Sonic General Discussion Zone Act 1: New Frontiers

[FaceOff81]

Sorry man. Can't help you, and even if I were to agree, it wouldn't do jackshit. I once made a CRT that got approved by official translators on the wiki, Ultima, and over 30 other users, and it still ended up rejected. These kinds of CRTs are very often kangaroo courts, and while Ultima is alright, I don't have any interest in debating him about this and I would rather push for Low 1-A at this point.

Elaborate on the Kangaroo Court specifics.

I’ll wait and see what he says in the future since I posted the Archie Continuity Cosmology blog to give him more context. I understand why he’s judging here being one of the main people for Tier 1-A and all of that, but I don’t think he knows a lot about any Sonic Cosmology like people here do. At the same time, I can’t blame him because he’s constantly having to look over other verses as well which can be a massive headache at times.

 

[Peptocoptr27]

Elaborate on the Kangaroo Court specifics.

I’ll wait and see what he says in the future since I posted the Archie Continuity Cosmology blog to give him more context. I understand why he’s judging here being one of the main people for Tier 1-A and all of that, but I don’t think he knows a lot about any Sonic Cosmology like people here do. At the same time, I can’t blame him because he’s constantly having to look over other verses as well which can be a massive headache at times.

Not gonna name anyone, but certain mods have egos too big to admit that they were wrong, even when faced with blatant evidence of such, and when those mods are classified as "experts" of certain series, there simply is no going against thier initial conclusion at all.

 

[Theuser789]

I don't know anything about tier 1 so I can't help, sorry.

 

[FaceOff81]

Not gonna name anyone, but certain mods have egos too big to admit that they were wrong, even when faced with blatant evidence of such, and when those mods are classified as "experts" of certain series, there simply is no going against thier initial conclusion at all.

I see. Very well then.

 

[Brogeefrong]

To note for the 1-A thread, it's actually not exactly going for QS per say, but more for Low 1-A/BDE Type 2. It's just so happens The Chaos Force, being a Type 1 Concept, makes those Low 1-A statements into 1-A

 

[MysticMania]

Hey, so, does anyone own a copy of the encyclospeedia or know where to find a scan where it talks about Sonic Boom? There is literally a page that says Sonic Boom takes place in an alternate universe. I'd like to have a decent quality scan or photo of it for a project I'm working on. (Shared cosmology babyyyyyyyyy)

I own it. I can look soon.

 

[MysticMania]

There's also several pieces of evidence in Archie, which is in the same cosmology as Boom, and by extension, the mainline games as well. Those pieces of evidence mostly come from scans I haven't been able to find, as well as references to concepts I'm not really educated about.

I don't think Archie and Mainline could share a multiverse. A cosmology, but, not multiverse. But I'm sorry if I'm misunderstanding.

 

[ShakeResounding]

@Peptocoptr27 Iirc the statement is from the 25th Anniversary Artbook that you're looking for

 

[FaceOff81]

To note for the 1-A thread, it's actually not exactly going for QS per se, but more for Low 1-A/BDE Type 2. It's just so happens The Chaos Force, being a Type 1 Concept, makes those Low 1-A statements into 1-A

That is something I completely agree with here especially after reviewing the already accepted Cosmology of Archie Sonic. This maybe just a me thing, but I’ve found Ultima’s reasoning contradictory to what has already been accepted in the cosmology along with going against already established guidelines on proving Low 1-A to 1-A. I get it. Each case is nuisanced especially when different verses are involved. This however seems like a situation where he’s missing context of how the cosmology was structured to begin with and how narratively specific word choice within each statement have shaped the cosmology itself.

 

[McFriesGuy075]

Not gonna name anyone, but certain mods have egos too big to admit that they were wrong, even when faced with blatant evidence of such, and when those mods are classified as "experts" of certain series, there simply is no going against thier initial conclusion at all.

Matthew?

 

[ShakeResounding]

Matthew?

Nah, name starts with a vowel

 

[Peptocoptr27]

@Peptocoptr27 Iirc the statement is from the 25th Anniversary Artbook that you're looking for

There's that too, but I did end up finding what I was talking about in the encyclospeedia. It turns out it's not as blatant of a statement as I remembered. However, thr fact that it's reffered to as a branch to Sonic's story on top of being in the encyclospeedia in the first place (when the purpose of it is to explore Sonic's world and lore) certainly implies they share a cosmology.

I don't think Archie and Mainline could share a multiverse. A cosmology, but, not multiverse. But I'm sorry if I'm misunderstanding.

A cosmology is what I'm saying.