffing that he was higher dimensonal towards welt at all, because the very move welt used is explicitly stated to be capable of affecting all dimensions and hence literally has one shot Ryusuke because he was higher dimensional being.
1. You're ignoring him pretending to cut Welt's limbs off when they were clearly functional enough for Welt to curl his fist (and, of course, when Welt used his powers to properly perceive Ryusuke's dimension, he saw that he was actually still in one piece). A lot of what Ryusuke was doing was just illusions to trick Welt, so it's really stupid of you to assume he's telling the truth about having pseudo-R>F over Welt.
2. You're ignoring the fact that Welt was also able to block one of Ryusuke's attacks with an imaginary barrier. Not his gravity powers, but his imaginary barrier. Yes, Ryusuke was able to bypass earlier, but all Welt had to do to properly block it was not to empower himself infinitely, but simply change his perspective and perceive Ryusuke's dimension properly. This clearly demonstrates that Ryusuke's ability to bypass Welt's barrier was not infinitely higher power, but was actually just hax.
The entire fight before welt used singularity rebuild is that welt literally had no way of interacting with Ryusuke
That wasn't because Ryusuke's durability was supposedly infinitely high, it was because he kept redirecting Welt's bullets back at him using his higher dimensional spatial hax. It has nothing to do with higher AP.
while ryusuke could do anything to welt
Again, that's just hax, not AP. Welt couldn't fully perceive Ryusuke's movements. Plus, Ryusuke didn't even hurt Welt that much. All he did was leave a cut on his arm.
 
The scan clearly explains that only the four dimensions of realspace are capable of producing any meaning, and blah blah blah I've already explained this multiple times. This obviously contradicts the idea that higher dimensional realities/structures/objects in Honkai are uncountably infinitely more powerful compared to lower dimensional ones.
The entire scan talks about Imaginary Space so what is your proof that Alien Space is imaginary space
1. You're ignoring him pretending to cut Welt's limbs off when they were clearly functional enough for Welt to curl his fist (and, of course, when Welt used his powers to properly perceive Ryusuke's dimension, he saw that he was actually still in one piece). A lot of what Ryusuke was doing was just illusions to trick Welt, so it's really stupid of you to assume he's telling the truth about having pseudo-R>F over Welt.
thats literally the proof that welt couldnt percieve shit when he was in lower dimension, his core allowed him to understand higher dimensions and was not limited to just 3 dimensions, theres literally him saying “dont just limit your mind to three dimensions”
2. You're ignoring the fact that Welt was also able to block one of Ryusuke's attacks with an imaginary barrier. Not his gravity powers, but his imaginary barrier. Yes, Ryusuke was able to bypass earlier, but all Welt had to do to properly block it was not to empower himself infinitely, but simply change his perspective and perceive Ryusuke's dimension properly. This clearly demonstrates that Ryusuke's ability to bypass Welt's barrier was not infinitely higher power, but was actually just hax.
Except thats exactly what his powers does, he used his herrscher authority and powered himself and his abilities, without it his barrier was literally broken to pieces it is also why he was able to unleash singularity rebuild, he literally had to get stronger because otherwise ryusuke would still be able to break his barrier like nothing
That wasn't because Ryusuke's durability was supposedly infinitely high, it was because he kept redirecting Welt's bullets back at him using his higher dimensional spatial hax. It has nothing to do with higher AP.

Again, that's just hax, not AP. Welt couldn't fully perceive Ryusuke's movements. Plus, Ryusuke didn't even hurt Welt that much. All he did was leave a cut on his arm.
I dont rly care if its hax or ap, all im saying is that this is not disqualifier for Ryusuke scaling to higher dimension above welt, because its explicitly said that lower dimensional beings cannot do anything to higher dimensional heings and he only lost after welt used powers that can affect higher dimensions
 
The entire scan talks about Imaginary Space so what is your proof that Alien Space is imaginary space
The scan defines "Imaginary Space" as ALL of the space that exists outside of 4 dimensional space.
Except thats exactly what his powers does, he used his herrscher authority and powered himself and his abilities, without it his barrier was literally broken to pieces it is also why he was able to unleash singularity rebuild, he literally had to get stronger because otherwise ryusuke would still be able to break his barrier like nothing
If you look at the part where Ryusuke bypasses Welt's barrier it looks less like Ryusuke is shattering the barrier with infinite force and more like Ryusuke's tentacle phased through the barrier by going around it in higher dimensional space. The reason why it fell apart was because Welt saw this happen and decided to dodge instead of continuing to try to block the tentacle. Additionally, Welt wasn't able to block it because he got some nonsensical uncountably infinite boost that isn't hinted at in the comic, but because he was able to perceive the higher dimensional space and block Ryusuke's attack instead of letting it go around Welt's barrier. The comic never says that Welt would get infinitely stronger, but that he'd "understand," "embrace," and "touch" the higher dimensional reality. This change is overwhelmingly portrayed more as a change in his mind's perception rather than his physical power.
its explicitly said that lower dimensional beings cannot do anything to higher dimensional heings and he only lost after welt used powers that can affect higher dimensions
I've already explained multiple times why he's not a reliable source, so why are you just assuming that we can trust Ryusuke's words? Nothing supports his credibility.
 
and nothing stated alien space is outside 4D space so
If you look at the part where Ryusuke bypasses Welt's barrier it looks less like Ryusuke is shattering the barrier with infinite force and more like Ryusuke's tentacle phased through the barrier by going around it in higher dimensional space. The reason why it fell apart was because Welt saw this happen and decided to dodge instead of continuing to try to block the tentacle. Additionally, Welt wasn't able to block it because he got some nonsensical uncountably infinite boost that isn't hinted at in the comic, but because he was able to perceive the higher dimensional space and block Ryusuke's attack instead of letting it go around Welt's barrier. The comic never says that Welt would get infinitely stronger, but that he'd "understand," "embrace," and "touch" the higher dimensional reality. This change is overwhelmingly portrayed more as a change in his mind's perception rather than his physical power
if only you knew that its impossible to block 4D attack without having 4D construct protect you…
I've already explained multiple times why he's not a reliable source, so why are you just assuming that we can trust Ryusuke's words? Nothing supports his credibility.
because nothing you said goes against what ryusuke is saying, the fact you treat his own words as bluffing when he blatantly showcases difference between higher and lower dimensionality
i mean even OP conceded hes 4D there tells me enough, id just suggest you make a new crt if you are really that willing to twist actual shit with some unreliable headcannon
 
Last edited:
i have so much to say against using that scan because everything from hi3 and hsr literally shuts down the idea that anything beyond the 4D space time is imaginary space, but this isnt a thread for it, nor is it anything regarding ryusuke and welt stuff.
 
@Super_Nova

I have a question. I found a scan showing that the Sugar's world where Ryusuke is located is very small. Does this fact affect the determination of Hoyoverse's tier?
 
That is not alien space, the candy house is the new dimension after their sugar space was destroyed
plus it literally says its a bubble universe while alien space is not it is realm created from alien key
ok it was alien space that was destroyed by welt lol i mixed this
The Sugars are an alien organization whose goal is to stop the Sky People. They were once attacked by the Sky People. After their home planet was taken over, they decided to abandon their physical bodies and revert to a psychic form. Using the Alien Key and their Sugars Fortress, they stay in a higher dimension. They take on the appearance of little puff balls.
But yeah after alien space was nuked they fled into that bubble world
 
https://manga.honkaiimpact3.com/book/1021/11


The Candy House existed even before Welt and Ryusuke fought. How can this be explained?
because thats the alien space before ryusuke trapped them using alien key, the entire story of alien space takes place when himeko was alive
meanwhile durandal found candy house bubble in ch 25/6 EX which happens many chapters after himekos death
 
because thats the alien space before ryusuke trapped them using alien key, the entire story of alien space takes place when himeko was alive
meanwhile durandal found candy house bubble in ch 25/6 EX which happens many chapters after himekos death



After being destroyed by Welt, where is the sentence stating that the name of the bubble universe is Candy House?

If you look at the link, it's referred to as the Candy House even before moving to the Bubble Universe. It mentions that the Candy House traveled through dimensions.
 


After being destroyed by Welt, where is the sentence stating that the name of the bubble universe is Candy House?

Welt destroyed Alien space alongside ryusuke since he basically merged with higher dimension
Candy House being bubble universe is the scan YOU sent when durandal and kira talk
If you look at the link, it's referred to as the Candy House even before moving to the Bubble Universe. It mentions that the Candy House traveled through dimensions.
i mean the scan mentions “candy jar” which is the tool they use to travel across dimensions, while candy house is the place of the bubble universe where they currently reside
 
i mean the scan mentions “candy jar” which is the tool they use to travel across dimensions, while candy house is the place of the bubble universe where they currently reside
The translation is incorrect. The original text reads “Candy House.”

In the Korean version, it was translated as “Candy House,” so I checked the original text and searched Google for the meaning of the original term, which also yielded “Candy House” as the result.
 
Welt destroyed Alien space alongside ryusuke since he basically merged with higher dimension
Candy House being bubble universe is the scan YOU sent when durandal and kira talk

i mean the scan mentions “candy jar” which is the tool they use to travel across dimensions, while candy house is the place of the bubble universe where they currently reside
I understand that Welt attempted to destroy it.
However, in the Korean version, it's translated as “Candy House,” and after checking the original text and Googling the word's meaning, it also appears as “Candy House.”

In other words, it was already called the Candy House even before moving to the Bubble Universe.
 
The translation is incorrect. The original text reads “Candy House.”

In the Korean version, it was translated as “Candy House,” so I checked the original text and searched Google for the meaning of the original term, which also yielded “Candy House” as the result.
average hoyo translation, but anyway this doesnt change anything they fled from alien space after it was destroyed to whatever bubble world using that tool
 
average hoyo translation, but anyway this doesnt change anything they fled from alien space after it was destroyed to whatever bubble world using that tool
The original text says “candy house,” so why is it interpreted as a tool? It can be interpreted that the candy house world possesses dimensional travel capabilities.
 
The original text says “candy house,” so why is it interpreted as a tool? It can be interpreted that the candy house world possesses dimensional travel capabilities.
because it specifically says the candy house is located inside bubble world in ch 25 EX so it just cannot be world similarly how it was located inside alien space before it was destroyed and they fled to sea of quanta
 
because it specifically says the candy house is located inside bubble world in ch 25 EX so it just cannot be world similarly how it was located inside alien space before it was destroyed and they fled to sea of quanta
The reason Candy House is inside the Bubble Universe is simple.
It's because the Candy House world underwent dimensional travel and entered the Bubble Universe.


If what you say is true, then before moving to the bubble universe, Sugars' world should not be called Candy House.
 
Simply put, it's not that the tools possess power; rather, power is inherent in the world itself.

Could you please provide the reference where the setting about a tool named ‘Candy House’ is located?
 
Last edited:
The reason Candy House is inside the Bubble Universe is simple.
It's because the Candy House world underwent dimensional travel and entered the Bubble Universe.


If what you say is true, then before moving to the bubble universe, Sugars' world should not be called Candy House.
whatever, i just dont see how this has to do with alien space, the small sized bubble is something else entirely while alien space is entire higher dimension so this is irrelevant topic
 
whatever, i just dont see how this has to do with alien space, the small sized bubble is something else entirely while alien space is entire higher dimension so this is irrelevant topic
It's true that the Bubble Universe is different from the Candy House.
The important thing is that the Candy House can enter the Bubble Universe.

If the Candy House is larger than the Bubble Universe, it cannot enter the Bubble Universe.
 
Welt destroyed Alien space alongside ryusuke since he basically merged with higher dimension
Candy House being bubble universe is the scan YOU sent when durandal and kira talk
You said it's a higher dimension than the Candy House.
This means the Candy House is where Welt is, and Ryusuke is in a higher dimension than the Candy House.

The Candy houses size must be at least 3A. to meet 4D which is included in the L2C classification
 
It's true that the Bubble Universe is different from the Candy House.
The important thing is that the Candy House can enter the Bubble Universe.

If the Candy House is larger than the Bubble Universe, it cannot enter the Bubble Universe.
this whole argument is pointless and derailing the thread. candy house is NOT alien space it was just where the sugars moved the candy house to after their world was destroyed. this isnt even taking into account bubble worlds vary in size (scan 2)
 
You said it's a higher dimension than the Candy House.
This means the Candy House is where Welt is, and Ryusuke is in a higher dimension than the Candy House.
?????????????????????????????????????????????????
bro just saying anything 😭.
listen Alien space is the actual 4D space the one ryusuke merged with and literally got entire +1D compared to welt, what you are arguing doesnt have to do anything with the alien space, you already provided that candy house is completely separate stuff related to alien space so arguing this is pointless lol
 
?????????????????????????????????????????????????
bro just saying anything 😭.
listen Alien space is the actual 4D space the one ryusuke merged with and literally got entire +1D compared to welt, what you are arguing doesnt have to do anything with the alien space, you already provided that candy house is completely separate stuff related to alien space so arguing this is pointless lol
It's dawn in Korea, so maybe I was too tired to understand what you said. Finally, let me ask: Why is it considered a separate world when both sugar and candy are visible in that space?
 
Back
Top