Upgrading Q to 1-A?

[Yukaphile]

Should Q and by extension the Q Continuum be upgraded to 1-A? Know it's weird to have me arguing in favor of a Trek upgrade given the huge argument me and Idazmi had a few months ago, lol, but imo, I do see a lot of similar Lovecraftian elements in the Q too, and they're all rated at 1-A mostly, such as how Q blatantly tells the Enterprise crew that the Q transcend the laws of physics. I mean, what was the reasoning for Q being 1-B?

 

[ZacharyGrossman273]

"Transcend the laws of physics"

Ummm... This isn't 1-A. Any 4-D being would be beyond 3-D laws of physics

 

[Crzer07]

Well they were responsible for the Nexus a realm beyond the concept of time and space, something that was further expanded on and explained in the apocrypha, and the reasoning for High 1-B didn't quite come to a conclusion.

 

[Yukaphile]

Isn't that canon-canon? Then again, VS Wiki allows stuff from the EU, so... eh?

 

[HammerStrikes219]

https://vsbattles.com/vsbattles/1935178


Yeah High 1B seems to be rejected in the thread I linked.

Not sure about the apocrypha given how there's no links to that for the quotes.

 

[HammerStrikes219]

Well they were responsible for the Nexus a realm beyond the concept of time and space, something that was further expanded on and explained in the apocrypha, and the reasoning for High 1-B didn't quite come to a conclusion.

Beyond time and space doesn't translate to being 1A though.