- 19,123
- 6,335
AP for regular magical girls
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Kaltias/Size_of_Elly's_labyrinth
So, i made this calc to quantify Elly's labyrinth and as a result, we now know that Sayaka stomped a baseline 7-C.Given that Sayaka pretty much slammed into the ground alongside Elly and was fine, her dura (0.5) should scale.
As a new scale i would propose:
0=Low 7-C
0.5-2 = 7-C
2.5-3 = At least 7-C
3.5 = At least 7-C, likely higher
4 = High 7-C
4.5 = Low 7-B (Based on Mami's feat)
The question is what we do with 0 (Homura, Oriko and weakest magical girls in general). Weaker, but not immensely (Homura did stunned Sayaka with a kick in Rebellion) so maybe Low 7-C?
Speed for regular magical girls
Talking about speed instead, i think that the ratings right now are a bit lowballed. We already have Homura (speed rating of 0) being Mach 619. That's over 60% of baseline MHS+ speed. Now, someone like Sayaka is easily faster than Homura (Blitzed her durinng Rebellion). Sayaka's rating is a 2. So, given that 2 is >>>>> Mach 619, wouldn't 2.5 and onwards be MHS+?
Top tiers revision
Now moving onwards to the top tiers. We know that Madoka becomes stronger with each timeline, correct? As we can see here (Where we can also see that Homura's forcefield is actually at most 5-C) she stomped Walpurgis Nacht during the first timeline where Homura decided to fight on her own (the fourth). We know due to WoG that Homura resetted the timeline 100 times (give or take) so, given that she becomes more powerful with each reset (look at her stats) i think that it's safe to assume that now she reached Low 5-B. For a similar reason, she should probably be "At least Massively Hypersonic+, likely higher", alongside everyone who scales.
Last thing, Kriemhild Gretchen has a statement of being able to destroy the world within 10 days. Normally i'd say that it's too vague, but considering that Gretchen is already Low 5-B via scaling, the statement could refer to the planet, so maybe "At least Low 5-B, possibly 5-B".
Proposed ratings for magical girls without official stats
Kirika as 7-C with "At least Low 7-C" dura (Via harming Mami, but i don't think that she tanked anything), Kazumi as "At least Low 7-C" (At least as strong as Homura) in her first key and 7-C in the second one (Stronger than before, should be stronger than Elly).
Suzune as "At least 7-C, possibly Low 7-B" with "At least 7-C dura" (For basically the same reasoning as her current stats).
Oriko as Low 7-C (One of the weakest magical girls).
Nagisa as "At least Low 7-C" via being at least as strong as Homura.
Misc stuff
Now that we consider Homura's shield (And by extension the Isolation Zone) as a nonexistent timeline, this means that Homura and Madoka are fully omnipresent (don't think that existing in nonexistence is a requirement to be omnipresent). As you can see here, the shield links to the obsolete timeline (no longer part of the multiverse). And as you can see here,Kyubey possess a shard of the shield.
Another thing is that the witch that Kazumi defeated is compared to Walpurgis both by Kyubey and the databook of the manga. So, "At least 7-B, possibly 5-C/far higher" Kazumi?
There is also this calc placing Patricia at Low 7-B. Only Homura scales.
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:Kaltias/Size_of_Elly's_labyrinth
So, i made this calc to quantify Elly's labyrinth and as a result, we now know that Sayaka stomped a baseline 7-C.Given that Sayaka pretty much slammed into the ground alongside Elly and was fine, her dura (0.5) should scale.
As a new scale i would propose:
0=Low 7-C
0.5-2 = 7-C
2.5-3 = At least 7-C
3.5 = At least 7-C, likely higher
4 = High 7-C
4.5 = Low 7-B (Based on Mami's feat)
The question is what we do with 0 (Homura, Oriko and weakest magical girls in general). Weaker, but not immensely (Homura did stunned Sayaka with a kick in Rebellion) so maybe Low 7-C?
Speed for regular magical girls
Talking about speed instead, i think that the ratings right now are a bit lowballed. We already have Homura (speed rating of 0) being Mach 619. That's over 60% of baseline MHS+ speed. Now, someone like Sayaka is easily faster than Homura (Blitzed her durinng Rebellion). Sayaka's rating is a 2. So, given that 2 is >>>>> Mach 619, wouldn't 2.5 and onwards be MHS+?
Top tiers revision
Now moving onwards to the top tiers. We know that Madoka becomes stronger with each timeline, correct? As we can see here (Where we can also see that Homura's forcefield is actually at most 5-C) she stomped Walpurgis Nacht during the first timeline where Homura decided to fight on her own (the fourth). We know due to WoG that Homura resetted the timeline 100 times (give or take) so, given that she becomes more powerful with each reset (look at her stats) i think that it's safe to assume that now she reached Low 5-B. For a similar reason, she should probably be "At least Massively Hypersonic+, likely higher", alongside everyone who scales.
Last thing, Kriemhild Gretchen has a statement of being able to destroy the world within 10 days. Normally i'd say that it's too vague, but considering that Gretchen is already Low 5-B via scaling, the statement could refer to the planet, so maybe "At least Low 5-B, possibly 5-B".
Proposed ratings for magical girls without official stats
Kirika as 7-C with "At least Low 7-C" dura (Via harming Mami, but i don't think that she tanked anything), Kazumi as "At least Low 7-C" (At least as strong as Homura) in her first key and 7-C in the second one (Stronger than before, should be stronger than Elly).
Suzune as "At least 7-C, possibly Low 7-B" with "At least 7-C dura" (For basically the same reasoning as her current stats).
Oriko as Low 7-C (One of the weakest magical girls).
Nagisa as "At least Low 7-C" via being at least as strong as Homura.
Misc stuff
Now that we consider Homura's shield (And by extension the Isolation Zone) as a nonexistent timeline, this means that Homura and Madoka are fully omnipresent (don't think that existing in nonexistence is a requirement to be omnipresent). As you can see here, the shield links to the obsolete timeline (no longer part of the multiverse). And as you can see here,Kyubey possess a shard of the shield.
Another thing is that the witch that Kazumi defeated is compared to Walpurgis both by Kyubey and the databook of the manga. So, "At least 7-B, possibly 5-C/far higher" Kazumi?
There is also this calc placing Patricia at Low 7-B. Only Homura scales.