• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

World of Warcraft Discussion Thread: For suffering!

If that's an outlier then Broxigar's greatest achievement is also an outlier.
Here's the thing

Broxigar doesn't physically scale to the axe.

If you want to whine about Cenarius and Malfurion not scaling in power to a guy who is ******* Multiversal or Multiversal+ despite having NUMEROUS anti-feats so such a level of power, sure, fine.

Just don't whine about the axe that has 0 anti-feats that rips and tears through literally everything Broxigar attacks like a white-hot knife through butter scaling to that guy.
 
Here's the thing

Broxigar doesn't physically scale to the axe.

If you want to whine about Cenarius and Malfurion not scaling in power to a guy who is ******* Multiversal or Multiversal+ despite having NUMEROUS anti-feats so such a level of power, sure, fine.

Just don't whine about the axe that has 0 anti-feats that rips and tears through literally everything Broxigar attacks like a white-hot knife through butter scaling to that guy.
If we are going to pull off Tuska the Daemon Killa. It's either the axe and the former 2 creators are outliers or the creators scale to their creations. It's either to accept or reject. We can't do both.
 
God dang.
Also one of the worst things is they pushed a sylvanas redemption act after all the crap she did in BFA. but push that arthus is a monster and part way through the last raid we get to see sylvanas monologuing about how he should just be forgotten to the last of arthus' soul that was fading away after it was freed from the blade it was sealed in.
Edit: And when your soul fades away in the shadowlands you are perma dead.
 
Also one of the worst things is they pushed a sylvanas redemption act after all the crap she did in BFA. but push that arthus is a monster and part way through the last raid we get to see sylvanas monologuing about how he should just be forgotten to the last of arthus' soul that was fading away after it was freed from the blade it was sealed in.
The chubbiest middle finger given to Lick King expansion ever.
 
If we are going to pull off Tuska the Daemon Killa. It's either the axe and the former 2 creators are outliers or the creators scale to their creations. It's either to accept or reject. We can't do both.
That's just the thing. One end has anti-feats, the other doesn't.

You don't have to scale to your creations you know, especially in this case where a 2-B/2-A power source was tapped into to make the damn thing.
 
That's just the thing. One end has anti-feats, the other doesn't.

You don't have to scale to your creations you know, especially in this case where a 2-B/2-A power source was tapped into to make the damn thing.
Then let them have that tier by drawing power from another source then since it doesn't scale to their own magic or physicals.

For the most part isn't Illidan like in charge of keeping Sargares at bay in the titan forge or something?
 
So...what happened?
Well it turns out she has a sister in the shadowlands who called out for help since there was a drought since they stopped getting souls. Well Elune did not bother to look into what was going on (We see that other cosmic forces could enter the shadowlands in that explanation) before she blocked the night elves that died in the genocide that was at the start of BFA from becoming Wisps. She than proceed to send the souls the normal way which dumped all of them into the Maw aka the home jailor and the realm of eternals torment and soul destruction, it turns out she had no ******* clue that she did this and was not even aware what the hell was even going on and did not even bother to see if the souls even made it to her sister's realm.
 
Well it turns out she has a sister in the shadowlands who called out for help since there was a drought since they stopped getting souls. Well Elune did not bother to look into what was going on (We see that other cosmic forces could enter the shadowlands in that explanation) before she blocked the night elves that died in the genocide that was at the start of BFA from becoming Wisps. She than proceed to send the souls the normal way which dumped all of them into the Maw aka the home jailor and the realm of eternals torment and soul destruction, it turns out she had no ******* clue that she did this and was not even aware what the hell was even going on and did not even bother to see if the souls even made it to her sister's realm.
Oh great
 
His literal first introduction into the warcraft lore is being captured by centaur...what the ****
Yeah he has a history of being a damsel in distress

Except the Damsel in distress in this case is a 10 foot tall 800 pound cow man who is capable of AP stomping a lot of the other folks in his position.
 
Yeah he has a history of being a damsel in distress

Except the Damsel in distress in this case is a 10 foot tall 800 pound cow man who is capable of AP stomping a lot of the other folks in his position.
It's either he has really bad luck or he is a bit of a *********.

But anyways, is Rexxar just gonna be 7-A or is he a lot higher?
 
Once I can make rexxar, yes he's most likely going to be 7-A, and pretty high into it at that
Considering the fact he single handedly slaughtered an entire army of naga, killed off entire armies of proudmore's troops, destroyed his fortress in Kalimdor and completely massacred his forces and proudmore himself in his own city in Theramore Isle whilst being compared to Grom by Thrall himself. Yeah, very far up the 7-A scaling chain.
 
Considering the fact he single handedly slaughtered an entire army of naga, killed off entire armies of proudmore's troops, destroyed his fortress in Kalimdor and completely massacred his forces and proudmore himself in his own city in Theramore Isle whilst being compared to Grom by Thrall himself. Yeah, very far up the 7-A scaling chain.
Yeh

TBH I have been wanting to make Maiev for awhile, I might insult her repeatedly but I can't deny that I actually do like her character lol
 
No, because he beaten Mannoroth, post purification.
Mannoroth is just a nickname, his actual name is Jobber because holy shit, he Jobs hard.

Grommash one-shotting him is an actual anti-feat to Mannoroth being 6-A anyway, seeing as Grom required an amp to even touch Cenarius
 
Mannoroth is just a nickname, his actual name is Jobber because holy shit, he Jobs hard.

Grommash one-shotting him is an actual anti-feat to Mannoroth being 6-A anyway, seeing as Grom required an amp to even touch Cenarius
Isn't the jobber comparable to other pit lords like Magtheridon? Aside from that, he's Tichondrius' superior.
 
Isn't the jobber comparable to other pit lords like Magtheridon? Aside from that, he's Tichondrius' superior.
Magtheridon at least has feats to back up his position.

And being of a higher rank doesn't automatically make you stronger, if it did, folks like Tyrande and Varian would be rock-solid 5-B
 
Magtheridon at least has feats to back up his position.
The point is, anything Magtheridon did, Mannoroth would have upscaled by virtue of being one of Archimonde's lieutenants compared to some random pit lord that might possibly be weaker than Mannoroth's former lieutenant Azgalor.
And being of a higher rank doesn't automatically make you stronger, if it did, folks like Tyrande and Varian would be rock-solid 5-B
You're making wrong comparisons. For one, the lore states that Archimonde himself. Chose Mannoroth to be his lieutenant amongst many other pit lords that was present while Magtheridon is merely a lord of shattered planet...big difference there bud. He is also remarked to have immense magic proficiency surpassing pre skull of Guldan illidan and only barring Azhara.
 
The point is, anything Magtheridon did, Mannoroth would have upscaled by virtue of being one of Archimonde's lieutenants compared to some lord that rules something as miniscule as a shattered planet.

You're making wrong comparisons. For one, the lore states that Archimonde himself. Chose Mannoroth to be his lieutenant amongst many other pit lords that was present while Magtheridon is merely a lord of shattered planet...big difference there bud. He is also remarked to have immense magic proficiency surpassing pre skull of Guldan illidan and only barring Azhara.
Except one has feats against meaningful characters and the other got his ass handed to him twice by the same guy just in Alternate timelines.

Which doesn't matter because Mannoroth gets 2 anti-feats to 6-A, wanna scale him to at most 5-B now too? Alternate Gul'dan was afraid of him!

But wait, Mannoroth got one-shot by a guy Gul'dan overpowered with his magic, WHOOPS!

Mannoroth is probably the biggest feat of Feats>Statements victim we have, the lore talks mad shit about his capabilities, but the he falls under the power-scaling lens and he's got all of 2 major feats.

Fought Cenarius in the War of the Ancients

Indirectly One-shot WC3 Thrall.

And the former has the issue of Mannoroth getting one-shot by a guy who couldn't fight Cenarius... TWICE.

As for Illidan and Xavius, they're 7-A with magic cause they don't got shit for feats with it
 
Except one has feats against meaningful characters and the other got his ass handed to him twice by the same guy just in Alternate timelines.

Which doesn't matter because Mannoroth gets 2 anti-feats to 6-A, wanna scale him to at most 5-B now too? Alternate Gul'dan was afraid of him!
He got 2? Maiev got far more than 2 and she couldn't take down characters far below her own weight class not to mention the dumpster fire that is getting herself pinned down on a single base in the broken isles requiring Malfurion's aid to break even.
But wait, Mannoroth got one-shot by a guy Gul'dan overpowered with his magic, WHOOPS!
Should probably just attribute the thing to Gorehowl. He after all, dies after tanking Mannoroth's death explosion back in the main timeline. which if he is physically strong enough to oneshot Mannoroth, he shouldn't have given a damn about the explosion.
Mannoroth is probably the biggest feat of Feats>Statements victim we have, the lore talks mad shit about his capabilities, but the he falls under the power-scaling lens and he's got all of 2 major feats.
Fair
Fought Cenarius in the War of the Ancients

Indirectly One-shot WC3 Thrall.
How does Cenarius' feats take him?
And the former has the issue of Mannoroth getting one-shot by a guy who couldn't fight Cenarius... TWICE.
Fair point.
As for Illidan and Xavius, they're 7-A with magic cause they don't got shit for feats with it
The point is, he is somewhat on Azhara's level albeit being inferior.
 
He got 2? Maiev got far more than 2 and she couldn't take down characters far below her own weight class not to mention the dumpster fire that is getting herself pinned down on a single base in the broken isles requiring Malfurion's aid to break even.

Should probably just attribute the thing to Gorehowl. He after all, dies after tanking Mannoroth's death explosion back in the main timeline. which if he is physically strong enough to oneshot Mannoroth, he shouldn't have given a damn about the explosion.

Fair

How does Cenarius' feats take him?

Fair point.

The point is, he is somewhat on Azhara's level albeit being inferior.
Thing is she's also got more feats then she does Anti-feats, unlike Mannoroth.

Or perhaps Mannoroth's death blast is far above his own AP?

They were pretty matched unironically, it's just unfortunate he's got 2 anti-feats to invalidate that otherwise rock-solid 6-A scaling.

Slightly Inferior to a bitch that has 5-B flat magic. Uhuh. Yeah. I don't think you realize what Azshara's scaling is with magic. She's nuts.
 
Let's just take a look at how how inferior Maiev is:
1. Unable to fight entire armies of fodder enemies while those that are below her in the scaling chain are able to single handedly achieve such a feat most prominently Rexxar, Grom.

2. Every encounter she had with Illidan is always with her herd of watchers. Never had she actually fought Illidan one on one without outside help like Arthas. The time Illidan was actually killed still required Akama's help

3. She had lost to people who aren't even comparable to the eredar brothers. She couldn't defeat a certain someone who got toyed with by Archimonde till heck and back yet Maiev couldn't defeat him whilst he held back against her.
Thing is she's also got more feats then she does Anti-feats, unlike Mannoroth.

Or perhaps Mannoroth's death blast is far above his own AP?
You're gonna need proof about the death blast.
They were pretty matched unironically, it's just unfortunate he's got 2 anti-feats to invalidate that otherwise rock-solid 6-A scaling.
Just what does exactly Magtheridon scale to first of all?
Slightly Inferior to a bitch that has 5-B flat magic. Uhuh. Yeah. I don't think you realize what Azshara's scaling is with magic. She's nuts.
Certainly not on the Eredar brother's level or medivh nor Aegwyn.
 
Let's just take a look at how how inferior Maiev is:
1. Unable to fight entire armies of fodder enemies while those that are below her in the scaling chain are able to single handedly achieve such a feat most prominently Rexxar, Grom.

2. Every encounter she had with Illidan is always with her herd of watchers. Never had she actually fought Illidan one on one without outside help like Arthas. The time Illidan was actually killed still required Akama's help

3. She had lost to people who aren't even comparable to the eredar brothers. She couldn't defeat a certain someone who got toyed with by Archimonde till heck and back yet Maiev couldn't defeat him whilst he held back against her.

You're gonna need proof about the death blast.

Just what does exactly Magtheridon scale to first of all?

Certainly not on the Eredar brother's level or medivh nor Aegwyn.
1. Indeed, the same could be said for Illidan.

2.Hence why her scaling to 5-B is AT MOST. it is not solid. Akama if his profile is ever made would ALSO be at most.

3. Yes, a certain someone who was literally using a large amount of power granted by Kil'jaeden who literally had to get reinforcements because Maiev and Khadgar would have won otherwise. I don't know who your talking about if not Alternate Gul'dan.

It killed the guy that one-shot him. Oh and also saying it was Gorehowl that provided that kind of AP requires an extra assumption so by Occam's razor my argument is more solid

Actually, yes, it straight up is. Mannoroth was actually scared of her and said that only Archimonde and his lord would prove superior. Spoiler alert, they aren't the only 5-Bs in the Legion.

ALSO, 5-B doesn't come from either Kil'jaeden or Archimonde, it comes from Illidan.
 
3. Yes, a certain someone who was literally using a large amount of power granted by Kil'jaeden who literally had to get reinforcements because Maiev and Khadgar would have won otherwise. I don't know who your talking about if not Alternate Gul'dan.
Wrong person, I was referring to Jarod.
It killed the guy that one-shot him. Oh and also saying it was Gorehowl that provided that kind of AP requires an extra assumption so by Occam's razor my argument is more solid
This is the exact same situation as Broxigar. They both have weapons that allowed them to dish out damage above their standard weight class. You even said it shouldn't even scale to their physicals if that's the case hence you reinforced my argument that Grom's physicals are not equal to the damage he dishes out with Gorehowl. Infact, his axe is far more durable than his own body. Same exact thing with Axe of Cenarius hence forth.
Actually, yes, it straight up is. Mannoroth was actually scared of her and said that only Archimonde and his lord would prove superior. Spoiler alert, they aren't the only 5-Bs in the Legion.
My estimations were a lot lower. Considering the fact that she recently loss to the combined efforts of Lor'themor Theron and Jain Proudmoore and got her slithering arse dragged in the abyss. Are we absolutely sure that she is that OP or are pit lords just really fodder and should be scrapped along into F tier?
ALSO, 5-B doesn't come from either Kil'jaeden or Archimonde, it comes from Illidan.
Yes, the same guy that is afraid of Kil'jaeden in Warcraft 3. I know he blew a planet up.
 
Wrong person, I was referring to Jarod.

This is the exact same situation as Broxigar. They both have weapons that allowed them to dish out damage above their standard weight class. You even said it shouldn't even scale to their physicals if that's the case hence you reinforced my argument that Grom's physicals are not equal to the damage he dishes out with Gorehowl. Infact, his axe is far more durable than his own body. Same exact thing with Axe of Cenarius hence forth.

My estimations were a lot lower. Considering the fact that she recently loss to the combined efforts of Lor'themor Theron and Jain Proudmoore and got her slithering arse dragged in the abyss. Are we absolutely sure that she is that OP or are pit lords just really fodder and should be scrapped along into F tier?

Yes, the same guy that is afraid of Kil'jaeden in Warcraft 3. I know he blew a planet up.
Two word Not. Canon. there are SEVEN inconsistencies with what Maiev pulled in Wolfheart, so for the same reason she has no scaling to Malfurion on her page despite nearly killing him, Jarod can't scale to her for beating her in Wolfheart

Actually, Grommash tanked the hit that one-shot Thrall, so no, it's not dealing with opponents out of his weight class. Sorry to burst your happy little bubble.

If I'm not wrong, kind of like Battle for Dazar'alor, they kind of just ******* stood around doing jack shit for the fight.

And the same guy that boxed Kil'jaeden in Legion
 
Last edited:
Two word Not. Canon. there are SEVEN inconsistencies with what Maiev pulled in Wolfheart, so for the same reason she has no scaling to Malfurion on her page despite nearly killing him, Jarod can't scale to her for beating her in Wolfheart
What is wolfheart? And Amy other things that aren't canon?
Actually, Grommash tanked the hit that one-shot Thrall, so no, it's not dealing with opponents out of his weight class. Sorry to burst your happy little bubble.
Oneshot as in knocking out? No, Thrall was merely knocked out, he didn't receive any grievous wounds or broken bones. As for grom tanking the hit and not getting knocked out, that is attributed to his notorious iron will and the fact he doesn't get skewered like Kratos. Had he simply one punched Mannoroth to his death I would not be correcting you.
If I'm not wrong, kind of like Battle for Dazar'alor, they kind of just ******* stood around doing jack shit for the fight.
Damn, just put them on 7-A.
And the same guy that boxed Kil'jaeden in Legion
Should make a key for post-resurrection Illidan.
 
What is wolfheart? And Amy other things that aren't canon?

Oneshot as in knocking out? No, Thrall was merely knocked out, he didn't receive any grievous wounds or broken bones. As for grom tanking the hit and not getting knocked out, that is attributed to his notorious iron will and the fact he doesn't get skewered like Kratos. Had he simply one punched Mannoroth to his death I would not be correcting you.

Damn, just put them on 7-A.

Should make a key for post-resurrection Illidan.
Jarod vs Maiev happens in the novel Wolfheart, for all intents and purposes, anything specifically involving Worgen or Varian(usually both) is canon. Anything involving High Elves, Jarod, or Maiev, generates too many inconsistencies and is straight up contradicted. To let you know what Maiev did, she killed numerous High Elf mages, nearly killed Malfurion, and got beaten by Jarod and left. Tyrande relieved her of duty then and put Jarod in her place... and the literal next time we see Maiev in Legion she is repeatedly stated in every media, including in-game to be the leader of the Watchers, she's even pretty much stated to be so in Warlords of Draenor too. And

Getting knocked out in one hit does count as getting one-shot yes. And saying that Grom didn't get one-shot by an attack that one-shot Thrall because of willpower... is NOT in the description of his willpower nor is that ever attributed to his willpower, because getting knocked out is biological, not mental. You're grasping at straws at this point, becuase by your logic, the weapons are doing the work, so Cairne is 6-A, random ass dragons are 6-A, Varian and Shalamanye are 6-A... get ready. WotLK Thrall is 6-A(Same key as WC3) and hold on a minute, this shit just got circular!

Wanna know why? Garrosh used Gorehowl against Taran Zhu. Who has scaling to 6-As. Gorehowl is now 6-A.

If I ever make Lor'themar he'd be 7-A Anyway, Jaina unironically has Tier 6 magic without a shadow of a doubt.

shrug
 
Jarod vs Maiev happens in the novel Wolfheart, for all intents and purposes, anything specifically involving Worgen or Varian(usually both) is canon. Anything involving High Elves, Jarod, or Maiev, generates too many inconsistencies and is straight up contradicted. To let you know what Maiev did, she killed numerous High Elf mages, nearly killed Malfurion, and got beaten by Jarod and left. Tyrande relieved her of duty then and put Jarod in her place... and the literal next time we see Maiev in Legion she is repeatedly stated in every media, including in-game to be the leader of the Watchers, she's even pretty much stated to be so in Warlords of Draenor too.
That did not mean it isn't canon unless it is stated as such.
Getting knocked out in one hit does count as getting one-shot yes. And saying that Grom didn't get one-shot by an attack that one-shot Thrall because of willpower... is NOT in the description of his willpower nor is that ever attributed to his willpower, because getting knocked out is biological, not mental. You're grasping at straws at this point, becuase by your logic, the weapons are doing the work, so Cairne is 6-A, random ass dragons are 6-A, Varian and Shalamanye are 6-A... get ready. WotLK Thrall is 6-A(Same key as WC3) and hold on a minute, this shit just got circular!
To level with you, if Cairne never had his runespear shattered he would've killed Garrosh there and now. Also you do realize that Gorehowl is the only thing that survived Thrall's lightning strike whereas Garrosh is vaporized. I would also like to point out that in WoW. Equipping weapon and items actually boost their physical stats which means they hit much harder than they should or if they cast magic spells that boost their physicals equal to their weapons like Illidan, so what you're saying is absolutely correct except the dragons that aren't dragon aspects or whatever is shalamanye...never head of em.
Wanna know why? Garrosh used Gorehowl against Taran Zhu. Who has scaling to 6-As. Gorehowl is now 6-A.
Then just give Grom 6-A via scaling to that! Why did we even discuss the above if there was already that!
If I ever make Lor'themar he'd be 7-A Anyway, Jaina unironically has Tier 6 magic without a shadow of a doubt.
He'd be comparable to Jaina if they survived their encounter with Azhara
Just do it!
 
That did not mean it isn't canon unless it is stated as such.

To level with you, if Cairne never had his runespear shattered he would've killed Garrosh there and now. Also you do realize that Gorehowl is the only thing that survived Thrall's lightning strike whereas Garrosh is vaporized. I would also like to point out that in WoW. Equipping weapon and items actually boost their physical stats which means they hit much harder than they should or if they cast magic spells that boost their physicals equal to their weapons like Illidan, so what you're saying is absolutely correct except the dragons that aren't dragon aspects or whatever is shalamanye...never head of em.

Then just give Grom 6-A via scaling to that! Why did we even discuss the above if there was already that!

He'd be comparable to Jaina if they survived their encounter with Azhara

Just do it!
Ever hear if something being retconned? You think Maiev behind the scenes stayed leader of the Wardens even though she was stated to not be that anymore? No, Maiev's activities in Wolfheart are pretty much entirely retconned as they're never mentioned again and what happened with her is directly contradicted. As such, not canon. Not usable.



Garrosh was totally holding Gorehowl when the lightning struck him

Garroshs_corpse.png

This corpse looks very vaporized.

Shalamayne is Varian's sword. That directly clashed with Gorehowl. Varian used this sword on Thrall and Thrall tanked it decently well.

I just told you that it generates circular scaling mate. I'm not scaling Thrall to someone who one-shot something that one-shot him.

And now you're using ******* game mechanics to back up your point... sigh

I'm scaling like this for the EXPRESS purpose of avoiding the circular scaling possibilities, and I'm not going to let you muck that up just because you want Grommash to be 6-A solid, and believe me, I could connect the dots with how much circular scaling happens if you make Gorehowl 6-A. Or even higher into 7-A.

Thrall=Shalamanye=Gorehowl>Thrall. Want this scanned and referenced or are you gonna take my word for it this time?

Does Genn scale to Rastakhan and Bwonsamdi because he was present for that fight? He didn't even throw so much as a cloud of dust in that fight, now apply this to the Azshara fight.

I'm gonna be blunt with you, I don't care enough to do so right now.
 
Back
Top