- 230
- 52
People based their ideas on this picture: Wall's Magic Confinement Fusion, which is said to be the same as real life Magnetic Confinement Fusion, which produces temperatures of 200 Million Degrees Celsius.
Now... i've seen someone saying this is from a Mashima interview or a FT databook in order to justify that picture as canon/reliable material... welp, it's not from an interview nor from a databook (FT databooks do not exist btw).
So, where that stuff comes from? To make it shortly it's a personal take of the english translator (Eng FT Volumes):
Basically he translates the Japanese words into english and talks about the folklore behind those japanese words and names. Nothing else, nothing more.
He/She didn't translate how the Magic Confinement Fusion works because there's nothing about it to translate. Nothing official that explains how it works or else. The translator just translated the japanese words that stand for the MCF and pulled out his personal theory.
Yup, he pulled those infos out from his ass, basically. The fact that you can't find anything about MCF in other language-translated FT volumes nor in the RAW Japanese volume is also the final nail in the coffin.
Let's look at another example. Here's his translation about Aqua Metoria and Grand Chariot.
As you can see he's just translating the japanese words of those magics. Nothing about how those magic works or else... cuz there's nothing about how those magic works to begin with. It's not that Jellal is throwing real constellations against his enemies just because the name of his magic is called "Grand Chariot".
And friendly reminder he/she also committed errors while translating, as he/she admitted.
I'd also like to add that nothing would even suggest Wall produced that amount of heat, neither Natsu or anyone else in the series up to date. I mean... in terms of real science If you bring a chunk of the sun's core back to Earth, it would annihilate everything in a 150-mile radius, create a shockwave that would circle the globe, and trigger a global ice age that would last for hundreds or thousands of years. Is something like this happened in the series so far? And the sun core's heat is 27 million degree as a whole... and here we are talking about 200 million degree pulled out by Natsu and others during their fights, as attacks.
Last but not least... to further cement that Wall's magic weapons are NOT like real weapons... this is how a railgun works in Fairy Tail. It shoots electricity. This cannot be more wrong.
================================================================================================
Agree ---> @Greatsage13th , @CiscoTheSoto , @PrinceofPein , @TheRustyOne
Disagree ---> @DemonGodMitchAubin , @CloverDragon03
Something else (explanation) ---> @ByAsura
Now... i've seen someone saying this is from a Mashima interview or a FT databook in order to justify that picture as canon/reliable material... welp, it's not from an interview nor from a databook (FT databooks do not exist btw).
So, where that stuff comes from? To make it shortly it's a personal take of the english translator (Eng FT Volumes):
Basically he translates the Japanese words into english and talks about the folklore behind those japanese words and names. Nothing else, nothing more.
He/She didn't translate how the Magic Confinement Fusion works because there's nothing about it to translate. Nothing official that explains how it works or else. The translator just translated the japanese words that stand for the MCF and pulled out his personal theory.
Yup, he pulled those infos out from his ass, basically. The fact that you can't find anything about MCF in other language-translated FT volumes nor in the RAW Japanese volume is also the final nail in the coffin.
Let's look at another example. Here's his translation about Aqua Metoria and Grand Chariot.
As you can see he's just translating the japanese words of those magics. Nothing about how those magic works or else... cuz there's nothing about how those magic works to begin with. It's not that Jellal is throwing real constellations against his enemies just because the name of his magic is called "Grand Chariot".
And friendly reminder he/she also committed errors while translating, as he/she admitted.
I'd also like to add that nothing would even suggest Wall produced that amount of heat, neither Natsu or anyone else in the series up to date. I mean... in terms of real science If you bring a chunk of the sun's core back to Earth, it would annihilate everything in a 150-mile radius, create a shockwave that would circle the globe, and trigger a global ice age that would last for hundreds or thousands of years. Is something like this happened in the series so far? And the sun core's heat is 27 million degree as a whole... and here we are talking about 200 million degree pulled out by Natsu and others during their fights, as attacks.
Last but not least... to further cement that Wall's magic weapons are NOT like real weapons... this is how a railgun works in Fairy Tail. It shoots electricity. This cannot be more wrong.
Shortly:
- Magic Confinement Fusion heat infodump = the equivalent of a fan-theory made by an english translator. Hence not canon nor official nor Mashima related.
- There's nothing that would even remotely suggest Wall's magic is 200mln degree, especially in terms of real science and natural events.
Characters that should be downgraded:
Natsu
Wall Eehto
Invel
Whoever scales from the false 200mln degree heat
================================================================================================
Agree ---> @Greatsage13th , @CiscoTheSoto , @PrinceofPein , @TheRustyOne
Disagree ---> @DemonGodMitchAubin , @CloverDragon03
Something else (explanation) ---> @ByAsura
Last edited: