• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece General Discussion: Elbaph

Ayo, is this true?

 
In your guys opinions, how do you see the gap between Katakuri/Pre-Udon Luffy and characters like the scabbards/Jack? and maybe the Tobi roppo?

Do y'all agree with the wiki rating or nah?
 
In your guys opinions, how do you see the gap between Katakuri/Pre-Udon Luffy and characters like the scabbards/Jack? and maybe the Tobi roppo?

Do y'all agree with the wiki rating or nah?
Probably not that much. Katakuri's probably pretty high into Tier 6.
 
In your guys opinions, how do you see the gap between Katakuri/Pre-Udon Luffy and characters like the scabbards/Jack? and maybe the Tobi roppo?

Do y'all agree with the wiki rating or nah?
I agree with the gap until Katakuri is reintroduced to the main storyline and gets new feats. I think that will happen since Pudding needs to be saved, Katakuri fans just need to be more patient.
 
Last edited:
After remembering the worst piece of criticism I've heard, I've devised this ranking with roughly every canon character in One Piece. Was I generous toward characters I like and not toward ones I dislike? Yes. Why? Because **** characters I don't like, that's why.


May or may not be an existing character:
-Nerona Im
-The Man with the Burn Scar
-Sogeking

Actually irrelevant: 709

Background Relevance(In the background or as part of it): 330

Somewhat Significant: 146

Fairly Significant: 133

Highly Significant: 133

Completely Essential: 56


So anyway, those random people online can suck my Gum-Gum Rocket.
 
After remembering the worst piece of criticism I've heard, I've devised this ranking with roughly every canon character in One Piece. Was I generous toward characters I like and not toward ones I dislike? Yes. Why? Because **** characters I don't like, that's why.


May or may not be an existing character:
-Nerona Im
-The Man with the Burn Scar
-Sogeking

Actually irrelevant: 709

Background Relevance(In the background or as part of it): 330

Somewhat Significant: 146

Fairly Significant: 133

Highly Significant: 133

Completely Essential: 56


So anyway, those random people online can suck my Gum-Gum Rocket.
Man, if One Piece goes for another 5 or 6 years, we might have more One Piece characters than the then-current calendar year.
 
After remembering the worst piece of criticism I've heard, I've devised this ranking with roughly every canon character in One Piece. Was I generous toward characters I like and not toward ones I dislike? Yes. Why? Because **** characters I don't like, that's why.


May or may not be an existing character:
-Nerona Im
-The Man with the Burn Scar
-Sogeking

Actually irrelevant: 709

Background Relevance(In the background or as part of it): 330

Somewhat Significant: 146

Fairly Significant: 133

Highly Significant: 133

Completely Essential: 56


So anyway, those random people online can suck my Gum-Gum Rocket.
For the record, that's 1507 total, 798 being relevant.

Nearly 53%.
 
Which is pretty dumb. Perospero failed to harm the dude who Chopper gets his Continental scaling from. Chopper has no business scaling that high tbh.
Didn't Chopper's damage come from getting shot in the back with piercing weapons?
 
Even Whitebeard got pierced by normal-ass bullets and swords, these are giant arrows created via magic fired by a Yonkou crewmate, and it isn't like they went through him.
I don't care that Whitebeard gets pierced by bullets. You tried to say that Queen tanked Perospero's arrows while Chopper couldn't because the former was covered in scales. That's not a valid argument because those same arrows can pierce through much harder material without issue. Again, Chopper was not durable enough while Queen simply was.
 
I don't care that Whitebeard gets pierced by bullets. You tried to say that Queen tanked Perospero's arrows while Chopper couldn't because the former was covered in scales. That's not a valid argument because those same arrows can pierce through much harder material without issue. Again, Chopper was not durable enough while Queen simply was.
Wait, that would still make Queen's body harder than steel.
 
I kinda understand the projectiles being outliers somewhat, although I still don't think chopper should scale that high. Its inconsequential ultimately speaking.
 
Good choreo? No way oda could ever make something like this
idk if this satire or not but literally the whole kata vs luffy fight is insane and a much better choreographed fight than that animation. Both anime and manga
 
idk if this satire or not but literally the whole kata vs luffy fight is insane
I think luffy vs kat was good but not that impressive, still one of the best post ts fights in terms of choreography but thats not saying a lot
and a much better choreographed fight than that animation. Both anime and manga
I agree with the anime being better, the anime always has great choreography.
 
I think luffy vs kat was good but not that impressive, still one of the best post ts fights in terms of choreography but thats not saying a lot
idk how you don't view it as impressive... Luffy rubber powers vs katakuri mochi powers, Future sight battle with new techniques happening consistently and luffy trying to surpass katakuri during the fight at the same time

And how all of that is displayed is nearly perfect in the manga and anime
I agree with the anime being better, the anime always has great choreography.
Bro the fan animation doesn't even do much in terms of choreography tho... It basically already copies most of the choreography from one piece and the best looking part is where Zoro is against the awakening environment mochi and he's starts running on them to get closer

watch it on mute and you can easily tell which parts are the best looking... The anime and manga of luffy vs katakuri is way better and has more depth than that animation, people can have preferences tho ✋🐵🤚 but to me the fan animation seem one dimensional in some ways compared to luffy vs kata
 
Last edited:
Back
Top