Scrooge McDuck VS Scrooge McDuck

[ZacharyGrossman273]

I made my name being tougher than the toughies and smarter than the smarters!

Both at 9-A
Scrooge Mcduck VS Scrooge McDuck

 

[Hazerddex]

why?

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

why?

Why not? I love this dudes thinking to make this thread. I feel this may be inconclusive, or the original Scrooge wins, due to likes of anger and much more whacky toon force.

 

[Zoxiver]

I agree with Magolor, the rebooted Scrooge doesn't seem as violent as the original Scrooge, so the point goes to Original Scrooge.

 

[KinkiestSins]

I dont know man, scrooge has a good chance to take this. But scrooge is also super rich.. Scrooge has more combat experience while scrooge is better with his mindset Scrooge can win, but scrooge can also take this.

 

[EMagoIorSouI]

I dont know man, scrooge has a good catch to take this.
But scrooge is also super rich.. Scrooge has more combat experience while scrooge is better with his mindset Scrooge can win, but scrooge can also take this.

I agree, Scrooge is stronger than Scrooge, but Scrooge is more atheletic than that Scrooge.

 

[Amelia_Lonelyheart]

We haven't seen much of Reboot Scrooge, but I agree with the others. So far he seems to be an explorer and adventurer first, fighter second. That said, we haven't really seen him in a situation where he can really go all out in a fit of anger just yet.

 

[Paulo.junior.969]

Going with the original, he has more feats and is faster.

 

[BattleReviews]

original via battle experience (its a cartoon canon vs a game canon, the game obviously would win because much more experience)

 

[MrKingOfNegativity]

Things like this are part of why I stick around this place.

Seriously though, OG Scrooge wins via feats alone. Dodging bullets at close range? Ripping apart smokestacks and destroying a cruise ship? Taking landmine explosions to the face? Tossing a coin across a river and then rowing a boat fast enough to catch it on the other side?

2017 Scrooge is like a cosplayer in comparison. Original Scrooge could beat him with nothing but his cane.

 

[Amelia_Lonelyheart]

Considering 2017 Ducktales is apparently going to be heavily based off the comics, we may just be blessed enough to see Scrooge perform some of the more insane feats in action.

 

[MrKingOfNegativity]

Lord, that would be great to see. The series has already been a fun ride so far. Having him pulling off his comic feats in-show would be the best.

Still though, when going with 2017 Scrooge in his current state, he's definitely outmatched.

 

[Dark649]

Considering 2017 Ducktales is apparently going to be heavily based off the comics.

About them, i have hundreds of them and by remembering the feats in them, it would lead to a massive revision of all the profiles that Magolor Soul presented, but i'm busy with a lot of other verses and it would take a lot of time to record all of them, so i will think about it much later.

 

[Hazerddex]

but if new scrooge the duck killed old scrooge the duck wouldn;t that kill new scrooge the duck? because then new scrooge the duck would not exists.


and is old scrooge the duck killing his potental future?

 

[Noahkaismith]

Scrooge wins.

 

[MrKingOfNegativity]

but if new scrooge the duck killed old scrooge the duck wouldn;t that kill new scrooge the duck? because then new scrooge the duck would not exists.

and is old scrooge the duck killing his potental future?

Late seeing this, but...

They're both from different continuities, so no to all of that.