- 663
- 551
- Thread starter
- #41
But here is the thing... The fan translation isn't correct either as it was discussed in the last thread. So...
.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
But here is the thing... The fan translation isn't correct either as it was discussed in the last thread. So...
.
You have a much simpler option here man... Just find a single sentence anywhere in the entire series where another character states that they felt a shaking indeed, so we know this case is not basic use of the literature as one expects, but rather a literal, factual statement.I don't think so. ¯\(ツ)/¯
Again. Yen Press translated 宇宙 (Uchū) wrong.
Space Shook is not the correct translation.
The correct translation is either Outer Space Shook or Universe Trembled.
OK. That was bad on my end.I think you should have done that before making the blog or the crt. I hope I don't sound rude, but would have been more productive that way
But I agree, Yen Press translation is not the best.
Can you call in all the Sword Art Online supporters please?
Yen Press is not a translator. They have tons of translators, generally dedicated to specific series. Their bad reputation comes from the earlier volumes of some series, which got promptly changed up within a volume or two.But I agree, Yen Press translation is not the best.
Are you agreeing, neutral, or disagreeing with this CRT?Well, they do get the job done, but some of the changes I see in Toaru and Overlord are just plain terrible. But anyway, I won't derail anymore about the publisher.
Aside from the fact that you never asked me or anyone else due to what I can only imagine you do not want to add negative feedback to your post, you literally are in a position where you do not trust the translation you have in your hands that 3 separate (one of which is official) translators agree upon and request an on-site translation, yet force people to agree or disagree prematurely?Are you agreeing, neutral, or disagreeing with this CRT?
OK. That was my bad. I swear I forgot to ask you that.Aside from the fact that you never asked me or anyone else due to what I can only imagine you do not want to add negative feedback to your post
Neutral on the 4A stuff and no opinion on the country level stuff yet.Are you agreeing, neutral, or disagreeing with this CRT?
People seems to believe that nobody felt any shaking since the fight was top-secret. If you think about it very closely, what this quote truly means is that nobody believed that the girls that the Abyssal Horror was truly defeated because the fight was top-secret. If there was a quote that said people did not actually feel any shaking, then it would have been a total different story.
I wouldn't even say there is anything to contradict. Our own skyboxes in games are modeled after Milky Way too. We have constellations on our skyboxes. That is what a skybox is. And even what Kirito says is "it is not Milky Way".It also provides absolutely no evidence that it should be the size of the Milky way, in fact, that whole misconception was extrapolated by a very vague description given by Kirito, which is then immediately contradicted by Reki stating there are only two planets and a star in the underworld.
The author statement doesn't seem to be machine translated in the last thread, only in this one. Although it could have been machine translated and cleaned up, ig, but there isn't anything indicating that.Okay so I feel like people are ignoring that the author statement is translated via Google which brings into question the validity of that statement
It should be asked to be translated by our on-site translator
Furthermore there is no harm in waiting for the previous requested translation to be done first before moving forward with anything regarding this thread
You guys are ignoring I provided actual translations in the previous thread. Linked it twice or more in this thread for you to check too.Okay so I feel like people are ignoring that the author statement is translated via Google which brings into question the validity of that statement
It should be asked to be translated by our on-site translator
Furthermore there is no harm in waiting for the previous requested translation to be done first before moving forward with anything regarding this thread
I would rather wait for the supporters to reply as time zones exist. I have to log off as I have to do some irl stuff.Anyways, a discussion moderator can close this at their leisure. There aren't any new arguments here and if there were, the OP and others can try to actually back them up. But I have my strong doubts that they will.
One thing about this point I dont quite understand is the "top secret bit". What does the universe shaking have to do with the fight being a secret to others?From the Translation it rather feels like universe shaking was quite correct.About the incident being top secret,it would be very good if there was any evidence of the top secret thing being not revealed to normal people
The idea is that it's hard to have the entire universe noticeably shake without anyone noticing.One thing about this point I dont quite understand is the "top secret bit". What does the universe shaking have to do with the fight being a secret to others?
As in, why does the battle with AH being a secret means the universe can't shake? They seem like 2 unrelated points.
Nah, people are Basically using this as a fact.I mean in later vollume,it was said the whole fight was top secret.So if the universe shook it shouldn't be top secret.But that's where i have problems with.I meant it's not necessary for top secret things to be not revealed.So was there statement indicating that.What does the universe shaking have to do with the fight being a secret to others?
Using DBS is a terrible argument, the shookwave was shown to not affect Earth until it travel further, and the feat was way better than SAO as we many visual indicated of universe destruction as the shookwave did affect the entire universe even reaching the kaioshin realm and statement from reliable character like Old Kai who could observe the universe from his realmNah, people are Basically using this as a fact.I mean in later vollume,it was said the whole fight was top secret.So if the universe shook it shouldn't be top secret.But that's where i have problems with.I meant it's not necessary for top secret things to be not revealed.So was there statement indicating that.
Even in DBS,first fight between goku and beruus was creating shockwaves that has universal statement but normal Humans daily life was going normally.
Chill dude,i just used it as an example for humans knowing about the fight or not.Also not comparing the feats,dbs feat was pretty direct.Using DBS is a terrible argument, the shookwave was shown to not affect Earth until it travel further, and the feat was way better than SAO as we many visual indicated of universe destruction as the shookwave did affect the entire universe even reaching the kaioshin realm and statement from reliable character like Old Kai who could observe the universe from his realm
You know that the Cardinal System kinda does the same. Right?statement from reliable character like Old Kai who could observe the universe from his realm