Noneless21
He/Him- 7,508
- 5,168
Shiro's a plot based AE type 1, so nobody's interacting with her without plot manipulation
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Top 10 Strongest Non-Smurfs for every tier continued
- Thread starter Setsuna_tenma
- Start date
-
- Tags
- lists
- Status
- 1,566
- 400
huh so she will have in con with 3 verse in 1-A list ? cuz i don't any of them have plot manip
Noneless21
He/Him- 7,508
- 5,168
well she ain't beating them either since she's just baseline 1-A, plus who knows there's another caveat in the profiles like verse specific powers
- 7,142
- 4,658
That's not really a thing, the Wiki's system doesn't treat plot related Abstract Existence as harder to interact with then normal Abstract Existence. Unless the series in question has other abstract beings to compare Abstract Existence to, normal Non-Physical Interaction on abstractions should work.
Noneless21
He/Him- 7,508
- 5,168
it's based off this thread
- 7,142
- 4,658
I read the staff responses, and that isn't really them explaining a standard, that was giving a opinion. Nor did all the staff agree which each other or a conclusion made in the thread.
Currently the standard is not to treat narrative abstractions as superior to other such abstractions, not unless the series in question specifically gives it's own answer to the question.
Currently the standard is not to treat narrative abstractions as superior to other such abstractions, not unless the series in question specifically gives it's own answer to the question.
Noneless21
He/Him- 7,508
- 5,168
It was never stated to be superior, but it was never stated to be the same, and you still need the right hax to interact with said abstraction without the right NPI in the first place...
- 2,379
- 763
Pretty sure we don't assume that just because you can interact with one abstraction that you can do so for others as well. For example just because you can interact with ae type 1 of concept doesn't mean you can interact with ae type 1 of possibilities. But even if we go by that, plot > type 1 concepts in verse
- 7,142
- 4,658
We generally do, if you can punch information you can punch concepts, if you can punch emotions you can punch possibilities.
Their's a reason when people ask if their Non-Physical Interaction can affect Abstract Existence Type 1 they generally don't also ask what type of Abstract it works on. If you can interact with an abstraction then you can interact with any abstraction, baring scaling chains of how abstract something is and such.
Oliver_de_jesus
He/Him- 24,745
- 17,775
Yes but no, possibly Plot Manipulation (Tzeentchs sheer ability to manipulate fate and probability is described as him being akin to an 'author' of a story[8]) and Chaos god resist
Either way, the Marvel characters can control and destroy the plot.
- 7,142
- 4,658
Something no one pays attention to. I've seen enough debates about Abstract Existence Type 1, some involving Staff, that just don't pay attention to that factor and treat Non-Physical Interaction on a abstraction as Non-Physical Interaction on any abstraction.
Noneless21
He/Him- 7,508
- 5,168
That's just like if you can interact with elemental intangible being means you can interact with incorporeal being, which is not true, some abstraction is different than the others, some embody the universe, some embody concept, some embody information, all of these are fundamental aspect but they're essentially differs
- 7,142
- 4,658
Generally the standard seen in threads is something like Elemental>Spiritual>Abstract, like how Mid-Godly Regeneration Negation makes no distinction between what the character in question is regenerating from.
Noneless21
He/Him- 7,508
- 5,168
Really? So you mean if someone's capable of punching an abstract being, they then can punch ghost?
Btw, abstract existence can differ very much so, some can embody death, some can embody time, some can embody space and so on...
- 7,142
- 4,658
Yep, you got Non-Physical Interaction on concepts you can punch Casper all day long.
All of that is just classified as a type of conceptual Abstract Existence. You can punch Death from Castlevania then you can punch Dialga's true form.
Rikimarox2
He/Him- 7,971
- 4,509
...What? What kind of logic is that, wtf???
If that's how we do things, then we're really going into the gutter. How does it make sense that if I can punch emotions, that somehow grants me the ability to affect shit like possibilities? It's like such a gross generalization, that if you can effect A, then **** it, you can effect any other one.
Not to mention, I haven't seen this shit discussed anywhere at all, most of them seem to think that if you can effect A, that doesn't mean you can effect B unless a huge amount of context is given. You're literally the first one who mentions we do stuff like this.
- 19,186
- 6,471
Yea first I have ever seen this, the general consensus has been affecting one type of abstract ie emotions, won't let you affect the other ie information.
- 1,566
- 400
bruh moment,well it seem shallow can't get any place in here
- 19,186
- 6,471
Featherlite baseline? If so might be a cool match.
- 657
- 259
Faa doesn't have hax or resistances on the level of her existence (1A) so Epilogue is still an ez GG. The only thing saving her here is acausality type 5 (which I'm pretty sure has been outdated, and wouldn't qualified for the current standard anyway).
- 18,628
- 18,684
Pretty much this. Affecting one form of abstraction doesn't mean you can affect another type at all, unless there's in verse context that implies as such.
- 2,083
- 1,143
Void Entity link is broken, you should change it to this
- 1,885
- 982
Oliver_de_jesus
He/Him- 24,745
- 17,775
He has smurf range
- 5,090
- 2,917
And smurf hax too + resistances
Oliver_de_jesus
He/Him- 24,745
- 17,775
i think 2 or 3
- 4,882
- 2,518
Make just 1 vs 1...not the entire top list.
- 399
- 110
So i need to make each battle separeted ?
Ok i will start with graham
I will edit it
- 399
- 110
We need to do the matches so that people understand why the list is changed
And madoka can interact with sasha
- 399
- 110
First battle graham vs madoka
- 11,353
- 19,874
Hey, if Anos stomps madoka. Madoka can't interact with Graham and Graham has haxes comparable to Anos so it's a Stomp, Eques has haxes comparable to Anos and Graham too and Madoka can't interact with Eques either, and Arcana the same but stronger than Eques, what's the point of spamming match knowing the outcome beforehand?
- 399
- 110
So
Change the Ranking list directly ?
- Status
