- 24,974
- 26,821
It still never ended up in the film tho. It's like saying prowl should have the same feats as barricade because he was intended to appear
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I've said this before, like 5 times lol, but BB Movie prequel was written to fit the TLK timeline, not the BB movie. BB movie changed its story before release.It still never ended up in the film tho. It's like saying prowl should have the same feats as barricade because he was intended to appear
Like what? BB movie prequel comic doesn't include all the comics as canon, but the ones that don't condradict the TLK timeline.Given how little the movies regard the tie-in comics, they should be treated as separate and given new keys. Also, there are still huge timeline contradictions between the films and comic books, in addition to characters that seemingly don't exist.
@Emirp Here's the sources for Aligned.
I've already suggested before and in the blog? Did nobody read that?Seperate keys can be made, but IMO, they aren't necessarily a different continuity.
It is a seperate continuity from the Bumblebee movie. BB Movie Prequel is a Bayverse (not Knightverse) comic that is meant to fit the TLK timeline. It just narrates what BB was doing in the 60s.Still, my point stands, it ended becoming a seperate continuity, the recent new confirms that bumblebee is indeed a soft reboot. Whether it was previously intended or whether they similarities.
The idw comics have been classified by ask vector prime as seperate from the movies
He straight up say they're in a different universe. We're they once canon? Yes. But now they're not because they've been contradicted now, meaning the stream split, and they're now non canon.So, clearly, AVP doesn't necessarily say that the comics are non-canon.
It is a seperate continuity from the Bumblebee movie. BB Movie Prequel is a Bayverse (not Knightverse) comic that is meant to fit the TLK timeline. It just narrates what BB was doing in the 60s.
I've already stated that the 2007 Movie Prequel is non-canon.You missed the edit. Bumblebee very explicitly doesn't show up on Earth until 2003 in the IDW and Titan comics, as well as the novels, yet the prequel is based in the Cold War and he arrived in WWII. There's your contradiction.
Honestly, the movies can't even keep up with their own timeline, let alone the comics.
Edit: Wait, Bumblebee was on Earth in WWII according to TLK, so that actually makes even more contradictions between the earlier comics and films.
He doesn't straight up say that at all tho. He literally says that the live-action movies are canon to the comics, but not NECESSARILY the other way around. That means he doesn't give a straight answer. All that means is that the movie comics are a different stream, but nothing says their events didn't happen in the movieverse. Also, AVP and FunPub tries not to change the main canons too much.He straight up say they're in a different universe. We're they once canon? Yes. But now they're not because they've been contradicted now, meaning the stream split, and they're now non canon.
It's implied bumblebee lost his voice before he got to earth
I didn't say the movie is non-canon. I said the 2007 Movie Prequel is non-canon.This doesn't just make the film non-canon, though, it makes most of the comic continuity irrelevant because it's included in different books and the Titan comics. These contradictions also don't even scratch the surface.
What I mean to say is that the BB Movie Prequel is not condradicted by the timeline established by TLK. And it references the miniseries like Sector 7 and Rising Storm. For example:Ok, what exactly are you trying to argue here, I don't really see what your point is or what exactly you're getting at. What are proposals and suggestions for the profiles and we should treat everything?
Ok (though I don't think the BB movie prequel and some of the comics are condradictory). I do think it should be keys instead of seperate profiles, as secondary canon is still information and stories approved by Hasbro and is meant to fit the Bayverse (the books and comics go through full Hasbro approval).I thought we all agreed with that ages ago? What I'm saying we should purely use feats for the movies that are from the movies instead of relying on contradictory extra source materials that contradict the movies and one another. I was never against secondary keys and I even mentioned we should have it way earlier.
"Q: Can you tell me about the aligned continuity? Are Transformers Prime and War for Cybertron in the same universe? There seem to be differences.Here's the sources for Aligned.
Maybe there can be secondary keys to them as well. I think they are semi-canon.They have similar events and the war plays out similarly, yes. But there a lot of other things that prevent them from being the same continuity.
A lot.So what did I miss?
no longer using weights from vehicles for re-entry, using guide weights and a lot more things.Like?
No idea for tiers, but the characters (in the first movie) should something be like:So what's the scaling chain for the Bayverse looking like?
When was that statement made? He sliced Brawl’s arm off, I don’t think he knocked him out though. And Brawl did no-sell some of Ratchet’s shots iirc.It is said that Ratchet is one of the only few bots who could actually give Megatron a fight before he is killed, so I feel he should be way higher on the list, also he knocked out Brawl IIRC
Also, Blackout was going to sneak attack Optimus, so I doubt he was confident
Huh, interesting. I guess Ratchet > Brawl. Although idk if he should be above Bee, since he squared up with Optimus and iirc, he could briefly fight Megatron in TLK.It was made in the movie guide, which I guess we are using it? He headshots Brawl and he is knocked out
Fair enough, but Grindor didn't really did much against Optimus, in the extended cut, he tried to cut Optimus with his saw thing, but that is it, though I guess an argument could be made by that
Yes, which makes a lot of the Titian and IDW line non-canon, as they're base off information in these comics.I didn't say the movie is non-canon. I said the 2007 Movie Prequel is non-canon.
I've already told you that the some of the comic continuity has been retconned away, but a good portion of it is still intact according to BB Movie prequel comic.
What condradictions are you talking about exactly?
There's already tons of differences, and as far as we know the WFC games never became the Prime series. There are macroscopic similarities, as they said, like both continuities being poisoned by Dark Energon. But, Orion Pax attained the Matrix from Primus after an attempt to save Cybertron from being poisoned, leading him to be reformatted as Optimus Prime well into the war. War For Cybertron was already called Optimus and became a Prime when Zeta died, and just takes the Matrix under similar circumstances without being reformatted."Q: Can you tell me about the aligned continuity? Are Transformers Prime and War for Cybertron in the same universe? There seem to be differences.
A: That's a bit of an animal to define. You are correct in observing differences betwixt Uniend 812.21 Kappa and Uniend 911.05 Alpha. However, these differences tend towards the cosmetic. Macroscopic events of the Uniend Cluster have a uniform cosmology and history, removed from much of the rest of the multiverse."
According to this, the two streams have a largely uniform history. So, the feats might be interchangeable.
I don’t really mind Starscream being above Blackout, although I think comparable would make more sense, especially if we scale Blackout to Grindor. He and Starscream did about the same amount of damage to Optimus during the forest battle.OP and Megs I don't need to explain, but I put Starscream above Blackout via he having feats against other characters
But Bee killed Brawl, and could fight Optimus and Megs in TLK.Ironhide is > Bumblebee cause he actually tanked Starscream's missiles
Bee should be slightly above, but from the little bit of the fight we saw, Barricade could still fight pretty evenly with him. And in TLK, he survived attacks from Grimlock and Bee.Bumblebee may be above Barricade since in the aftermath Bumblebee was not really injured, while Barricade was quite destroyed