The Wiki Audit Hub

Summary

A while ago we posed the question of creating a wiki audit. A while after that we laid out how we'd do it, and asked for people to volunteer. We now have a group of twenty people including both staff and regular users.

The idea (I won't bother explaining it in-depth again, since it was spoken about on the last threads) is that we'll go through each verse in alphabetical order and see if they have justifications for their most notable abilities and stats. This thread will be kept locked to be updated by Auditors only, with each post announcing the day's changes (optimally changes will be announced at the end of each day until the audit is done.

The Lists
Each list/category is a representation of the audit's current rating of a verse (this can change if users can assist in CRTing or just fixing the verse). It is strongly advised you follow this thread and keep an eye on the lists to see if verses you are knowledgeable on have been changed.

Gree verses are in such a state that they require no CRT- they possess reasonably explained abilities and legitimate reasons for their ratings. Optimally all verses will be in this category with the help of the Auditors.

Yellow verses miss some criteria detailed in the last thread (linked above) but not so much it is fully unreliable. In these instances it is unlikely that a CRT will even be needed- merely clarifications on the profile, fixes to structure, and other small things.

Orange verses are those that could be deleted if it weren't for the presence of active members, preferably those that are working on it. Keep in mind that such a verse will be deleted if active members aren't willing to put in immediate work to bring it to a more acceptable station. If CRTs are able to provide the level of information required, such verses may be saved.

Red verses are those in immediate danger of being deleted. In such cases, either the active members have failed to provide information regarding their ratings, or there are no active members capable of revising/explaining the verse to the Auditors. These verses need to either be adopted by users familiar with them and willing to fix them, or be removed due to unreliability.

Note that we aren't listing White here (since the White category is just a verse that hasn't been evaluated yet) and Grey (since these verses have literally zero pages, they will be deleted on the spot).

Auditors

• Mr. Bambu
• Agnaa
• Wokista
• The Divine Phoenix
• Damage3245
• Promestei
• Sir Ovens
• Steven Pogi Paitao
• IMadeThisOn8-1-2017
• ShiroyashaGinSa
• Monarch Laciel
• Edwellke
• Xulrev
• AKM sama
• Elizhaa
• GyroNutz
• DarkDragonMedeus
• Crabwhale
• Qawsedf234
• DarkGrath

Audit Changes so Far:

Green Verses

• Idling to Rule the Gods has been put into the Green category (Wokistan)
  
  
  • 123 Slaughter Me Street has been put into the Green category (GyroNutz)
  • Imscared has been put into the Green category (Wokistan)
  • Block Story has been put into the Green category (Promestein)
  • Incarnations of Immortality has been put into the Green Category (Wokistan)
  • InFAMOUS has been put into the Green Category (Wokistan)
  • Samurai 8 has been put into the Green Category (Crabwhale)
  • Blood has been put into the Green Category (Edwellken)
  • Samurai Jack has been put into the Green Category (Crabwhale)
  • Ip Man has been put into the Green Category (Wokistan)
  • A Catastrophe Report has been put into the Green Category (GyroNutz)
  • Iron Kingdoms has been put into the Green Category (Wokistan)
  • Iruna and Toram Online has been put into the Green Category (Wokistan)
  • Once Upon a Time has been put into the Green Category (Steven Pogi Paitao)
  • Outlast has been put into the Green Category (Steven Pogi Paitao)
  • OFF has been put into the Green Category (Sir Ovens)
  • Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? Has been put into the Green Category (Mr. Bambu)
  • RWBY has been put into the Green Category (Steven Pogi Paitao)
  • The Strongest Girl has been put into the Green Category (Damage3245)
  • Fortnite has been put into the Green Category (Elizhaa)
  • Izuna has been put into the Green Category (Mr. Bambu)
  • Isekai Mahou wa Okureteru has been put into the Green Category (Mr. Bambu)
  • Isekai Maou to Shoukan Shoujo no Dorei Majutsu has been put into the Green Category (Mr. Bambu)
  • Izure Shinwa no Ragnarok has been put into the Green Category (Mr. Bambu)
  • Okami has been put into the Green Category (IMade)

Yellow Verses

• Iczer was placed here by Wokistan ("Mostly okay, though 4-B first key is probably High 4-C and MFTL needs a calc and a link that doesn't try to download itself.")
  
  
  • Ijii was placed here by Wokistan ("I'm not the biggest fan of 9-A justification not listing an example of human heavy weapons to scale to, and the tier 7 justification is also bad, but other parts seem okay."
  • Ikki Tousen was placed here by Wokistan ("Maybe green. I don't like taking a statement like that literally to get 9-A without support for it being literal explained and the verse seems really bare, but there's nothing really wrong with it besides that."
  • Sakura Dungeon was placed here by The Divine Phoenix (Lacking calcs and some of the AP justifications are off, such as the 6-C justification not being 6-C at all and generic storms being Low 7-B, but it has supporters and the abilities are mostly fine, aside from Higher Dimensional Manipulation which should be explained better)
  • Inazuma Eleven was placed here by Wokistan ("Resistance to time stop doesn't seem to make sense and generally abilities could use some sources/explanation but no other issues.
  • Salt and Sanctuary was placed here by The Divine Phoenix ("7-B should be Low 7-B for the generic storm and the last key abilities could use explanation, the rest seems fine")
  • Infinite Stratos was placed here by Wokistan (9-C seems more 10-A, some general cleaning should be done on the formatting side, and using the 7-C cruise missile due to "countries can't destroy these" seems kinda arbitrary, but serviceable besides that.)
  • Fossil Fighters was placed here by Elizhaa/DarkDragonMedeus (We think it is Yellow. Regarding: *Frigi *Hunter *Igno *Dynal *Zongazonga Their At least 7-B be rating scaled to this: [Igno's and Frigi's clash would have leveled Vivosaur Island, Igno is stated to have absorbed all of the heat and energy of an active volcano. ]This feat sounds too vague and we think need a calculation especially since volcano's feats can varied from 7-B to High 6-C; some volcano's feat are way higher… (carries on, please consult Elizhaa and DDM concerning this if you will)
  • Samurai Deeper Kyo was placed here by Crabwhale (Mostly alright, although some of the formatting is weird, one or two statistics are missing and some explanations are missing. Also the one linked supporter is inactive.)
  • Instant Death was placed here by Wokistan (More green than orange. Main concerns are Yogiri's untyped concept manip and taking some of the "1/10k as strong as this guy" statements literally without further support.)
  • InuYasha was placed here by Wokistan (Some pretty minor formatting hiccups.)
  • Inuyashiki was placed here by Wokistan (Circular scaling here. Someone's dura is from taking attacks from someone, and their AP is from damaging the other guy.)
  • Invaders of the Rokujouma was placed here by Wokistan (2-A seems 2-B and I'm not liking the whole "tier via size" thing going on. Would like to note that the abilities are explained, bt its in notable attacks and techniques.)
  • Absolute Duo was placed here by GyroNutz (Verse is generally solid, couple grammar mistakes here and there, main thing is that there should be a source for their High 8-C rating, otherwise it'd be green)
  • Tom and Jerry was placed here by Damage3245 (Profiles are not great; having pretty few calcs and a lot of rating justifications without sources.)
  • 007 was placed here by AKM sama (Uncontroversial ratings that can be relied upon to be correct but still need sources. A few abilities and resistances need justifications. Has active members that can turn it into green with a CRT.)
  • The Twilight Zone was placed here by Damage3245 (Only a single profile for the verse with unknown ratings and could do with more justifications / elaboration)
  • The Witch's House was placed here by Damage3245 (No calcs for the verse. Justifications have no sources / links but profiles are decently written. Just needs general improvement + sources for feats.)

Orange Verses

• Nurarihyon no Mago was placed here by Sir Ovens (No comment)
  
  
  • Sakamoto desu ga was placed here by The Divine Phoenix (the verse has the issue of no AP justification, no supporters or anything either, however the abilities don't seem to have any issues and it has a speed calc)
  • Pathfinder was placed here by Steven Pogi Paitao (Verse has no calcs, no supporters, some abilities need elaboration. Bordering becoming a Red)
  • Ico was placed here by Edwellken (No comment)
  • Ichiban Ushiro no Daimaou was placed here by Wokistan (Pretty much by default, given that it's tier 0. No readily avalible explanation blog, the justifications on the profile are not 1-A or 0, none of the abilities are explained at all, but its saved from Red by actual structure being okay, DontTalk, and the existence of an active CRT.)
  • Ilona Mitrecey was placed here by Wokistan ("Unknown" for most stats, that speed thing is absolutely not subsonic, and it seems like mere visual effects of a music video are taken as things a character is actively doing for an ability.
  • A House of Many Doors was placed here by GyroNutz (No sources for higher tier ratings or good justification for Ashen's 8-B rating, Ashen's profile has grammar issues and Lucetta has 21 resistances which are scarcely explained. Types for abstract existence/concept manipulation aren't listed. Speed calc isn't linked on the profiles.)
  • Inheritance Cycle was placed here by Wokistan (The profiles for dragons are not good, and one doesn't have justifications for anything. The other profiles are fine though and unlike with Image it wasn't a minority, so it's here as opposed to red)
  • A Song of Ice and Fire was placed here by GyroNutz (A lot of the profiles were fine after I cleaned them up, but many profiles still have ratings with no scaling/justification whatsoever. Among the profiles are two profiles with no abilities and regular human stats, along with a profile with two keys that are practically identical, which probably shouldn't exist. Children of the Forest's 6-B feat seems questionable.)
  • Ah! My Goodness was placed here by GyroNutz (The one profile has somewhat sloppy formatting, no further explanation for abilities or types for regen/immortality and most importantly its tier 1 scans don't work.)
  • Toilet in Wonderland was placed here by Damage3245 (Only two profiles but lacking in calcs. Has some links in justifications to feats but also has justification that are just referencing other characters who don't have profiles yet.)
  • Uber was placed here by IMade (Not many profiles and few of them are missing proper justifications. Calcs can be done for the profiles that do have linked feats. Only one supporter for the verse who is at least active.)

Red Verses

• 100% Orange Juice was placed here by GyroNutz (The verse has no calcs, no sources backing up its ratings, and a fair few of its justifications fall flat even without sources. The main contributor/supporter is inactive and some of the structure is confusing.)
  
  
  • Idol Mahou Shoujo Chiruchiru Michiru was placed here by Wokistan (This is very red. The High 8-C and 8-B have super vague justifications of "killed a big guy" and "made a bombardment", then there's a High 2-A with some of the strongest abilities on the site (Acausal 5, concept 2) and no explanations for any of this.)
  • Image Comics was placed here by Wokistan (Note that this is more due to the idea of judging the verses by worse off files. While some are good like Spawn, others have literally nothing like Best Tiger. The verse in general suffers from a lack of justification for powers (besides Spawn) and messy scaling, calcless things, and formatting issues. I saw "Class MJ Striking Strength" on a profile. WOuldn't be above Orange anyways, but the worst profiles really push this one down. As it is, a lot of files should be deleted, but not all of them.)
  • Infinity Blade was placed here by Wokistan (Nothing is really justified except the abilities, and Monarch doesn't seem to have done much with it in a while.)
  • Interlude was placed here by Wokistan (The files just don't have proof of anything, nor do they have regular stats.)
  • InterWorld was placed here by Wokistan (Again nothing is really justified or proven.)
  • Invader Zim was placed here by Wokistan (Could go orange, but in dire need of calcs. Reaction speed via the speed their vehicle travels at is a big no)
  • Samurai Shodown was placed here by Crabwhale (No calcs on the profiles, unexplained powers, bad powerscaling, little to no explanations whatsoever on AP or speed)
  • TOME (verse) was placed here by Damage3245 (Generally lacking content, almost no verifiable calcs, no sources or justifications for others, and only a single supporter for the verse.)
  • To Be a Power in the Shadows was placed here by Damage3245 (Completely lacking in calcs or solid justifications for any stats on the 5 profiles for the verse. Has a supporter for the verse but needs major work on all the profiles.)
  • Tokyo Alice was placed here by Damage3245 (Only one page for the verse with no stats or summary, and a single supporter.)
  • Tokyo ESP was placed here by Damage3245 (Virtually no justifications for ratings across several profiles. Virtually no calcs. Only a single supporter.)
  • Tibia was placed here by Damage3245 (No calcs and no reliable information in justifications for ratings in the two profiles for this verse. No supporters. Only one of the profiles is decently written but ratings need major work.)
  • Tiger & Bunny was placed here by Damage3245 (The verse has a couple of calcs from other sites but most statistics lack justifications. No active supporters. Profiles generally have a few formatting errors in them too.)
  • Zorro was placed here by IMade (The supporters are either inconsistently active, not active and with one who is active. There are no justifications, calcs nor linked feats for any of the three profiles. Verse page could use a rewrite.)
  • Zork was placed here by IMade (Only one supporter, verse page is lacking, three profiles lacking justifications and calcs. Formatting errors throughout the pages.)

That's all for today, this will be updated with any new audits/changes in classification tomorrow.

New Audit Changes:

Changelog:

• Lord Xue Ying has changed from Yellow to Green by DarkGrath

• Sakamoto Desu ga changed from Yellow to Green by The Divine Phoenix

• Zorro changed from Red to Green by IMade

• Uber changed from Orange to Red by IMade

Green Verses:

• Lobotomy Corporation, Monarch Laciel

• Zombie Land Saga, IMade

• Looney Tunes, Monarch Laciel

• Saw, Crabwhale

• One Piece, Sir Ovens

• LSD Dream Emulator, DarkGrath

• Friday the 13th, Elizhaa

• Ju-On: The Grudge, Wokistan

• The Ring, Damage3245

• The Matrix, Damage3245

• Fukashigi Philia, DarkDragonMedeus

Yellow Verses:

• Love, Chunbiyo, and other Delusions was placed here by DarkGrath ("Only one page with 0 supporters and 1 inactive knowledgeable member, so it's understandable. Just got some mildly off justifications on it's character page and weird wording/formatting. Monarch said he'll handle it a bit later.")

• Lord of the Rings was placed here by Monarch Laciel ("A lot of non-standard wording and power listings without links to appropriate power pages, a few unknown ratings, a few profiles with only a bare minimum, at least one profile that has stats listed out of the standard order (range between speed and AP), but a lot of supporters who'd probably be willing to fix it")

• Lockwood and Co was placed here by DarkGrath ("Strongly in the yellow. Generally well formatted pages with decent justifications, with some major exceptions especially regarding speed statistics. I've contacted the main supporter already.")

• Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark was placed here by The Divine Phoenix ("Maybe leaning slightly towards orange, some unexplained abilities that could use more elaboration, like Death and Fate Manip, some of the stats are not properly formatted, but most things make sense")

• Ajin was placed here by GyroNutz ("AP, while not controversial, should be justified. Abilities are generally well explained otherwise.")

• Freedom Planet was placed here by Elizhaa ("The current rating is from this statement and with a calculation in Sash Lilac's profile: Building level (Damaged and defeated the Holodragon, which was the size of a building, and also destroyed Lord Brevon's entire army. Easily defeated a robot that collapsed part of a building)"...and so on, contact Elizhaa)

• Jeff the Killer Saga was placed here by Wokistan ("While i find "at least 9-B, likely 3-A" to be rather ridiculous (legit just call something an outlier or determine who is stronger than what), the justifications listed would be sufficient for it by the standards of most of the wiki. However, some powers could do with better explanation, beyond just stuff like "can send him away" for BFR. Zalgo's a major offender for this.")

• Clowderverse was placed here by Wokistan ("Some small issues. Firstly, I do not believe the justification listed on Vermis Worms is sufficient for High 3-A, it doesn't really seem that quantifiable. Secondly, some profiles like the flea have justifications of "shouldn't be much weaker than x" without explaining why they shouldn't be much weaker. Thirdly, Automatons, First Person Shooter, Head Yard Hydra, Automatons, all need the explanations for scaling in speed put in. Fourthly, I don't think Fictionist can get a "should be" if it doesn't fight. Fifthly, Emnn can't be 2-B now that we aren't scaling to that by multipliers. Finally, the conceptual manipulation of Genie should be updated in accordance with the types, as Genie predates this split.")

• Jurrasic Fight Club was placed here by Wokistan ("Small issues. Firstly, the Komodo Dragon link seems to be broken. Secondly, I'm not sure that we award vibration manipulation for just normal actions, lest everyone who talks have non combat applicable vibration.")

• Blood Lad was placed here by Promestein ("Nothing is calced, and the feats here should really be calced, given that they involve things like mountain destroying. The powers are justified, at least.")

• The Hero is Overpowered but Overly Cautious was placed here by Damage3245 ("Profiles have sources and explanations but really need some refining and details added to them.")

• The Devil is a Part Timer was placed here by Damage3245 ("Only a single profile. Has links to feats but only a single calc from another forum which needs remaking on here.")

Orange Verses:

• The Magic Circle was placed here by Damage3245 ("Lacking in the justifications section plus no calcs. But does have @Mr. Bambu as a supporter so I presume he can improve the couple of profiles that are there.")

• A Hat in Time was placed here by Monarch Laciel ("Speed justification is unreliable and probably wrong. Has no calcs. AP justification is also shaky given they all are scaled to a feat performed by several time pieces in an unknown amount of time through hax and a character was empowered by some of those pieces. Justifications for Acausality and Dura Negation also don't make sense. Has a few active members tho.")

• Freezing was placed here by Elizhaa (" from my and Medeus's conclusion, the verse is orange. A lot of profile tier looks to be based on circular reasonings and there looks to be called no justification or links calculations for the Pandora's feat. Even some 8-B are being powerscled to be much stronger than some 7-C in AP justification i.e: [Isuzu Sawatari At least City Block level (Much more stronger than Satellizer [7-C]) There is also no current supporters but only two active knowledgeable members: A6colute AKM sama Their God tier looks fine; "At least two planes of higher infinity above an infinite number of timelines" does sound like at least Low 1-C.")

• The Rising of the Shield Hero was placed here by Damage3245 ("No calcs and few sourced justifications for any of the stats, does have a few supporters on the main verse page and profiles looks decently written outside of the stats.")

• Jurassic Park was placed here by Wokistan ("The Player's calc was never accepted, and death manip should be poison manip. Spinosaurus needs its feat calced. Pretty sure destroying cars is not 9-A (T Rex), and the building destruction should be calced or at least linked on the file. Compsognathus scales to profiles that we don't have on the site, Velociraptor has a 9-C+ with no calc (not legal), I have no clue who this "echo" blue's file refers to is, Parachus is 9-B off scaling to a file that doesn't exist that scales to a 9-C, the I.Rex needs its building collapse calced or listed (that can easily be 9-B), Titanoba is 9-B off "kills dinosaurs" in a verse with 9-C dinos.")

• One-T was placed here by Sir Ovens ("Only one page; said page is severely lacking explanations for stats and is an overall very barebones profile. However, the sole supporter of the verse is Ogurtsow, who by virtue of being staff, should be active and available to fix up the page.")

• Ore, Twintail ni Narimasu was placed here by Sir Ovens ("Pages don't have calcs and the reasons for their stats are vague. There aren't even any links to scans to prove the ratings.")

Red verses:

• Sand Land was placed here by Crabwhale ("Justifications make no sense and have no sources, for the ones that are even there, along with no active supporters.")

• The Secret Life of Pets was placed here by Damage3245 ("Few solid justifications, no calcs, and most of the ratings just seem to be circularly linking back to themselves. Only one supporter for the verse.")

• The Reunion with Twelve Fascinating Goddesses was placed here by Damage3245 ("No calcs or sources for the justifications on the profiles. Profiles are formatted poorly (has multiple keys but some ratings only have a single key).")

• Jet Set Radio was placed here by Wokistan ("I deleted this one though. The files don't justify anything and scale to a character who doesn't have a file, and Sera (only listed supporter) said she'd rather just remove the stuff anyways to start fresh. She can always retrieve the pages herself if she changes her mind, being an admin. also the pages haven't been updated in > 1 year so i kinda doubt anyone else was going to do stuff with it")

More to come.

Since Bambi is offline, I'm just gonna update this myself.

Changelog:

• Juuni Taisen: Zodiac War has changed from Yellow to Green by Mr. Bambu
• Jurassic Fight Club changed from Yellow to Green by Wokistan
• Lockwood and Co. changed from Yellow' 'to Green by DarkGrath
• Inheritance Cycle changed from Orange to Green by DarkDragonMedeus

Green Verses:

• Tekken, Verlux
• Scream, Crabwhale
• Scurd the Disposable Assassin, Crabwhale
• Saw, Crabwhale
• Pokemon, Steven Pogi Paitao

Yellow Verses:

• K Project was placed here by Mr. Bambu ("9-C scales to Misaki Yata who doesn't have any justification (I assume it comes from the bat but then why do people scale to him physically?). There's also some weird formatting errors like all caps and random words in the quote sections of pages (See: Sarujiko Fushimi). I think the 10-B page with no powers doesn't exactly need to exist but it isn't hurting anybody. Aside from this, nothing is really controversial enough to be any worse than Yellow.")
• Fullmetal Alchemist was placed here by Elizhaa ("About Fullmetal Alchemist, I think some of the justifications are too vague. Like for some Alchemist, High 8-C is from comparable to State Alchemist. The only High 8-C calc is from Edward Eric. They should powerscaled to him at least on their profiles. Edward Eric 9-B's justification is bit iffy since he soften/brittle Greed's armor with Alchemy then destroyed the carbon Video proof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZ3XPULM1AY&t=179s He could powerscaled to the verse valid's 9-B, still. I and DarkDragonMedeus think the verse is yellow.")
• Furi was placed here by Elizhaa ("I and Medeus think Furi looks is a yellow verse. At a first glance, there doesn't seems to be problems with current tiers and abilities, but there were complaints about them and others abilities were brought here: https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/3288242 . So, some better calculations and fixing the abilities's problem would be good toward improving the Verse's status.")
• Scott Pilgrim was placed here by Crabwhale ("Mostly fine, but a good few chunks of the AP don't make any sense (like Wall level+ as a major statistic without any calcs). Also the speeds are kind of unjustified, at least the "Superhuman" ones.")
• Teen Titans was placed here by Verlux ("All persons in the verse scale from Beast Boy in speed, who has no linked calc and an assertion of 'casually dodges lightning' with no feat or calc linked, random assertions for tiering with no backing for at least two characters")
• G.I. Joe was placed here by Elizhaa ("DarkDragonMedeus and I looked up G.I. Joe, while I think the profiles' tiers looks legit. It look like the majority of calculations by Jasonsith used as a justifications, were not evaluated and not accepted by Calc group. Ex: Those from Snake-Eyes. The verse is legit yellow but can be fixed by getting calculations evaluated and accepted.")
• OneShot was placed here by Sir Ovens ("The universal stuff checks out since I've seen gameplay of the game, but links to statements would be nice. The street level ratings need to be properly referenced because I don't buy the explanation that was given without proper evidence. Other than that, it should be fine..")
• Oniwakamaru The Visitor was placed here by Sir Ovens ("Would honestly be green if the the other profiles in the verse followed Hitori's profile. Just gotta copy and paste the explanations that Hotori's profile was given on the other two profiles and it should be Gucci.")
• Gakkou Gurashi! was placed here by DarkDragonMedeus ("From what Elizhaa and I discussed. Everyone scales from Zombies, who are 9-B with 9-C durability where as everyone is 10-A but 9-C with weapons. The 9-B feat looks pretty cut and paste, but it should scale to durability via Newton's third law. And those who can kill Zombies "easily" should be 9-B.")
• The Carpet People was placed here by Damage3245 ("Profiles are generally fine but could use some sources on a few of the stats.")
• Game & Watch was placed here by Elizhaa ("Medeus and I believe after looking at the calculations (https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Saikou_The_Lewd_King/Game_&_Watch_stuff) that some of them look more like reaction speed for catching small objects so are calc stacking. For stuff that is legit launching someone at great speeds, those calculations are fine. Speed ratings are fine, but something about the KE calculation likely is needed to be done. The verse is yellow.")

Orange Verses:

• Scooby Doo was placed here by The Divine Phoenix ("Main issue is the Evil Entity profile, Higher-D existence and manipulation aren't properly backed up and none of the abilities have any explanations, aside from that things are mostly fine, but we judge by worst profile so that's the result")
• Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was placed here by Verlux ("No rationale for over 50% of profiles' given tiering or physicals in general, only one subsection of the verse has any good work done on profiles, needs a massive overhaul of quite a few profiles")
• Futurama was placed here by Elizhaa ("I and DarkDragonMedeus looked up Futurama and we agree it to be a orange verse. A lot justifications look to be missing. Some characters are just High 3-A from a 4-D statement with no proper context like Mobius Dick. Yivo's Tier looks to be mess at 4-A with no justifications.")
• Gakusen Toshi Asterisk was placed here by DarkDragonMedeus ("One inactive supporter and one profile. His speed looks fine, but his fireball busting feat needs a better calculation.")
• Akatsuki Blitzkampf was placed here by GyroNutz ("The verse's AP is justified, but the scaling is weird (9-As who are considered equals to 9-A, likely 8-Cs are only 9-A). The speed is for the most part unjustified and messy with a MHS+ rating being given for dodging electricity. Abilities are, for the most part, explained where necessary. Two active supporters")
• Akira was placed here by GyroNutz ("No scans to back up tier 2 ratings, and they're based off a big bang which can be interpreted as 3-A anyway. Relavistic+ reactions are based off a laser which doesn't seem to meet light standards. Two profiles have no justifications whatsoever, and most abilities in general are unexplained. One active supporter.")
• Gamaran was placed here by DarkDragonMedeus ("Problems are mostly in the verse page by how dated it appears. This includes Supperters/Opponents/Neutral being unfinished, characters being poorly formatted, and power of the verse being bare bones. The characters are mostly fine in terms of tier and speed, but their durability an striking strength should line up with their Tiers.")
• Scribblenauts was placed here by Crabwhale ("Almost no justifications whatsoever outside of the DC stuff, and even using common sense it doesn't work out (nukes are not automatically 7-B, meteors are not automatically 6-B, etc.")

Red verses:

• Kado;The Right Answer was placed here by Mr. Bambu ("Formatting for the verse is way off, no discussions since the literal only one two years ago, 1-B doesn't seem to be layers of transcendence so automatically goes through the ringer with upcoming tiering changes and it seems like nobody will be able to re-tier it. Lots of notable abilities are just sort of there (Concept Manip for example, which has no type on it).")
• Teen Wolf was placed here by Verlux ("No calcs at all, only one supporter, no knowledgable members, no actual backing or feats anywhere(and the supporter is a blocked person so nobody can even work on this verse, it should be deleted, gonna move it to grey, didn't see they were blocked)")
• The Book Eating Magician was placed here by Damage3245 ("Lacking sources, calcs or even justifications for almost all of the stats. Profiles also need tidying up / slimming down in the powers section.")
• The Breaker was placed here by Damage3245 ("Also lacking sources, calcs or justifications for the majority of the stats on all profiles. Power & Abilities sections are outdated and need tidying.")

Wew. Someone should really thank Bambu. Doing this takes effort.