- 225
- 35
First, the only thing right on the Isaac profile is his gender. Now starting....
Various things are wrong on Isaac profile. His name should be just "Isaac" and he shouldn't have separated keys just for alternative personalities. Maybe, only maybe, The Lost is a different character but hey, that's just a theory! Nevermind, Isaac shouldn't have the names of entire character list on different keys, could be just a explanation of Isaac having multiple personalities and each one being a different character on the game. His age is also bizarre, he have one key saying "Unknown" and another saying "Very Young (Is a kid)". He should just have written "Unknown (Is a young child)". Before we get on Powers and Abilities we need revise the keys, oh the keys....
"By Himself" and "With Every Item" is pretty confuse and controversial. First, what "By Himself" means? Without Mom's help? Without any of his items? If the definition of "By Himself" means "Without any item that Isaac doesn't start" it's wrong, his items are his and aren't any form of external help. Maybe "Emergency Contact" and "Broken Shovel" are external help (althrough I wouldn't say that Broken Shovel is a "help" anyway) but aside that, every one of items are his and just his. "By Himself" implies that he is getting some external help on the second key, but that isn't necessary true. About his second key.....I need to say, I don't know how got approved on the first place. Let's talk about this.
"With Every Item" is completly controversial. I will show how. Take two items, one is Soy Milk and Eve's Mascara one amplifies the firing rate but decreases the damage and another amplifies the damage but decreases the firing rate. How will you define the outcome of these two items combined? Will you add both items and take the result? Because "With Every Item" is basically taking the best parts of his abilities and removing the defects. On Isaac some items overrides others and get overridden by another. You can't just add both effects and say that's just how it works. Isaac secundary key is fundamentaly wrong and shouldn't be called the way is called. First, because Isaac is a permadeath game with semi-random map and items. Isaac can or not have some ability. He isn't a character that just stack up items and profit with that. Second, because his secundary key is literally a "Composite" with a different name. I have a suggestion but I need staff input before that.
Now about his "Powers and Abilities", there's various abilities missing or too vague. Take for example, "Invulnerability". How is someone supposed to know that Isaac have three different types of invulnerability and each one have completly different limits and conditions? I will list some examples of "vague" abilities and how misleading they can be.
Reality Warping and Data Manipulation: Isaac just bugs the sprites of the enemies and slow downs the music, with random tear upgrade. Just that.
Limited Absorption: He can absorb any type of item with The Void or The Melter. Doesn't states what he can absorb.
Power Mimicry: Literally where this come from?
Transformation: How works? He transforms on what? It's active or passive?
Sealing: I'm not even sure how this works.
Time Stop: He can't attack while the time is stopped.
Darkness Manipulation: Only works when he takes damage and can varie between items.
Now about missing abilities....
Non-Corporeal: Various items makes him a ghost and The Lost/The Soul is a ghost/soul respectively.
Self-Sustenance: All types, look at The Lost.
Immortality: He is supposed to have likely type 1 (The Lost is a soul and shouldn't age), Type 2 and Type 7 (??? and The Forgotten are undead and both have much more injuries than a normal human would withstand), Limited 4 (have various revive-inducing items and one always have a 50/50 chance of revive him) and Type 8 (Isaac's Heart makes him immortal and invulnerable while his heart still intact).
Anti Gravity : Self explanatory.
Gravity Manipulation: Tiny Planet.
Disease Manipulation: The Virus and Contagio.
Rage Power: Lusty Blood and Bloody Lust.
X-Ray Vision: Self explanatory.
Data Manipulation: While stated on his profile, it's written like was just by Dataminer while he have GB Bug and Undefined.
Aura: Succubus and Godhead.
And he also have this, but I'm unsure what is this.
For now, is this, maybe I will remember of one or another things to talk later.
Various things are wrong on Isaac profile. His name should be just "Isaac" and he shouldn't have separated keys just for alternative personalities. Maybe, only maybe, The Lost is a different character but hey, that's just a theory! Nevermind, Isaac shouldn't have the names of entire character list on different keys, could be just a explanation of Isaac having multiple personalities and each one being a different character on the game. His age is also bizarre, he have one key saying "Unknown" and another saying "Very Young (Is a kid)". He should just have written "Unknown (Is a young child)". Before we get on Powers and Abilities we need revise the keys, oh the keys....
"By Himself" and "With Every Item" is pretty confuse and controversial. First, what "By Himself" means? Without Mom's help? Without any of his items? If the definition of "By Himself" means "Without any item that Isaac doesn't start" it's wrong, his items are his and aren't any form of external help. Maybe "Emergency Contact" and "Broken Shovel" are external help (althrough I wouldn't say that Broken Shovel is a "help" anyway) but aside that, every one of items are his and just his. "By Himself" implies that he is getting some external help on the second key, but that isn't necessary true. About his second key.....I need to say, I don't know how got approved on the first place. Let's talk about this.
"With Every Item" is completly controversial. I will show how. Take two items, one is Soy Milk and Eve's Mascara one amplifies the firing rate but decreases the damage and another amplifies the damage but decreases the firing rate. How will you define the outcome of these two items combined? Will you add both items and take the result? Because "With Every Item" is basically taking the best parts of his abilities and removing the defects. On Isaac some items overrides others and get overridden by another. You can't just add both effects and say that's just how it works. Isaac secundary key is fundamentaly wrong and shouldn't be called the way is called. First, because Isaac is a permadeath game with semi-random map and items. Isaac can or not have some ability. He isn't a character that just stack up items and profit with that. Second, because his secundary key is literally a "Composite" with a different name. I have a suggestion but I need staff input before that.
Now about his "Powers and Abilities", there's various abilities missing or too vague. Take for example, "Invulnerability". How is someone supposed to know that Isaac have three different types of invulnerability and each one have completly different limits and conditions? I will list some examples of "vague" abilities and how misleading they can be.
Reality Warping and Data Manipulation: Isaac just bugs the sprites of the enemies and slow downs the music, with random tear upgrade. Just that.
Limited Absorption: He can absorb any type of item with The Void or The Melter. Doesn't states what he can absorb.
Power Mimicry: Literally where this come from?
Transformation: How works? He transforms on what? It's active or passive?
Sealing: I'm not even sure how this works.
Time Stop: He can't attack while the time is stopped.
Darkness Manipulation: Only works when he takes damage and can varie between items.
Now about missing abilities....
Non-Corporeal: Various items makes him a ghost and The Lost/The Soul is a ghost/soul respectively.
Self-Sustenance: All types, look at The Lost.
Immortality: He is supposed to have likely type 1 (The Lost is a soul and shouldn't age), Type 2 and Type 7 (??? and The Forgotten are undead and both have much more injuries than a normal human would withstand), Limited 4 (have various revive-inducing items and one always have a 50/50 chance of revive him) and Type 8 (Isaac's Heart makes him immortal and invulnerable while his heart still intact).
Anti Gravity : Self explanatory.
Gravity Manipulation: Tiny Planet.
Disease Manipulation: The Virus and Contagio.
Rage Power: Lusty Blood and Bloody Lust.
X-Ray Vision: Self explanatory.
Data Manipulation: While stated on his profile, it's written like was just by Dataminer while he have GB Bug and Undefined.
Aura: Succubus and Godhead.
And he also have this, but I'm unsure what is this.
For now, is this, maybe I will remember of one or another things to talk later.
