- 15,998
- 6,001
My apologies, but still, my point stands there was an instant disproportionate leap in punishment in Matt vs MGR.HR is for staff punishments. That’s why they’re called Human Resources
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
My apologies, but still, my point stands there was an instant disproportionate leap in punishment in Matt vs MGR.HR is for staff punishments. That’s why they’re called Human Resources
To be fair I personally was happy with some amount of ban time for both LordGinSama and Matthew, but I didn't want to post on it and push for it when it looked like things were calming down on the thread.My apologies, but still, my point stands there was an instant disproportionate leap in punishment in Matt vs MGR.
Whether he helped for 2 or 4 years, that's irrelevant. What he did was against Fandom rules as a whole, as stated by DDM, so his run time on the wiki has no weight whatsoever.Matthew has helped out a massive amount over the years, so he has more leeway than a new member who has not helped out at all, but I also think that he stepped over the line above, and removed his remaining posts.
Ant, no amount of work over fictional characters can even compare to accusing someone of racism and child pornography. If things like that continue to slide, people are going to detest and distrust the moderators even more.Matthew has helped out a massive amount over the years, so he has more leeway than a new member who has not helped out at all, but I also think that he stepped over the line above, and removed his remaining posts.
That’s fine, I’m just pointing out there is a clear difference between who gets punished vs pinched.To be fair I personally was happy with some amount of ban time for both LordGinSama and Matthew, but I didn't want to post on it and push for it when it looked like things were calming down on the thread.
MGR and his punishment is a new issue.
Okay, but all I’m saying is what are they going to do him? MGR was about to get banned for essentially saying the wiki sucked, but accusing someone of racism and supporting CP will never compare.@Milly_Rocking_Bandit both cases are not the same. For Matt, the information already reached the HR group but most people were asleep at the time. On the other hand, MGR's case blatantly implies that he has no intention of shaping up or being useful to the community.
I understand where this argument is coming from, but I feel it is just used too frequently and excessively to ignore. All this should demonstrate is nothing more than the fact that they have examples of being a helpful individual and may be generally more trustworthy than the other person in this situation, not that they should be free of blame or punishment for serious actions.Matthew has helped out a massive amount over the years, so he has more leeway than a new member who has not helped out at all, but I also think that he stepped over the line above, and removed his remaining posts.
I obviously agree that it is not acceptable, yes. Matthew has placed us in a very bad position here.Ant, no amount of work over fictional characters can even compare to accusing someone of racism and child pornography. If things like that continue to slide, people are going to detest and distrust the moderators even more.
I think you severely misinterpreted what DDM said. He was just referring to uploading such scans on other platform.What he did was against Fandom rules as a whole
I know exactly what you mean, I’ll explain it for others since I’m always on this thread.My apologies, but still, my point stands there was an instant disproportionate leap in punishment in Matt vs MGR.
That doesn't change what I said either way. He still broke fandom rules.I think you severely misinterpreted what DDM said. He was just referring to uploading such scans on other platform.
All I’m saying is, whatever happens to Matthew (out of my judgement), should be given some intensive thought. The state of this wiki is very fragile at the moment, and many members are unhappy. The outcome of it could cause a lot of unrest.I obviously agree that it is not acceptable, yes. Matthew has placed us in a very bad position here.
That said, I have talked with Lina a lot over the years, and he does have a history of being mentally unstable and rather paranoid, but then so do I, and neither of us are remotely Nazis because of that.
I come from a time where we actually had a template for this things instead of eyeballing everything, nor was I even told I had to do multiple of the things he said, but yes, I can.
i have not seen any CTR and also the tier key is still on 5-AWasn't that because the feat was calced at multi-continental instead of planetary?
this user https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User:Dark-Carioca change this profile https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/Tso_Lan (erased planetary and put multi-continental instead)