- 1,034
- 231
No, it only damages his soul, the type of destruction described in that scene is to tear it apart, but it does not destroy it completely (or eliminate it completely).
Aiolia returned due to a temporary anomaly.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Saint Seiya Discussion Thread (IV)
- Thread starter TheUnshakableOne
- Start date
-
- Tags
- saint seiya
Aiolia returned due to a temporary anomaly.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
No, that’s not at all the correct interpretation.
- 6,358
- 2,408
Ok so I read a later chapter, and it wasn’t his souls arm shura chopped. Because aiolias willpoer and cosmo was resisting the control, zeus body overflowed into “an ethereal form“. That’s what shura chopped
- 1,034
- 231
That's what is said in the manga.
- 6,358
- 2,408
I just looked at the scan on a site, and it says “I destroyed his flesh and soul!”
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
The implication is clearly that the body and soul were destroyed at the same time. We do not see pieces of his body anywhere, so we know “tore to pieces” contextually means destroyed.
- 1,034
- 231
The type of destruction that the author describes in that scene is to tear an object into pieces, not to make it disappear completely, this is written differently in Japanese.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
And context tells us what happened and how to interpret the phrase.
- 1,034
- 231
Yes, damage his body and soul at the same time, but this does not mean that it made him disappear completely. This is the difference with the writing and the words that the author uses in the manga scene.
- 1,034
- 231
Yes, he damaged his body, that's why he changed his host. Like when the Gold Saints destroyed Andreas' body, but Loki survives because he switched to a new body at the right time.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
We know his body was completely destroyed. Otherwise there would be no need to take Aiolia’s body. Furthermore, we know that whatever happened to his body also happens to his soul. Since his body was no where to be seen, we can conclude that it was destroyed completely, so his soul should have also been destroyed in the same manner.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
For someone who’s vehemently against cross scaling, you seem to rely on it A LOT for all your arguments.
- 1,034
- 231
This is just one example.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
An example by your own standards shouldn’t be applied.
You’re consistently contradicting your own standards ALL THE TIME.
- 1,034
- 231
The gods in this franchise do not have such impressive regeneration, even damaging his body with some really serious injury was enough to force him to change hosts, although Aiolos describes in that scene that he was torn apart, so the body Zeus was using at the time took a lot of damage.
- 1,034
- 231
It's a quick example and it works for what we are describing at the moment.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
“ gods in this franchise”
but you’re against cross scaling? So what’s it matter if gods anywhere else can’t do it huh? Sounds like you need to cross scale to arrive at this conclusion.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
How’d a soul that’s been torn to pieces and killed take over Aiolia?
- 1,034
- 231
I am using the general description of the gods and what was shown in Episode.G where the gods do not have a great regeneration, even their avatar has never fully regenerated and Athena herself died decapitated by a sword.
Souls are not easy to destroy, this is not something new, even a part of a soul can take possession of an avatar.
Aiolos never says that Zeus' soul would disappear, he only says that the god would return to sleep in that scene.
- 6,358
- 2,408
Well yes.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
Ahh so you’re decontextualising everything again.
- 6,358
- 2,408
It’s likely a sacred relic sword or somethin. Also, Athena let herself get killed
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
The scene makes 0 sense under the interpretation Gods don’t have a fundamental being below their soul.
even in Classic Hades soul was destroyed, but we see his shadow form again in GA, as it’s intended to be more fundamental than the soul.
- 1,034
- 231
It is only a sword and nothing special is ever described about this weapon. The only weapon in the Sanctuary that can kill gods is the sword of Chrysus.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
Athena is a human who reincarnates.
This is what happens when you take stuff out of context, you end up with stupid interpretations like “gods die from their head being chopped off”
- 6,358
- 2,408
Def does seem like a ga thing
- 1,034
- 231
In Assassin it is never said that Hades' soul was destroyed and Hades himself cannot rebuild his body after it was destroyed.
The souls of the gods are difficult to destroy, but this does not mean that they can regenerate their bodies.
- 6,358
- 2,408
In the classic tho, his soul is destroyed, which should still hold in Ga
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
Again, GA is written as a sequel to Classic, separating them will get you no where.
we understand through Zeus that Hades’ soul was destroyed.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
Doesn’t have to be, it’s literally shown.
but GR does refer to the shadow forms as “divine spirits”
- 1,034
- 231
As a sequel that has several changes with the original manga, even Kanon is also alive and Radamanthys is alive, even though all the rosary beads changed color in the original manga.
The Underworld still exists in Assassin, even though it disappeared completely in the original manga with the death of Hades.
- 6,358
- 2,408
Possibly a result of the summoning spell I think
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
none of those "differences" arise to the level of contradiction when you actually understand the events that take place.
- 1,034
- 231
A different universe, even in the story this is indicated, and it is a story with some changes.
In the original manga the Underworld disappeared with the death of Hades, but in Assassin it did not disappear, this is because Athena does not destroy her soul in this universe and only destroys her body.
- 6,358
- 2,408
I actually think that’s LW rhad. Hear me out. The Saints in the Lw had a ceasefire with the underworld. And rhad does mention a ceasefire. Plus, the history of the Lw is very diff from normal
- 1,034
- 231
Kanon did not disappear like the others who were summoned and it is because he is part of that world.
Hasty12345
Username Only- 4,931
- 3,832
The UW was only ever shown to be crumbling, we never see it disappear.
