-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Root changes and possible High 1-A upgrade
- Thread starter BasedNecoScaler69
- Start date
- Status
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
I mean, yeah, but he would have to argue why these concepts are all 1-A in the first place.
- 18,393
- 14,323
* platonic concepts *
- 12,802
- 5,928
outerversal confirmed
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Should work only if properly explained and if it meets the standards
.
AizenSosuke
He/Him- 60
- 23
Agrees
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #47
These concepts are already stated to be 1-A by the work itself, im not talking about every concept in the nasuverse, just the ones regarding "「 」" like concepts
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #48
1A+ is literally infinitely above baseline 1-A, which an infinite amount satifies
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #49
These screenshots, which are accepted by the vsbw
dont talk about "「 」", and therfore, arent "「 」", so my point still stands
dont talk about "「 」", and therfore, arent "「 」", so my point still stands
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #50
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Where exactly ? It would greatly help your OP if you posted such scans.
No. The Root is apophatic to the whole verse and is inaccessible/ineffable to everything else as such. In that case, it would be completely inaccessible to already 1-A concepts thus making it High 1-A, as someone else said above :
And these concepts, while accepted as 1-A when all put together, are also accepted to be the Root itself, therefore making it 1-A.
You'd have to prove that "「 」" is a separate, higher thing than these.
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #52
the original work already says it is seperate, though nothing on if its higher, but by default knowledge of how the cosmology works, they have to be on a lower plane than「 」. the currently accepted description in the vsbw wiki also supports this
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #53
The only character in verse that is capable of giving a true description of 「 」 is possibly ryougi
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Okay then are you saying that since the concepts that are being attributed to 「 」are already accepted as 1-A, it should be tiered higher since it automatically exists above all definitions and logics that we give it ? Is that your proposition ?
In this case, it would be High 1-A and not 1-A, as I said earlier.
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #55
Yea, thats what im trying to say here
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Alright, that looks better than before, I'm changing to neutral for now.
I'd advise you to edit your OP a bit and use that instead.
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
Like I said before,「 」being High 1A based on all the scans shown so far makes much more sense than root being 1A+ cuz nothing really implies infinitely layered 1A concepts. Only infinite amounts of 1A concepts being unreachable to 「 」
If it's for High 1A, I agree with the CRT
If it's for 1A+ I disagree with the CRT.
If it's for High 1A, I agree with the CRT
If it's for 1A+ I disagree with the CRT.
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #58
done.
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #59
it might even be an aleph-2 amount of 1-A concepts. The original idea i had for this thread was an H1-A change, but i wasnt so sure
- 842
- 511
I'm pretty sure platonic concepts don't scaleShould work only if properly explained and if it meets the standards
But the ontological nature of forms is that they are aspatial and atemporal, absolute/pure (colloquially denoted as immaterial and unchangeable) and are that which things of the material world exemplify properties from them
The origin does meet all of those criterias but I doubt it would scale forms don't scale anymore in the wiki which it should but the wiki is the wiki
The origin comes directly from the root I think that's what he is using to infer it being 1-A but I don't know why is he still pushing this he should just wait for me to make a high 1-A crt with better arguments than this
Which concepts again? There are no concepts that are the root itself that contradicts the nature of the root it seems to me alot of people here have trouble understanding negative theology
Separate to what? It's descriptions and everything in the verse? Yes it is
The symbol that you're using already entails it being above that which is separate from already and yes everything in the nasuverse would be not on a lower plane but ontological greater than that it's not a matter of planes but a matter of ontology
No she can't there's no true description of it, it can't be described that again contradicts its nature ryougi was inside of it and she still couldn't describe it, that's its nature even a person connected to it can only describe it as being indescribable i
I suppose if you want it to be high 1-A I'll present some scans and the argument for that a little bit later to help with the CRT
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #61
Spiral of Origin, the root, Maelstrom of origins,Akashic Records, Source Maelstrom
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #63
The only counter argument ive seen is " hurdur they're the same concept" which is pretty much debunked by the work itself
they cannot be the exact same concept, because「 」is meant to be indescribable. Any concept in the nasuverse is automatically a part of 「 」.
- 842
- 511
Oh ye then it does exist beyond that
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #65
Yeah i said possibly because she's an avatar of it, so she has the most accurate definition
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #66
Yea, pretty much any attempt to name 「 」or describe 「 」 is moot, its emptiness
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Yes, I know that, which is why those concepts qualify for 1-A only if properly elaborated on and if they meet the required standards for the tier.
Fine, this CRT badly started so it would probably be better.
No. What I meant is that all the definitions, conceptions, descriptions etc that you apply to 「 」are automatically below it because of its apophatic nature ; which is why it would make 「 」High 1-A if said definitions/conceptions are already 1-A by themselves. But I'm not entirely sure of its validity for some reasons, thats why I'm staying neutral for now.
Yes, that's what I meant and agree with.
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #68
what makes you unsure?
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
The definitions/concepts we are already accepting as 1-A are also heavily supported by negative theology and inaccessible transcendance over the rest of the verse. It would mean that we're scaling 「 」to High 1-A via negative theology off of negative theology, which is weird when you think about it.
But anyways that's not really that big of a problem and I'll stay neutral until further input.
- 292
- 123
Can you write to the staff to make the thread more specific? if they join, it won't be anything that stops this thread (I'll probably join too, lol)
- 3,346
- 1,912
- Thread starter
- #71
Not really weird if you think about it, just that lower level beings cant describe it in its entirety.
Maxeez
He/Him- 499
- 197
Probably, that's why I'm not disagreeing nor am I fully agreeing for now. I'm leaning towards agreeing but would rather wait for more people to voice out their opinion on that matter.
- 842
- 511
My justification for the root being high 1-A goes as follows starting with this scan to which I elaborate on from there
The root is directly implied to unreachable through a stacking of infinities
I know people have a problem interpreting stuff properly so I'll explain better as to how this is implied
"the concept of infinity is twinned with the concept of finite existence. It is this finite existence, this is end of all things that shiki ryougi observes with her arcane eyes, and the same end that she cuts to make entropy act quickly almost immediately. The prison she was contained in was made to be infinite, an inconceivable non-Euclidean space"
This explains how conventional infinity has limits
Actual infinity is completed as a collection, the idea is further extrapolated on using the analogy of an non-Euclidean space which is still an infinite space but with limits because for any dimension X it would be infinite but the limit comes from the next dimension which is a directly higher infinity
So for 2 dimensions it would be infinity^infinity in hyperbolic geometry/non Euclidean geometry and the idea is carried on to any dimension up to 1-A+ the arithmetic and principle stays the same all the way up to 1-A+ the limit of the infinity relative to the the first dimension would be infinity|^infinity, it can't reach the second dimension which is a higher infinity
As you know powersetting one infinity to reach another is an arithmetic operation that carries on all the way up to 1-A+ as well and powersetting a set of natural numbers is 2^n or infinity^infinity which is still a similar arithmetic to the hyperbolic geometry stacking of any dimension X take 2 dimensions for now being infinity^infinity
Getting into to the root in comparison which it is said that
"the only denial of end that exists is the true nothingness of " "."
Essentially what this means is that the root distinct from such infinities and with the arithmetic operations used in those infinity cannot be used on the root, this is why infinities that use arithmetic operations of infinity^infinity can be cut by shiki ryougi who can perceive the end of such infinities due to her eyes being connected to the root which is an infinity of a fundamentally greater scale to such infinities and why for her such infinities are only small rooms as said "to this girl, the space was nothing more than a room with its door unbarred and unguarded"
This makes it clear cut that the root would be ontologically equivalent to the inaccessible cardinal in magnitude and should be high 1-A
Furthermore the origin is accepted to exist within the root and should be 1-A as such we've already had people like roa who is accepted as having a 1-A soul that exists within the root from which he can reincarnate from
The ontological nature of the root would exists inaccessibly greater than such baseline 1-A things and should be more supporting evidence for it being high 1-A
The root is directly implied to unreachable through a stacking of infinities
I know people have a problem interpreting stuff properly so I'll explain better as to how this is implied
"the concept of infinity is twinned with the concept of finite existence. It is this finite existence, this is end of all things that shiki ryougi observes with her arcane eyes, and the same end that she cuts to make entropy act quickly almost immediately. The prison she was contained in was made to be infinite, an inconceivable non-Euclidean space"
This explains how conventional infinity has limits
Actual infinity is completed as a collection, the idea is further extrapolated on using the analogy of an non-Euclidean space which is still an infinite space but with limits because for any dimension X it would be infinite but the limit comes from the next dimension which is a directly higher infinity
So for 2 dimensions it would be infinity^infinity in hyperbolic geometry/non Euclidean geometry and the idea is carried on to any dimension up to 1-A+ the arithmetic and principle stays the same all the way up to 1-A+ the limit of the infinity relative to the the first dimension would be infinity|^infinity, it can't reach the second dimension which is a higher infinity
As you know powersetting one infinity to reach another is an arithmetic operation that carries on all the way up to 1-A+ as well and powersetting a set of natural numbers is 2^n or infinity^infinity which is still a similar arithmetic to the hyperbolic geometry stacking of any dimension X take 2 dimensions for now being infinity^infinity
Getting into to the root in comparison which it is said that
"the only denial of end that exists is the true nothingness of " "."
Essentially what this means is that the root distinct from such infinities and with the arithmetic operations used in those infinity cannot be used on the root, this is why infinities that use arithmetic operations of infinity^infinity can be cut by shiki ryougi who can perceive the end of such infinities due to her eyes being connected to the root which is an infinity of a fundamentally greater scale to such infinities and why for her such infinities are only small rooms as said "to this girl, the space was nothing more than a room with its door unbarred and unguarded"
This makes it clear cut that the root would be ontologically equivalent to the inaccessible cardinal in magnitude and should be high 1-A
Furthermore the origin is accepted to exist within the root and should be 1-A as such we've already had people like roa who is accepted as having a 1-A soul that exists within the root from which he can reincarnate from
The ontological nature of the root would exists inaccessibly greater than such baseline 1-A things and should be more supporting evidence for it being high 1-A
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
I agree. Although, you should probably start your own crt since this crt is already falling into shambles.
- 292
- 123
Can't the OP change the scale he wrote and put it on? or it may make more sense to open a new sequel title
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
It would make more sense to open a new one imo.
- 842
- 511
You can remove me from here I agree now that it's high 1-A I disagreed with 1-A+ especially with the reasons for it
- 842
- 511
Bruh I don't feel like writing allat again it's a pain
Tdjwo
He/Him- 3,180
- 1,299
Alright. Should I help creating the CRT myself then?
- Status
