• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Removing CM1 from Aeons (Honkai: Star Rail)

Status
Not open for further replies.
well a simple read on the imaginary blog tells you that the imaginary governs everything, which includes a conceptual mindscape
For some reason I don’t trust this interpretation. Also, you can have IM2 for CM3. It sounds weird but there’s no issue here because IM2 is absurdly broad. It can have CM3 in an indirect sense though.

how are the aeons controlling a certain part of imaginary = same thing, neither those are cm1 when cm1 requirement is to govern a part of reality and that's it, like do I have to quote it
That’s not CM1. At all.

yeah but according to your logic, you won't get cm1 unless you're manipulating the sequence down to the conceptual level, when the sequence itself is already conceptual so you know how this just doesn't make sense at all
You can’t manipulate a Pathway’s concepts without the Authority or Symbolism.
 
Translation: “You haven’t read the series so now you must accept any wank I tell you about.”

Also, do you believe all Imaginary Energy is equally CM1?
All Imaginary Energy is CM1.
So are those cannons the IPC uses to destroy planets CM1? What about all Pathstriders, they got CM1 too? Why not HSR atoms atp? They naturally interact with Imaginary Energy as well. Also what about when Imaginary stuff leaves Imaginary Space and becomes Real? Is that something CM1 transforming into a physical object?
Yes. Concept 1 NPI, but not straight-up CM1.
Do you even realize how ridiculous your position sounds?
No one really asked for your own personal opinion that is only comprehensive within your own personal perspective.
 
Energy too, since both of them are quantities, while universals are qualities.
Being energy isn't really an anti-feat, unless it is actual physical energy. It is entirely depends on how the verse portrays it

Hmm, anyway, still reading both this thread and the blog. I already disagreed with the conceptual domain thing already, since it is just Otto talking about him conceptualized on the model of the cosmology for reference, not a literal conceptual world
 
Hmm, anyway, still reading both this thread and the blog. I already disagreed with the conceptual domain thing already, since it is just Otto talking about him conceptualized on the model of the cosmology for reference, not a literal conceptual world
There are scans on cosmology page that says it is a non-existent domain without any real meaning.
 
There are scans on cosmology page that says it is a non-existent domain without any real meaning.
Undimensioned domain???, oke, no more 1-B i guess. Idk how this is relevant to the discussion
 
Undimensioned domain???, oke, no more 1-B i guess. Idk how this is relevant to the discussion
1-B defines a structure that is equivalent to a 12-D to N-D universe. That does not mean it needs to strictly mean a 12-D to N-D physical space-time itself. As for how what I said is relevant to the discussion, you said that the Imaginary Tree isn't a conceptual domain, but Imaginary Space is fundamentally non-existent, and it does not contain any space nor time.
 
1-B defines a structure that is equivalent to a 12-D to N-D universe. That does not mean it needs to strictly mean a 12-D to N-D physical space-time itself. As for how what I said is relevant to the discussion, you said that the Imaginary Tree isn't a conceptual domain, but Imaginary Space is fundamentally non-existent, and it does not contain any space nor time.
I still don't see how this relevant to the discussion, you claimed it is a conceptual domain, now it is a nonexistent domain and it does not contain any space nor time, mean it is undimensioned (don't have any dimensions at all), but currently it is 12-D mean it must have dimensions. Do you see how contradictory your claims is?. Nonexistent have nothing to do with concept, and it being nonexistent contradicting the current 12-D rating it have
 
I still don't see how this relevant to the discussion, you claimed it is a conceptual domain, now it is a nonexistent domain and it does not contain any space nor time, mean it is undimensioned (don't have any dimensions at all), but currently it is 12-D mean it must have dimensions. Do you see how contradictory your claims is?. Nonexistent have nothing to do with concept, and it being nonexistent contradicting the current 12-D rating it have
The writers themselves putted statements that it does not contain space nor time, a domain devoid without any meaning. Its abstract, non-existent from reality, and governs everything, then that is enough to be a type 1 concept. The Imaginary Tree is 12-D in-nature but that doesn't mean it needs to have space and time. Just like how the World of Void in Dragon Ball is still 5-D in nature but it doesn't have space nor time either.
 
Being energy isn't really an anti-feat
Honestly Idk how you reconcile this for CM1 without a shittload of context to make it some extraordinarily esoteric form of “energy” (which wouldn’t even be energy in any proper sense).
 
Honestly Idk how you reconcile this for CM1 without a shittload of context to make it some extraordinarily esoteric form of “energy” (which wouldn’t even be energy in any proper sense).
Fictional energy goes bruhhhhhhh. But anyway sure i guess, though i disagree with the notion that seeing the name energy drop automatically make it an anti-feat against concept, still really depends on context

The writers themselves putted statements that it does not contain space nor time, a domain devoid without any meaning. Its abstract, non-existent from reality, and governs everything, then that is enough to be a type 1 concept. The Imaginary Tree is 12-D in-nature but that doesn't mean it needs to have space and time. Just like how the World of Void in Dragon Ball is still 5-D in nature but it doesn't have space nor time either.
WoV isn't 5D, it is Undimensioned, untiered

About it being abstract, i thing i already explained so.....
 
Fictional energy goes bruhhhhhhh. But anyway sure i guess, though i disagree with the notion that seeing the name energy drop automatically make it an anti-feat against concept, still really depends on context
I was never against Imaginary Energy being CM1 cuz of its name…. But it literally acts like energy, in every way energy acts like energy lol. The Astral Express literally uses the Path Energy for fuel ☠️
 
@ActuallySpaceMan42 @FinePoint @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless @Qawsedf234

It’s why they move so much because they gain energy through trailblazing

so any conclusions on your end? Also could u tag some mods, I’ve alr written on their message boards but none of then have responded in over a month…
So assume this go through, what will get affected by this thread?, because from what i see Imaginary Energy is CM1 and there is Soul being CM1 too with different reason if i'm not wrong
 
the entire hoyo cosmology explains why imaginary itself is cm1 and no one used it in any sort of argument
 
@ActuallySpaceMan42 @FinePoint @Oblivion_Of_The_Endless @Qawsedf234


So assume this go through, what will get affected by this thread?, because from what i see Imaginary Energy is CM1 and there is Soul being CM1 too with different reason if i'm not wrong
Well anything that is derived from Imaginary Energy will get downgraded to CM3. Souls have even less proof for CM1 and I believe I already mentioned why it’s not. (Hint: It’s quite literally IM2, like, it specifically states it as “containing information” as well)

Now we can try and debunk that in this thread as well but if you want I can js open a second one for it regardless
 
the entire hoyo cosmology explains why imaginary itself is cm1 and no one used it in any sort of argument
I explained it here with the entire Kiana & Sirin stuff but everyone just ignores that lol
Well anything that is derived from Imaginary Energy will get downgraded to CM3. Souls have even less proof for CM1 and I believe I already mentioned why it’s not. (Hint: It’s quite literally IM2, like, it specifically states it as “containing information” as well)

Now we can try and debunk that in this thread as well but if you want I can js open a second one for it regardless
Imaginary Energy is universal, there's no reason for it to be CM3 when it's literally more fundamental than whatever concepts that's perceived by the Erudition that's already a type 2 concept on its own since matter makes up reality. I'd say a higher degree of CM2
 
This hypothetical “Imaginary Universal” is what I’ve been debunking the whole thread mannnn.
How the hell is the Imaginary not universal but Genshin one is somehow universal when you know, Genshin takes place in the Imaginary Tree lol
 
The Astral Express literally uses the Path Energy for fuel ☠️
this is literally a physical energy bro, how can it use conceptual as fuel? , In my opinion, it seems we should differentiate between the path concept and path energy, so not all path users will get CM1
 
How the hell is the Imaginary not universal but Genshin one is somehow universal when you know, Genshin takes place in the Imaginary Tree lol
I’m on record MULTIPLE times saying I disagree with genshin CM bro. But if you genuinely want to upscale everyone to CM2 through Genshin you’re more than welcome cuz I ain’t touching that shithole
 
this is literally a physical energy bro, how can it use conceptual as fuel? , In my opinion, it seems we should differentiate between the path concept and path energy, so not all path users will get CM1
Path Energy isn't even physical, we all know it's metaphysical in nature c'mon
 
I’m on record MULTIPLE times saying I disagree with genshin CM bro. But if you genuinely want to upscale everyone to CM2 through Genshin you’re more than welcome cuz I ain’t touching that shithole
Alright fine by me bro, Ena's law is universal anyway so I'll scale it off that since Phanes one is universal and that's how it got accepted

My next CRT if this passes genuinely
 
theres ******* text upon text explaining this shit bro... (Theres even more lol).
this is literally a physical energy bro, how can it use conceptual as fuel?
cause its not a literal fuel but a way to bypass imaginary barriers and get from star system to star system, literally used to travel across imaginary.
 
How the hell is the Imaginary not universal but Genshin one is somehow universal when you know, Genshin takes place in the Imaginary Tree lol
Universal mean the whole of something, the leyline being conceptual and affect the entirety of Genshin world make it Universal within Genshin world.
 
Predate ≠ independent

Well, to be honest actually. Finality is the source of all Honkai-related phenomena in the world so we could equate Honkai's characteristics to Finality technically. But that's not the main argument here, the main argument about Finality is that the Cocoon of Finality itself could catalyze the Herrscher of Finality using Imaginary Energy. Herrschers are stated to be "pure concepts" that is derived from the imaginary concept. There's not really a single scan in Honkai saying that time predates Finality itself, I think everyone who's knowledgeable about Honkai understands this.

Through the Imaginary, one can add Imaginary properties to objects to make them Imaginary by abstracting it, or Kiana destroying Imaginary itself to destroy the Imaginary authority and an Imaginary Space. Honkai Energy is basically Imaginary internal energy, the powersource of the Cocoon of Finality is technically Imaginary Energy anyway.

All Herrschers, simply put are just projections of Finality. Which means, the Herrschers that are "pure concepts" are just well: Projections for Finality to manifest in the first place.

So, the full context is like: Herrschers are imaginary concepts, they're born through Imaginary Energy as abstract concepts that are independent from their own. This is why the Herrscher of Finality, who has authority over time is unaffected by time. Because it was explained that Herrschers are independent from their own authority, to be more precise. This is like shown with how Divine Keys cannot harness the same power as Herrscher, but Herrscher are able to do that with their own respective Divine Keys.

So, Herrscher's ability to manipulate higher-dimensional realm, it also can be used to manipulate time hence the entire manipulating time ≠ manipulating Finality stuff. Time itself is a primordial abstract concept that acts as a sequence and causality basically. Time also has its own concepts and laws, which is something that's outside of the universe (Yes, world here is universe by the way but I don't think it matters much for concept manip).

Now, Paths are just congregations of Imaginary Energy. It'd be more precise if Path is CM1 and it's respective Aeon because it's just congregations of Imaginary Energy tbh.

That's the entire explanation.
this one literally sums up the IMG energy=phyiscal energy shit
Not to mention you ALWAYS use imaginary energy by drawing the power from an conceptual creature gazing at your ass aka Aeon.
Hence why entire phainon feat happened using path of destruction and not physically boxing nanook.
 
This is Imaginary Energy fighting Imaginary Energy.

Universal mean the whole of something, the leyline being conceptual and affect the entirety of Genshin world make it Universal within Genshin world.
Leylines merely transport information and elements (which are the actual building blocks). It’s a CM3 pathway that specifically transports IM2. I will never agree on CM2 for this, even “limited”
 
Universal mean the whole of something, the leyline being conceptual and affect the entirety of Genshin world make it Universal within Genshin world.
Yeah but a quick look at the Imaginary would tell you already that the Imaginary shapes and makes up everything in Honkaiverse
 
That’s for concepts (singular), Imaginary Energy is a quantity of a certain substance. Please do read what the other parts of that description says; you can’t prove something with a half-assed defintion
I didnt even mention imaginary energy here, just imaginary itself lmao. read the blog dude
 
I didnt even mention imaginary energy here, just imaginary itself lmao. read the blog dude
There is no distinction between “Imaginary” and “Imaginary Energy”. Philosophical Concept = Path = Path Energy = Imaginary Energy = “this part of the Imaginary” (going from Welt’s statement)
 
There is no distinction between “Imaginary” and “Imaginary Energy”. Philosophical Concept = Path = Path Energy = Imaginary Energy = “this part of the Imaginary” (going from Welt’s statement)
The Imaginary predates, creates and shapes up all of creation itself; it is a primordial concept that constitutes of the reality-transcending conceptual domain that are built above layers of rules, the origin of all law and order, incarnation of truth itself -- the Imaginary Tree.

The Imaginary Tree governs absolutely everything, ranging from mere individual objects, such as Sirin's subspace lances, and all the way up to the Imaginary Space, the conceptual domain that shapes up utterly everything across the Honkai metaverse.
Its literally here, From imaginary itsef we got its energy, paths, aeons, IT, SoQ, civilizations, literally everything in the verse
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top