• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Yeah, another Undertale upgrade.

Based on what?
Asgore is not in his prime.
The assignment of a prime to Asgore in itself is a headcanon.

Prove he was any stronger during the war than he is now. Physical strength isn't a factor, they're mostly magical so being weaker due to time is impossible.

Gerson also says Asgore stopped aging when Asriel passed away, thus he shouldn't be any weaker.
is depressed and holds back in the fight we also learn that the less the monsters want to fight the worse their stats are.
That doesn't apply for boss monsters, evidently.

Toriel had 80 ATK & DEF even when she didn't want to actually hurt us, yet, she was getting massive damage from our 5 ATK attacks, and doing pitiful damage to us meaning that the 80 DEF we see is her peak. She is also one shot by our genocide route attacks despite keeping her 80 DEF.

Sparing her and making her not wanting to fight us still keeps her 80 DEF.

Unlike Papyrus, which has poor stats before the fight starts, but increases it after we try to spare him in the neutral and pacifist routes.


Asgore's stats also do not waver when we mentally harm him by talking and eating the pie, also proving that his mental state does not affect his overall strength.

Seems as if Boss Monsters can keep their strength at better control due to their strong souls.
Big no no
Denying based on personal preference is not proper in a debate.

Undyne the Undying's attacks are much more complex than Asgore's.

Based on what would you say Asgore has the upper hand in skill?
 
When she is literally determined buffing herself while asgore is literally depressed and wants to die holding back-

Debatable

Nope.

When?
Doesn't mean butt **** all when she's still statistically stronger.

no it isn't. she has better stats than him.

yes she is. she knocked asgore on his ass while trying to become the captain of the royal guard. she says this when you go to her house i believe.
 
Also, the idea that asgore lost badly is headcanon too, canonically the war was "a long battle" which would imply they actually put up a fight.
The war was described as "hardly a war" too, you can't just isolate one piece of information. It's a long war that was so one sided that the monsters couldn't even call a war. Both informations are true, and no, it being long doesn't imply a fight was held for too long, it implies nothing other than the fact it had a long duration. A long lasting massacre is still a massacre, we don't know the reason why it was long.

But admitting the hypothesis of Asgore losing is too a headcanon, you also admit him putting any fight at all is headcanon as well. My hypothesis is supported by the war being described as a one sided massacre.

Possibly 8-B is off the table for me, I'm sorry.
regardless, your idea relies on none of humanities mages were 8-B, despite being able to use magic to create a Low Complex Multi/Multiversal structure to hold them underground. To say a group of weak humans could do that is rediculous.

Oh but that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying there is no evidence or support to suggest Asgore made them use the peak of their soul's determination again him, which is the only moment where a human may be 8-B, otherwise they're 9-A.
 
The assignment of a prime to Asgore in itself is a headcanon.

Prove he was any stronger during the war than he is now. Physical strength isn't a factor, they're mostly magical so being weaker due to time is impossible.

Gerson also says Asgore stopped aging when Asriel passed away, thus he shouldn't be any weaker.
I already proved it since monsters become weaker when they are mentally bad or don't want to engage in a fight. Papyrus is a example his stats are worse than his other route versions because it spares us at the beginning since he doesnt want to fight us. Asgore is depressed while undyen was determined
That doesn't apply for boss monsters, evidently.
What evidence?
Toriel had 80 ATK & DEF even when she didn't want to actually hurt us, yet, she was getting massive damage from our 5 ATK attacks, and doing pitiful damage to us meaning that the 80 DEF we see is her peak. She is also one shot by our genocide route attacks despite keeping her 80 DEF.
That was not her peak. Toriel was holding back massively against us and didn't want to fight against us proving my point
Sparing her and making her not wanting to fight us still keeps her 80 DEF.
How cna you see her stats after sparing her? After you spare her the fight ends? What??
Unlike Papyrus, which has poor stats before the fight starts, but increases it after we try to spare him in the neutral and pacifist routes.
Papyrus stats are lower in genocide since he doesnt want to fight and spares us but his stats are stronger in the others since he actually fights.
Asgore's stats also do not waver when we mentally harm him by talking and eating the pie, also proving that his mental state does not affect his overall strength.
Asgore is already depressed as ****
Denying based on personal preference is not proper in a debate.
Never did.
Undyne the Undying's attacks are much more complex than Asgore's.
Asgore holds back + being hard doesnt mean more skilled. By that logic sans is more skilled than undyne
Based on what would you say Asgore has the upper hand in skill?
Because...he is asgore? Its literally in the stroy that he is superior to undynes base by A LOT
no it isn't. she has better stats than him.
Once again comparing a Depressed wanting to die man vs Undynes new buffed form filled with determination is not fair.
yes she is. she knocked asgore on his ass while trying to become the captain of the royal guard. she says this when you go to her house i believe.
Can I see a scan of that? Undyne talks about how he fought asgore who was not even fighting back and got her ass handled.
 
The war was described as "hardly a war" too, you can't just isolate one piece of information. It's a long war that was so one sided that the monsters couldn't even call a war. Both informations are true, and no, it being long doesn't imply a fight was held for too long, it implies nothing other than the fact it had a long duration. A long lasting massacre is still a massacre, we don't know the reason why it was long.

But admitting the hypothesis of Asgore losing is too a headcanon, you also admit him putting any fight at all is headcanon as well. My hypothesis is supported by the war being described as a one sided massacre.

Possibly 8-B is off the table for me, I'm sorry.
using any example from Monsterkind themselves aint reliable. barely any monsters in the war survived to see the end of it besides Asgore, and Gerson. (Both who fought in the frontlines)

everyone else wasn't actively fighting in it, and what they say is likely exaggerated due to their irrational fear of humans.
I already proved it since monsters become weaker when they are mentally bad or don't want to engage in a fight. Papyrus is a example his stats are worse than his other route versions because it spares us at the beginning since he doesnt want to fight us. Asgore is depressed while undyen was determined

What evidence?

That was not her peak. Toriel was holding back massively against us and didn't want to fight against us proving my point

How cna you see her stats after sparing her? After you spare her the fight ends? What??

Papyrus stats are lower in genocide since he doesnt want to fight and spares us but his stats are stronger in the others since he actually fights.

Asgore is already depressed as ****

Never did.

Asgore holds back + being hard doesnt mean more skilled. By that logic sans is more skilled than undyne

Because...he is asgore? Its literally in the stroy that he is superior to undynes base by A LOT

Once again comparing a Depressed wanting to die man vs Undynes new buffed form filled with determination is not fair.
At this point your just stonewalling both me and Sans015. if this went through (which personally, i dont want it as a solid rating, at best a possibly) it'd have to effect Undyne and Mettaton. their mental states again, mean JACK. SHIT. Undyne is stronger than asgore, end of story.

if you want to bring up actually good points, and not just say 'no', your free to do so, otherwise im ignoring what you say next.
Can I see a scan of that? Undyne talks about how he fought asgore who was not even fighting back and got her ass handled.
79UfKmV.jpg
 
At this point your just stonewalling both me and Sans015. if this went through (which personally, i dont want it as a solid rating, at best a possibly) it'd have to effect Undyne and Mettaton. their mental states again, mean JACK. SHIT. Undyne is stronger than asgore, end of story.
What the heck so instead of debating and trying to win me over you say I am trolling tf?
if you want to bring up actually good points, and not just say 'no', your free to do so, otherwise im ignoring what you say next.
I- What the hell is happening I am arguing normally giving my own proof and idea on the topic chill the **** out?
"FINALLY" Proving she had to retry a lot of times to actually do it showing asgore is more skilled. What comes after this?
 
I already proved it since monsters become weaker when they are mentally bad or don't want to engage in a fight. Papyrus is a example his stats are worse than his other route versions because it spares us at the beginning since he doesnt want to fight us. Asgore is depressed while undyen was determined.

I already disproved the Papyrus evidence, thus this is irrelevant. Asgore is weaker, and you couldn't possibly prove his war version is stronger.

His mental state does not change the stats we see in the menu.

What evidence?
The entire text below the word "evidently", stop breaking my argument in pieces to pretend I didn't say anything.

That was not her peak. Toriel was holding back massively against us and didn't want to fight against us proving my point

How cna you see her stats after sparing her? After you spare her the fight ends? What??

Papyrus stats are lower in genocide since he doesnt want to fight and spares us but his stats are stronger in the others since he actually fights.

Asgore is already depressed as ****.

This doesn't respond to anything I said.

Yes, that was her peak. Her 80 DEF was her peak, even though she was using a much lesser amount of DEF, she was getting massively harmed by a 5 ATK hit, that is evidence that the 80 DEF we see in the menu is not her current defense, but rather her peak which she is not using. You can't explain this otherwise.

You can see her stats after convincing her to stop fighting. When she's giving the speech about letting you go, you can go over her stats and check to see they're still intact even though her mental state changed. This is evidence that Boss Monsters stats are not displayed based on mental state. (they do change, Frisk just can't check it)




Papyrus' stats are in fact, lower in the neutral route and pacifist routes as well. Before the fight actually begins, before the blue attack, his stats are lower.
Then when he fights for real, they get higher.

His mental states directly affected the displayed stats. This doesn't happen to boss monsters as seen with Toriel and Asgore.




By eating the pie, the game says his defense and attack power is dropped. Yet, if we check his stats again, they are unchanged.

Mind you, he does get weaker in actuality. What I think is happening here is that Frisk's ability to measure their opponent's power level is ineffective against boss monsters due to their soul being stronger, making them only see their opponent's absolute best even though they're weaker.

Never did.

Asgore holds back + being hard doesnt mean more skilled. By that logic sans is more skilled than undyne.
He is. Due to arsenal, but still, he is.

So you have to prove Asgore is superior in skill, then. Yes, being harder means Undyne is more skilled, it takes more skill to defeat her than it takes to defeat Asgore.
Because...he is asgore? Its literally in the stroy that he is superior to undynes base by A LOT.
That's appeal to authority.
Undyne the Undying is a transformation never seen before, she and Asgore never interacted, the fact Asgore is superior to base Undyne doesn't mean anything.
Prove he is stronger than her undying form.

It's like saying someone is stronger than Super Saiyan Goku because they're stronger than Base. No.
Once again comparing a Depressed wanting to die man vs Undynes new buffed form filled with determination is not fair.
It is. Because the stats displayed are not what he is using, it's his hypothetical peak.
 
What the heck so instead of debating and trying to win me over you say I am trolling tf?
Yes. you give no scans to your opinions, and you either repeat your point reworded differently, or just say 'no' to it. that isn't debating thats you just stonewalling arguments.
I- What the hell is happening I am arguing normally giving my own proof and idea on the topic chill the **** out?
Where is said proof then? because fun fact you never linked anything throughout this conversation.
"FINALLY" Proving she had to retry a lot of times to actually do it showing asgore is more skilled. What comes after this?
Yeah no, that means at the time Undyne finally reached to a comparable skill to asgore.

they were training. they were trying to make undyne more skilled, and asgore did his job well when undyne was finally able to outwit him.
 
I already disproved the Papyrus evidence, thus this is irrelevant. Asgore is weaker, and you couldn't possibly prove his war version is stronger.

His mental state does not change the stats we see in the menu.
I don't remember you disproving how he is weaker on genocide
The entire text below the word "evidently", stop breaking my argument in pieces to pretend I didn't say anything.
I am not doing that stop trying to accuse me of stuff.
This doesn't respond to anything I said.
It does tho-
Yes, that was her peak. Her 80 DEF was her peak, even though she was using a much lesser amount of DEF, she was getting massively harmed by a 5 ATK hit, that is evidence that the 80 DEF we see in the menu is not her current defense, but rather her peak which she is not using. You can't explain this otherwise.
That was not her peak she holds back massively remember what he did to asgore? If her stats were the same she wouldnt be able to destroy asgore like that
You can see her stats after convincing her to stop fighting. When she's giving the speech about letting you go, you can go over her stats and check to see they're still intact even though her mental state changed. This is evidence that Boss Monsters stats are not displayed based on mental state. (they do change, Frisk just can't check it)
Hmm Idk.
Papyrus' stats are in fact, lower in the neutral route and pacifist routes as well. Before the fight actually begins, before the blue attack, his stats are lower.
Then when he fights for real, they get higher.
Because he is getting more into the fight spirit??!
Mind you, he does get weaker in actuality. What I think is happening here is that Frisk's ability to measure their opponent's power level is ineffective against boss monsters due to their soul being stronger, making them only see their opponent's absolute best even though they're weaker.


He is. Due to arsenal, but still, he is.

So you have to prove Asgore is superior in skill, then. Yes, being harder means Undyne is more skilled, it takes more skill to defeat her than it takes to defeat Asgore.
Normal undyne got her ass kicked by non serious asgore who is not fighting back.
That's appeal to authority.
Undyne the Undying is a transformation never seen before, she and Asgore never interacted, the fact Asgore is superior to base Undyne doesn't mean anything.
Prove he is stronger than her undying form.

It's like saying someone is stronger than Super Saiyan Goku because they're stronger than Base. No.

It is. Because the stats displayed are not what he is using, it's his hypothetical peak.
I am not saying he is stronger than undying I am saying prime asgore is stronger than undying
Yes. you give no scans to your opinions, and you either repeat your point reworded differently, or just say 'no' to it. that isn't debating thats you just stonewalling arguments.
If you know the game you would know what I am talking about. Since you know the game I don't have to show scans of general undertale knowledge.
Where is said proof then? because fun fact you never linked anything throughout this conversation.
You 2 also only linked one thing which was undyne saying she "FINALLY" beat asgore after a lot of tries.
Yeah no, that means at the time Undyne finally reached to a comparable skill to asgore.

they were training. they were trying to make undyne more skilled, and asgore did his job well when undyne was finally able to outwit him.
Yeah no just because you beat your master once doesnt mean you are always more skilled then them. This is meaningless asgore has way better experience and skill feats anyway.


I am not contiuning this since I don't care about 8-B asgore just saying some of you gotta chill out like come on its just a discussion no need to be offended.
 
using any example from Monsterkind themselves aint reliable. barely any monsters in the war survived to see the end of it besides Asgore, and Gerson. (Both who fought in the frontlines)

everyone else wasn't actively fighting in it, and what they say is likely exaggerated due to their irrational fear of humans.

I agree it's not a perfect argument, but all the lore implies humans are massively stronger than monsters. It makes sense to think it might include Asgore.

But you have to see that, a somewhat unreliable support is better than no support at all, don't you think? What support we have for the hypothetical feat of Asgore fighting off humans?

And we have so much more variables, like providing support for the humans using their peak against monsters. The fact Human Strength varies based on their determination.

How can we say the humans, who are much stronger than monsters, needed to use their 8-B levels of power to defeat Asgore? We can't. That's why scaling to 8-B is nonsensical. (It also implies some other stuff I don't agree with like Lv 13 Chara/Geno Frisk being 8-B).

I vouch for Asgore to keep his "likely far higher" rating. Maybe "possibly drastically higher" if you'd want to argue that.
 
I don't remember you disproving how he is weaker on genocide.

Please pay attention. I said, "yes monsters do get weaker from their mental state, but boss monster stats are not displayed as weaker due to said mental state".

I never tried to disprove Geno Pap is weaker, I disproved his example applied to our current assessment.
That was not her peak she holds back massively remember what he did to asgore? If her stats were the same she wouldnt be able to destroy asgore like that.
Asgore was unharmed.
Also yes, 80 ATK vs 80 DEF is plausible.
Normal undyne got her ass kicked by non serious asgore who is not fighting back.
When she was a literal child, what is this point...?
I am not saying he is stronger than undying I am saying prime asgore is stronger than undying.
I see you're saying that.

Proving that is a different story altogether. Prime Asgore is not a real thing. You can't even measure how strong this supposed Prime Asgore would be, so how can you claim anything about him?
 
What Sams015 said.

You can't prove anything about this supposed 'Prime asgore', and would literally just be a bunch of guesswork for his stats.
 
Hello, I'm here and I want to get involved.

Pull all your arguments at once

Also sans, your arguments sometimes suck ass, for example the thing you said about Atk5 nuking DEF80 is justified by UT's mechanics as "Betrayal kill".

Also, Frisk is capable of varying their DT level as high as needed for defeating the enemy.
 
By everything I mean, everything at what you can think off. I'm ass lazy to stonewall both of you for 3 hours. It's not working tactic.

and please, stop acting like you guys are professional masterminds, most of you doesn't even know that redacteda is a horse
 
Hello, I'm here and I want to get involved.

Pull all your arguments at once.

Also sans, your arguments sometimes suck ass, for example the thing you said about Atk5 nuking DEF80 is justified by UT's mechanics as "Betrayal kill".
That's some great interpretation skills.

5 ATK harming a 80 DEF Toriel doesn't happen at the betrayal kill, it happens during the normal fight, Toriel takes much more damage than what she's supposed to. Also, my point is that the stats shown in the menu are not her actual stats in battle.
Also, Frisk is capable of varying their DT level as high as needed for defeating the enemy.
In a pacifist route that doesn't make any sense.

By everything I mean, everything at what you can think off. I'm ass lazy to stonewall both of you for 3 hours. It's not working tactic.

and please, stop acting like you guys are professional masterminds, most of you doesn't even know that redacteda is a horse
Stop being rude. 8-B Asgore is not plausible and if it were Undyne the Undying would scale, end of story.
 
That's some great interpretation skills.
Who's?
5 ATK harming a 80 DEF Toriel doesn't happen at the betrayal kill, it happens during the normal fight, Toriel takes much more damage than what she's supposed to. Also, my point is that the stats shown in the menu are not her actual stats in battle.
And? It was stated by game that it's not the stats but the SOUL harming the monsters, and more stronger SOUL is, more damage we can deal. Also Frisk is capable of adapting to damage and etc, which were especially shown in Undying fight and in Asriel's one.
In a pacifist route that doesn't make any sense.
Asriel moment
Stop being rude.
Just hate when people thinking that they know everything.
8-B Asgore is not plausible and if it were Undyne the Undying would scale, end of story.
End of the Undying story since 8-B Asgore is just a thing for his possible peak SOUL power which was never shown. Most of the arguments were placed just to say that he is far stronger than we get him in the game.

Undying SOUL is far, drastically weaker than Asgore's since she couldn't hold it even for a second. Asgore did it for 5 while Toriel for 4.

also if you didn't notice, OP says that it's arguing for a possible, not flat out or likely
 
Who's?

And? It was stated by-
That was never stated.
And it weights nothing to or against my final point.
Just hate when people thinking that they know everything.
Or rather you hate when people just argue for their point in eloquence. Stop being rude and be quiet.
End of the Undying story since 8-B Asgore is just a thing for his possible peak SOUL power which was never shown.
Which doesn't exist and has never been proven to even be a thing.
Undyne has higher stats so she scales. Too bad the scaling is cut and dry and we already scale Undyne to Asgore.
also if you didn't notice, OP says that it's arguing for a possible, not flat out or likely
Actually read my point, I disagreed with any ratings for 8-B.
 
"That was never stated"
Never stated? Eh? Did you read any of books in Snowdin's library?
Or rather you hate when people just argue for their point in eloquence. Stop being rude and be quiet.
Maybe the one who should be is you. But ya know, I don't care since you can build yourself all anything you want lmao.
Which doesn't exist and has never been proven to even be a thing.
Undyne has higher stats so she scales. Too bad the scaling is cut and dry and we already scale Undyne to Asgore.
Who doesn't exist? Who?
Dunno, maybe point of your argument.
As indeed, it's simply "Possible (insert 8-B or likely far higher) with true power".

You can't scale it to anyone besides Toriel at this point.
Undyne? Yeah, the Undyne surely would scale to base one.

But ultimately it was shown that mental state is capable of nuking Monster's stats, like Ice and Papyrus etc.
Actually read my point, I disagreed with any ratings for 8-B.
Your opinion.

But anyway, you really want to forget that those humans were capable of RESET which is Determination's peak ability and proof to the fact that they're indeed won't give up to some 9-A and just kick his ass like nothing he is.
 
It seems that I can't continue this thread. I'm sorry.

It was my worst decision to touch some Omori

I'm morally devastated after it and feeling high dismorality to anything, have a nice day
 
I'm mentally restored now.

So, let me explain what the **** will happen if guys start to scale to Asgore.

So, the 8-B tier itself gonna update like 5x times making humans like 5 times stronger
 
Back
Top